Thus far, there have been just eight confirmed cases of Ebola in the United States following an outbreak in West Africa. Far more contagious here has been a new virus of hysteria — and of the sort of ignorant discrimination that immigrants in general and Africans specifically have endured for decades.
People are being shunned and mocked for having visited, or even for simply having been born in, Africa — and anywhere in Africa will do, afflicted with Ebola or not. Others face discrimination simply for living in the same neighborhood where a single Ebola patient once lived. Politicians and pundits have seriously discussed closing our borders to entire nations. Panic is dividing the country at a time when the U.S. and indeed the whole world needs to pull together to solve a viral health crisis.
Early signs of Ebola hysteria came after Liberian Thomas Duncan became the first person in the U.S. reported to have the disease a few weeks ago. Even before Duncan died from Ebola, immigrants who lived in his Dallas, Texas neighborhood faced discrimination and other forms of disrespect. They were turned away from local jobs, stores, and restaurants, while frightened tutors refused to work with their children.
Sixty miles southeast of Dallas, Navarro College earlier this month denied admission to two Nigerian students, not because they were diagnosed with Ebola but simply because they were from a country stricken by the disease. Never mind that Nigeria did a remarkable job in containing Ebola, went six weeks without new cases, and this week was declared Ebola free by the World Health Organization.
Such racial embarrassments aren’t confined to Texas. The week before last in Nazareth, Pennsylvania, a Guinean high school soccer player from Nazareth Area High School was subjected to chants of “Ebola” from opposing players on rival Northampton High School’s team. The chants left him in tears. Northampton’s head and assistant coach have since resigned from their positions and disciplinary action against the heckling players is pending. Meanwhile, a few parents in Mississippi decided to pull their children from a middle school after discovering the school’s principal returned from a trip to Zambia, a country nowhere near the Ebola outbreak.
Liberia’s immigrant population in Staten Island, New York, reportedly the largest outside of Liberia, is also subject to unfortunate discrimination thanks to Ebola. “When they see you’re African, they’re kind of afraid to even shake your hands, you know, to talk with you and stuff,” one Liberian male told NY1. Another man said that while doing his school’s physical, the examiners “had to pull me, isolate me, ask me questions like how long I been here, just from knowing that I’m from Liberia,” according to the news channel.
The Village Voice awkwardly added to the stereotypes last week. A story about how the Ebola panic affected the Nigerian Independence Day Parade was headlined “Cloudy With a Chance of Ebola?” The piece, apparently written by a writer of Nigerian descent, was a generally thoughtful exploration of the intersection of ignorance, nationality, and health concerns, but commenters could not get past the headline, which was criticized as “disrespectful,” “stupid,” “ignorant,” “offensive,” “despicable,” “racist,” and worse.
More worrisome than grassroots Ebola hysteria are the calls for official national security policies rooted in the same sort of ignorance. Rep. Fred Upton (R-Michigan) is among those in favor of a ban on travel to and from countries stricken with Ebola outbreaks. “No, you’re not coming here, not until this situation is solved in Africa ,” Upton said recently. “We should not be allowing these folks in, period.” Talk-show host and noted icon of religious tolerance Bill Maher has also thrown his support behind the idea of national quarantines.
Center for Disease Control and Prevention Director Tom Frieden has done his best to try and combat this sort of hysteria with facts. “We don’t want to isolate parts of the world, or people who aren’t sick, because that’s going to drive patients with Ebola underground, making it infinitely more difficult to address the outbreak,” Frieden wrote in a blog entry last week. Charity organization Doctors Without Borders also poured cold water on any national lockdown ideas last month, saying that a ban placed on Sierra Leone would not prevent Ebola from spreading.
That sort of educational outreach is sorely needed right now. Spouting racist chants, discriminating against entire neighborhoods, nations, and continents, and isolating whole countries will only create unnecessary division around a health problem that requires a unified response.
Photo: Tony Gutierrez/AP
Ebola Racism? Nahhh…Fear & Folly Replacing Leadership Is More Like It.
http://dougbiviano.com/index.php/press-releases/19-ebola-racism
Malevolent people use whatever there is in their reach to act out their hatred. They are just pernicious. As grim as they are, they lack any sense of humor. The word play in the headline “Nigerian Independence Day Parade 2014: Cloudy With a Chance of Ebola?” – they just don’t get it, because it sheds light on their narrow mindedness.
Link given in the article:
http://blogs.villagevoice.com/runninscared/2014/10/nigerian_independence_day_parade_2014_cloudy_with_a_chance_of_ebola.php?utm_content=buffer346a8&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter.com&utm_campaign=buffer
Reality over & over again confirms Alice Miller’s works:
http://www.psych.yorku.ca/eavitzur/documents/Dramaofthegiftedchild.pdf
http://www.arvindguptatoys.com/arvindgupta/alicemiller.pdf
There are more than two points of view here. I think it’s sad and wrong that people are being turned away from jobs because they are from Africa due to xenophobic paranoia, but I also do not believe that travel restrictions are useless in this case. There is still no preventative measure for Ebola other than quarantine, and due to the way it attacks white cells and lymph nodes it can be very difficult to treat, which leads to the frequent fatalities among medical staff. There have been only 8 cases in the U.S. Wonderful. We are fortunate we do not have thousands of cases like Liberia; Thomas Duncan’s treatment involved 76 people, and he died anyway. I say we are _fortunate_. Ebola is not a “brown-person disease”. It has no cultural bias, and CDC’s assertion that the spread in Liberia is due to local burial customs is at the very least condescending; after Duncan was taken to an American hospital, the virus still spread at the expected rate to two of the nurses caring for him. The particular strain spreading in Liberia is different in some ways from strains previously studied, and there is reason to believe the viral load (and thus, the likelihood of spread) is higher this time. We should not make mistake our good fortune for inevitability; there is nothing inherent in the virus or in ourselves that prevents it from spreading here.
I agree that there is a lot of misinformation and hysteria out there. 8 cases isn’t a lot yet, and there is still time to develop either a vaccine for the disease, or a reliable treatment for its immunogenic effects. However, we are going to have to play for time, and the R0 of this disease is around 2 at this time, with around a 50% mortality rate. A sensible set of travel restrictions are going to be necessary to slow it down before new treatments are available, otherwise nonsense ad-hoc restrictions will be implemented all over the place, to everyone’s detriment. When I say sensible travel restrictions, I do not mean to say a thermometer and a questionnaire.
I was curious to read in the newspapers today that the authorities are clueless about how to find out the names off the people who were in contact with the doctor in New York who has contacted Ebola. The answer is surprisingly simple. NSA can, using one of their myraid snooping tools, within seconds identify all owners of cellphones who were in close proximity to the doctor’s cellphone. This is one use that NSA can cite with pride and justify the billions they spend.
Ebola hysteria is spreading faster than the virus itself, creating a climate of fear mongering, misinformation and intolerance. Along with calls for travel restrictions and border closures, the panicked reactions resemble another viral epidemic of nearly a century ago, the polio virus of 1916 that hit an unprepared NYC. Like the Ebola virus, the sources were unknown, the panic unchecked, making it ripe for conspiracy theories and xenophobic blaming
During that epidemic the east coast became like a war zone. To stop the virus from establishing a beachhead in their towns, medical inspectors, behaving more like paramilitary soldiers, guarded state borders, setting up roadblocks, ready to turn away any refugees from NYC especially immigrants. Residents mobilized, setting up barricades and taking drastic action to keep New Yorker’s out as panic and prejudice went viral. http://envisioningtheamericandream.com/2014/10/23/panic-and-prejudice-go-viral/
I am not so sure if this is an epidemic of racism and hysteria but lack of trust for what other people may have been in contact with. People are simply suspicious and worried because Mr Duncan, according to the government, lied on a questionnaire at the Roberts International Airport (RIA) by answering “NO” when asked if he had had contact with anyone infected with the virus in the past 21 days.
So there is actually no guarantee that other visitors from the infected areas won’t do the same.
I remember that i was the same reactions during the epidemic outbreak of SARS in China during 2012-2013 even if SARS is not as deadly as ebola. So how can we interpret that as a temporary racism against Chines people.
“epidemic outbreak of SARS in China during 2002-2003″
Lied on the questionnaire or was unaware that he had been exposed? I don’t believe that has actually been determined. He apparently thought he was assisting a woman who was having a miscarriage.
The Land of opportunity gave Ebola every chance: misdiagnosed and sent our patient zero home, put family back in a Ebola contaminated apartment, had no decontamination or waste disposal plan, put bare skinned nurses in Ebola intensive-care and infected two, got Ebola a plane trip and tried to book it a sea cruise. This did not instill trust in our public health system or expert opinion.
You article plays to the sum of our fears and trivializes them. However, little over a year ago those who spoke out against government surveillance were considered overly fearful. The truth is there are many more questions than answers for Ebola 2014. The best comment on the situation I have seen was the expert epidemiologist who stated “My crystal ball is painted deep black.” Will Ebola contagion go extremely airborne not likely but I have seen this fear-card played by both racist to discriminate and humanitarians to get more aid.
You point out expert opinion as to the lesser contagion of Ebola. Other “experts” claim that some new strain of Ebola seen in West Africa in 2014 replicates faster and cause pathology quicker than previously seen. This increased viral replication by the numbers would be more contagious. Indeed all Ebola strains have varying degrees of lethality and infection and contagion in humans. Due to the high mutation rate of the Ebola virus variations may also occur within a single strain such as Ebola Zaire. What landed in Dallas could have been “Ebola-light.” Our next encounter may be very different. We simple do not know what we are facing. If Ebola can vary rate of replication some variants might replicate fast be more contagious and lethal, others more slowly and explain how many people in endemic areas get natural immunity to the virus without getting sick. We simple do not know and nether irrational fear nor optimism will help, truth and answers need to be discovered ASAP.
Ehh, clearly that is what I’m saying there.
“Panic is dividing the country at a time when the U.S. and indeed the whole world needs to pull together to solve a viral health crisis.”
Thank you for responding to my remarks. If you add and incompetence to panic we are on the same page. Misplaced fear and blame is not useful. Yes, Africa has a lot of disease because it has a lot of life to included being the candle of humanity. Ten square foot of rain forest triple canopy from heaven high to hell deep hold more life and viruses that can infect that life than an acre of deciduous forest here. The truth for those that wish to take the time and thought to find it is Ebola is a biological numbers game not a “black” thing. Misinformation fear and prejudice feed on each other are poison to seeking truths that can help plot some solutions. The more the peoples of the world delay in response to this epidemic the fewer and worst chooses we will have.
The sum of our fears for Ebola is in part caused by post 9/11, post Constitutional l America were lies and misinformation have become government policy. Fear and mistrust and a steady diet of lies haves been sown to the point where most cannot grasp the truth or accept it, a sad state of affairs that is well reported in the Intercept.
Yours is the first story the Intercept has done on Ebola. I hope you and the Intercept stay with it. Many parts of the Ebola story intertwine science and human interest and relate to the broader thyme of the Intercept to inform the public on malfeasance and misinformation issues in governance not well covered in the MSM.
Three important Ebola stories not being well covered in any depth are:
1. Many people in areas were Ebola exists have antibodies, natural immunity, to Ebola indicating they have by some unknown mechanism been exposed and perhaps have immune defense against Ebola.
2. Some very good scientists are reporting that at least some of Ebola-Zaire 2014 in West Africa replicates faster and is more pathological. They suggest this is a new “bug” quite different from other strains they have seen in the past,” Ebola-Guinea?”
3. A Liberia doctor, DR. Gobee Logan, has claimed to have achieved some success in the treatment of Ebola cases with the HIV drug Lamivudine. This rural Doctor’s efforts were out of desperation after he saw Ebola patients, probably many people he knew from his practice. Although the numbers of patients were limited to 15 all but two survived.
I would be glad to help you or any other reporter source and find some answers to the above stories. I for one as a scientist sincerely wish to find some answer to these questions.
I have four decades experience as a Special Forces soldier, research scientist (microbiology, immunology) inventor and biotechnology consultant in Government service and the private sector. The nexus of this work was several peer reviewed articles on the multi-threat medical countermeasure hypothesis for developing broad spectrum countermeasures with efficacy against the inflammatory pathology, “cytokine storm” caused by different classes of chemical and biological threats (2003, 2004). Specifically affirmed in “Homeland Security Presidential Directive/HSPD-18” (January 31, 2007, Medical Countermeasures against Weapons of Mass Destruction). I have also pioneered invention of Fc receptor immunotherapy (US Patent # 5,189,014), one of the first uses of a receptor as a drug. I further spent 23 years at United States Army Medical Research Institute of Chemical Defense, APG, Md. and am familiar with open literature work on Ebola done at the sister Institute United States Army Medical Research Institute of Infectious Diseases (USAMRIID).
Related Literature:
Cowan FM, Broomfield CA, Stojiljkovic MP and Smith WJ. A Review of Multi-Threat Medical Countermeasures Against Chemical Warfare and Terrorism. Military Medicine 169, 850-855, 2004.
Nadia Wauquier, Pierre Becquart, Cindy Padilla1, Sylvain Baize, Eric M. Leroy. Human Fatal Zaire Ebola Virus Infection Is Associated with an Aberrant Innate Immunity and with Massive Lymphocyte Apoptosis. Open access on line.
Katze Simmons, Jeremy Farrar, Thomas R. Martin and Michael G.Jennifer R. Tisoncik, Marcus J. Korth, Cameron P. Into the Eye of the Cytokine Storm. Microbiol. Mol. Biol. Rev. 2012, 76(1):16. DOI:
Washington Post photographer Michel du Cille had a Syracuse University invitation rescinded, related to his travel to Liberia to cover the Ebola crisis and fears that the incubation period might be longer than 21 days.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2014/10/17/syracuse-university-disinvites-washington-post-photographer-3-weeks-after-he-returned-from-liberia/
Americans are suffering from a serious panic attack as panic has gone viral. Ebola hysteria is spreading faster than the virus itself, creating a climate of fear mongering, misinformation and intolerance. Along with calls for travel restrictions and border closures, the panicked reactions resemble another viral epidemic of nearly a century ago.
The 1916 Polio epidemic all but forgotten now was the worst polio epidemic ever, striking an unprepared NYC out of the blue creating a pandemic of panic. Like the Ebola virus, the sources were unknown, the panic unchecked, making it ripe for conspiracy theories and xenophobic blaming. Sound familiar? http://envisioningtheamericandream.com/2014/10/21/panic-gone-viral/
Okay, let’s think deep. Let’s act like people die, like that’s a possibility. Let’s act like that would make sense, that would be amusing. Let’s act like that happens, that’s sinister almost. Let’s act like that happens though, and that we’ve seen the result. Let’s act like it didn’t look pretty, and that it happens. Let’s point out that we’ve served in the military, and know what we’re talking about. Let’s act like they’re telling the truth, and let’s act like we believe them. Let’s act like that’s important.
Interesting that the west african immigrant community in USA is also avoiding contact with new arrivals from west africa. The only explanation for this is that they are all racist down to the marrow of their bones.
A couple of self-identifies:
The man from Liberia self-identified as Eric Duncan, not Thomas Duncan.
MSF self-identifies as a medical humanitarian organization, not a charity.
The funny thing is that these same people being racist about Ebola also fear martial law, and FEMA camps. Don’t they realize that what they are calling for is exactly what they fear most?
As Maz Hussain tweeted today, an actual adult actually wrote this:
Marc Thiessen in Wapo. Rest of derangement seen here: http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/marc-thiessen-a-dark-winter-of-ebola-terrorism/2014/10/20/4ebfb1d8-5865-11e4-8264-deed989ae9a2_story.html
Pardonnez-moi! Maz could have noted that, but it was actually tweeted by Jon Schwarz.
“Manic Marc ” clearly forgot to take his Prozac.
“Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist uninvited to Syracuse University conference because of Ebola scare”
http://www.syracuse.com/news/index.ssf/2014/10/pulitzer_prize-winning_journalist_uninvited_to_syracuse_university_conference_be.html
“U disinvited the three-time Pulitzer Prize winner from the 2014 Fall Workshop amid fears he may have Ebola after traveling to Liberia last month to cover the virus’ outbreak. He and his wife Nikki Kahn, a fellow award-winning photojournalist, were scheduled to do portfolio reviews at the S.I. Newhouse School of Communications when Provost Eric Spina told them not to come after a student expressed concern to Newhouse Dean Lorraine Branham.
“It’s a disappointment to me,” du Cille told the Post. “I’m pissed off and embarrassed and completely weirded out that a journalism institution that should be seeking out facts and details is basically pandering to hysteria.””
“SU dean explains decision to disinvite photog just back from Ebola-plagued nation”
http://www.syracuse.com/news/index.ssf/2014/10/su_newhouse_school_dean_says_she_would_not_have_disinvited_photog_if_decision_we.html
Village Voice article title? Who is responsible for that? I’ve looked at the first several comments to the article and am seeing a number of people asking that question with blood in their eyes, so to speak. But the author, Irene Chidinma Nwoye, has so far not answered. Quite often someone other than the author of an article is responsible for the headline of the article. It’s a horrendous headline. I hope that the author will come around to say that she takes no ownership of it. The editors, the headline writers and The Village Voice should all be held to account. It’s not too late to take that headline down either, accompanied by an update to the article with and explanation and an apology.
She had the chance to and has chosen, weirdly. not to. She has tried to move on for not going against that title being used for her piece, or worse, her picking that title.
Rwanda has decided to screen all incoming passengers from countries with Ebola outbreaks, meaning yes, that passengers from the US would be screened,
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/10/21/rwanda-us-ebola_n_6022032.html
Would this help anyone put the Africa ban idea in perspective? If we’re going to ban travel from Africa, why not from Texas as well?
There are huge and obvious differences between the cases in America/Spain and those in Africa. But if they want to use this as an opportunity to tout how they’re sticking it to Americans (which it *very obviously* is btw – read the gleeful comments on the Huffington Post page), don’t be surprised when many people laugh at them for thinking we care about the possibility that we can’t travel to Rwanda.
How about Ted Rall or the Yale epidemiologist who supported the travel ban? I don’t think they’re ignorant and I’ve actually been won over by their arguments.
Correction Yale trained** epidemilogist. Also, this was supposed to be a comment to the main article, not a reply to someone.
Well of course Fox News is warning all Americans about the impending arrival of hordes of terrorists ..who apparently will infect themselves with Ebola before arriving at our shores …and then proceed to walk around our cities , coughing, sneezing, vomiting , and spreading their bodily fluids any way they can.
http://www.newshounds.us/fox_s_maccallum_fear_mongers_about_an_ebola_terrorist_attack_10202014#6rLbLABtOlRqjOtq.01
Fox News is good at that. They appear to be telling the truth. Let’s discern whether it’s valid.
Joe: I’ve often wondered why that hasn’t been done. Seems like it would be more effective than IMD’s.
Or rather, thanks to fear-mongering, ignorance and stupidity.
Do I understand you correctly? You’re stating that because someone notes that a virus that kills about 50% of those it infects, a virus that is killing THOUSANDS in the tiny country of Liberia and is amazingly contagious. Because that someone plays the odds and chooses to lower the odds off infection by avoidance of those MOST LIKELY to be carriers of same- are racist? wow, I didn’t know until now that viruses had a race! You see, Aveina, it’s not the people they’re avoiding- it’s the virus. (moron)
It’s not fear-mongering, ingnorance or stupidity to avoid something that could potentially kill you. If you don’t get that, prove to the world you aren’t racist and stand in froont of a bus.
PS- Only a racist would link a virus to a race…..
Did I say anything about race? No,I didn’t. To discriminate against someone because they happen to be originally from a country where the virus is currently killing people displays ignorance of and unwillingness to educate oneself about the disease. Instead people are listening only to those who are doing the fear-mongering.
Ebola is a serious danger and I therefore support quarantine. Quarantine should include some protection against discrimination and job loss.
One way to avoid racism and over-reaction is to ensure that whatever sanctions are applied to travelers from Liberia are also applied to travelers from Texas.
While the thought of an African concentration camp seems promising, it appears to be against the law. There are other factors at play here that seem obvious.
Sorry Todd, internment camps are still very legal in the United States. All you have to do is whisper “National Security” and the United States Supreme Court says you are good to go.
It appears that prison exist, and that people reside in them. I will take their word for it, it appears to be relevant.
Please refer to “Japanese-American Internment Camps” and the court case: Korematsu v. United States, 323 U.S. 214
The prison with the most torture is the mind. There can be escape from physical prison but never the mind. Some people experience this “no escape” as the very essence of freedom, but they never do anything without the tv on.
The Ebola threat is tragically obvious in it’s origin and strain. The subject of disease is a tricky subject worthy of introspection. Let’s act like it didn’t happen, and point out the obvious. Point proven.
Ebola is like the unfortunate dolphin that no one stops to consider. Are they truly of this world, or just the fevered premonitions of our eternal need for renewal? No one can say, but some diseases are worse than bad ideas and embracing bigotry I fear will only accentuate the inevitable.
Life can be like that. While the threat of foreignness is self-evident, there appears to be no justification.
The Monsters Are Due On Main Street (1960) – an episode of the TV program The Twilight Zone – is more timely today, nearly 55 years later, than it was then. The plot of the show was how people are their own worst enemy and will easily destroy themselves & their neighbors with very little prodding.
Much of the fear is obviously driven by race (those “Africans” have it), plus the eagerness of our profit-based news media to stoke fears & fantasize about absurd scenarios for ratings, plus an American political party whose entire identity is wrapped in representing White America ONLY.
Unfortunately, even a statement as common sense as “educational outreach is sorely needed right now”, would be seen as suspect by many people who ‘know’ that the scientific community is lying to us to serve some greater, inexplicable global liberal agenda.
What’s truly frightening is not the Ebola virus which people will likely be a hard-to-recall trivia question a year from now, but how shockingly susceptible people are in this country to wild over-reaction to any pandemic they hear about real or imagined.
As Rahm would say, it would be a shame to let a good crisis go to waste. If everyone is fitted with a GPS chip (completely non-discriminatory), then government databases would record every person with whom they have had contact. If someone is diagnosed as infected, all those at risk can be notified, tested and, if necessary, isolated. People, knowing the government was in full control of the situation, would stop behaving irrationally – or at least, would redirect their irrationality into more socially acceptable channels, such as blaming Islam for American dependence on Middle Eastern oil.
“… blaming Islam for …”
—–
Yes, we should blame Yusuf Islam for that, …, totally.
The Middle East is a conflict awaiting an answer. We have provided the answer. There appears to be no solution. We give up and move on to the next issue. Excellent foreign relations policy.
George W. Bush: “Africa is a nation that suffers from incredible disease.”
It would be interesting to know how many people just agreed with Bush’s “ahem” statement without a second thought.
A heck of a lot for sure.