A federal jury in Washington, D.C., returned guilty verdicts against four Blackwater operatives charged with killing more than a dozen Iraqi civilians and wounding scores of others in Baghdad in 2007.
The jury found one guard, Nicholas Slatten, guilty of first-degree murder, while three other guards were found guilty of voluntary manslaughter: Paul Slough, Evan Liberty, and Dustin Heard. The jury is still deliberating on additional charges against the operatives, who faced a combined 33 counts, according to the Associated Press. A fifth Blackwater guard, Jeremy Ridgeway, had already pleaded guilty to lesser charges and cooperated with prosecutors in the case against his former colleagues. The trial lasted ten weeks and the jury has been in deliberations for 28 days.
The incident for which the men were tried was the single largest known massacre of Iraqi civilians at the hands of private U.S. security contractors. Known as “Baghdad’s bloody Sunday,” operatives from Blackwater gunned down 17 Iraqi civilians at a crowded intersection at Nisour Square on September 16, 2007. The company, founded by secretive right-wing Christian supremacist Erik Prince, pictured above, had deep ties to the Bush Administration and served as a sort of neoconservative Praetorian Guard for a borderless war launched in the immediate aftermath of 9/11.
While Barack Obama pledged to rein in mercenary forces when he was a senator, once he became president he continued to employ a massive shadow army of private contractors. Blackwater — despite numerous scandals, congressional investigations, FBI probes and documented killings of civilians in both Iraq and Afghanistan — remained a central part of the Obama administration’s global war machine throughout his first term in office.
Just as with the systematic torture at Abu Ghraib, it is only the low level foot-soldiers of Blackwater that are being held accountable. Prince and other top Blackwater executives continue to reap profits from the mercenary and private intelligence industries. Prince now has a new company, Frontier Services Group, which he founded with substantial investment from Chinese enterprises and which focuses on opportunities in Africa. Prince recently suggested that his forces at Blackwater could have confronted Ebola and ISIS. “If the administration cannot rally the political nerve or funding to send adequate active duty ground forces to answer the call, let the private sector finish the job,” he wrote.
None of the U.S. officials from the Bush and Obama administrations who unleashed Blackwater and other mercenary forces across the globe are being forced to answer for their role in creating the conditions for the Nisour Square shootings and other deadly incidents involving private contractors. Just as the main architect of the CIA interrogation program, Jose Rodriguez, is on a book tour for his propagandistic love letter to torture, Hard Measures: How Aggressive CIA Actions After 9/11 Saved American Lives, so too is Erik Prince pushing his own revisionist memoir, Civilian Warriors: The Inside Story of Blackwater and the Unsung Heroes of the War on Terror.
While the Blackwater verdict is an important and rare moment of accountability in an overwhelmingly unaccountable private war industry, it does not erase the fact that those in power—the CEOs, the senior officials, the war profiteers—walk freely and will likely do so for the rest of their lives.
What is so seldom discussed in public discourse on the use of mercenaries are the stories of their victims. After the Nisour Square massacre, I met with Mohammed Kinani, whose 9-year-old son, Ali, was the youngest person killed by Blackwater operatives that day. As he and his family approached the square in their car:
“[T]hey saw one armored vehicle and then another, with men brandishing machine guns atop each one,” Mohammed recalls. The armored cars swiftly blocked off traffic. One of the gunners held both fists in the air, which Mohammed took as a gesture to stop. “Myself and all the cars before and behind me stopped,” Mohammed says. “We followed their orders. I thought they were some sort of unit belonging to the American military, or maybe just a military police unit. Any authority giving you an order to stop, you follow the order.” It turns out the men in the armored cars were neither U.S. military nor MPs. They were members of a Blackwater team code-named Raven 23.
As the family waited in traffic, two more Blackwater vehicles became visible. Mohammed noticed a family in a car next to his—a man, woman and child. The man was staring at Mohammed’s car, and Mohammed thought the man was eyeing Jenan. “I thought he was checking my sister out,” Mohammed remembers. “So I yelled at him and said, ‘What are you looking at?'” Mohammed noticed that the man looked frightened. “I think they shot the driver in the car in front of you,” the man told him.
Mohammed scanned the area and noticed that the back windshield of the white Kia sedan in front of him was shattered. The man in the car next to Mohammed began to panic and tried to turn his car around. He ended up bumping into a taxi, and an argument ensued. The taxi driver exited his car and began yelling. Mohammed tried to break up the argument, telling the taxi driver that a man had been shot and that he should back up so the other car could exit. The taxi driver refused and got back into his vehicle.
At that point, an Iraqi police officer, Ali Khalaf Salman, approached the Kia sedan, and it started to slowly drift. The driver had been shot, and the car was gliding in neutral toward a Blackwater armored car. Salman, in an interview, described how he tried to stop it by pushing backward. He saw a panicked woman inside the car; she was clutching a young man covered in blood who had been shot in the head. She was shrieking, “My son! My son! Help me, help me!” Salman remembered looking toward the Blackwater shooters. “I raised my left arm high in the air to try to signal to the convoy to stop the shooting.” He said he thought the men would cease fire, given that he was a clearly identified police officer.
“As the officer was waving, the men on the armored cars started shooting at that car,” Mohammed says. “And it wasn’t warning shots; they were shooting as in a battle. It was as though they were in a fighting field. I thought the police officer was killed. It was insane.” Officer Salman managed to dive out of the way as the bullets rained down. “I saw parts of the woman’s head flying in front of me,” recalled his colleague, Officer Sarhan Thiab. “They immediately opened heavy fire at us.”
That’s how the Nisour Square massacre began.
“What can I tell you?” Mohammed says, closing his eyes. “It was like the end of days.”
Mohammed would later learn that the first victims that day, in the white Kia, were a young Iraqi medical student, Ahmed Haithem Al Rubia’y, and his mother, Mahassin, a physician. Mohammed is crystal clear that the car posed no threat. “There was absolutely no shooting at the Blackwater men,” he says. “All of a sudden, they started shooting in all directions, and they shot at everyone in front of them. There was nothing left in that street that wasn’t shot: the ground, cars, poles, sidewalks; they shot everything in front of them.” As the Blackwater gunners shot up the Rubia’ys’ vehicle, Mohammed said, it soon looked like a sieve “due to how many bullet holes it had.” A Blackwater shooter later admitted that they also fired a grenade at the car, causing the car to explode. Mohammed says the Blackwater men then started firing across the square. “They were shooting in all directions,” he remembers. He describes the shooting as “random yet still concentrated. It was concentrated and focused on what they aimed at and still random as they shot in all directions.”
One of the Blackwater shooters was on top of an armored vehicle firing an automatic weapon, he says. “Every time he would finish his clip, he would throw it on the ground and would load another one in and would start shooting again, and finish the new one and replace it with another.” One young Iraqi man got out of his car to run, and as he fled, the Blackwater shooter gunned him down and continued firing into his body as it lay on the pavement, Mohammed says. “He was on the ground bleeding, and they’re shooting nonstop, and it wasn’t single bullets.” The Blackwater shooter, he says, would fire at other Iraqis and cars and then return to pump more bullets into the dead man on the ground. “He sank in his own blood, and every minute the [Blackwater shooter] would shoot left and right and then go back to shoot the dead man, and I could see that his body would shake with every bullet. He was already dead, but his body was still reacting to the bullets. [The shooter] would fire at someone else and then go back to shoot at this dead man.” Shaking his head slowly, Mohammed says somberly, “The guy is dead in a pool of blood. Why would you continue shooting him?”
In his vehicle, as the shooting intensified, Mohammed yelled for the kids to get down. He and his sister did the same. “My car was hit many times in different places. All I could hear from my car was the gun shots and the sound of glass shattering,” he remembers. Jenan was frantic. “Why are they shooting at us?” she asked him. Just then, a bullet pierced the windshield, hitting Jenan’s headrest. Mohammed shows me a photo of the bullet hole.
As gunfire rained on the SUV, Jenan grabbed Mohammed’s hair, yanked his head down and covered him with her body. “My young sister was trying to protect me by covering me with her body, so I forced myself out of her grip and covered her with my body to protect her. It was so horrific that my little sister, whom I’m supposed to protect, was trying to protect me.” Mohammed managed to slip his cellphone from his pocket and was going to call his father. “It’s customary that when in agony before death, you ask those close to you to look after your loved ones,” he says. Jenan demanded that Mohammed put down the phone, reminding him that their father had had two strokes already. “If he hears what’s happening, he’ll die immediately,” she said. “Maybe he’ll die before us.”
At that moment, bullets pierced the SUV through the front windshield. A bullet hit the rearview mirror, causing it to whack Mohammed in the face. “We imagined that in a few seconds everyone was going to die–everyone in the car, my sister and I and our children. We thought that every second that passed meant one of us dying.” He adds, “We remained still, my sister and I. I had her rest her head on my lap, and my body was on top of her. We’d sneak a peek from under the dashboard, and they continued shooting here and there, killing this one and that one.”
And then the shooting stopped.
Kinani thought his family had somehow miraculously survived the massacre. But then the silence of the aftermath was shattered by relatives in his car shouting, “Ali is shot! Ali is shot!”
Mohammed rushed around to Ali’s door and saw that the window was broken. He looked inside and saw his son’s head resting against the door. He opened it, and Ali slumped toward him. “I was standing in shock looking at him as the door opened, and his brain fell on the ground between my feet,” Mohammed recalls. “I looked and his brain was on the ground.” He remembers people yelling at him, telling him to get out while he could. “But I was in another world,” he says. Then Mohammed snapped back to consciousness. He put Ali back in the car and placed his hand over his son’s heart. It was still beating. He got in the driver’s seat of his car, tires blown out, radiator damaged, full of bullets, liquids leaking everywhere, hoping still that he could save [Ali’s] life. Somehow he managed to get the car near Yarmouk Hospital, right near the square. He picked up Ali and ran toward the hospital. He nearly collapsed on the road, and an Iraqi police officer took Ali from his arms and ran him into the hospital.
Mohammed checked that the other children were safe and then dashed to the hospital. “I entered the emergency room, and blood was everywhere, dead people, injured people everywhere,” he remembers. “My son was in the last bed; the doctor was with him and had already hooked him with an IV line.” As Mohammed stood by Ali’s bed, the doctor told him that Ali was brain dead. “His heart is beating,” the doctor said, “and it will continue to beat until he bleeds out and dies.” The doctor told him that if there were any hope to be found, it would require taking Ali in an ambulance to a neurological hospital across town. The fastest route meant that they had to pass through Nisour Square. Iraqi police stopped them and told them they could not pass. “The US Army is here and won’t let you through,” the officer told them. The driver took an alternate route and was going so fast the ambulance almost crashed twice. When they got to the hospital, Mohammed offered to pay the driver–at least for the gas, which is customary. The driver refused. “No, I would like to donate blood to your son if he needs it,” he told Mohammed. A few moments later, Mohammed stood with a doctor who told him there was nothing they could do. Ali was dead.
Filmmaker Richard Rowley and I produced a 30 minute documentary on the Nisour Square massacre and the story of Ali Kinani for Democracy Now! and The Nation magazine:
Photo: Susan Walsh/AP
“The company, founded by secretive right-wing Christian supremacist Erik Prince, pictured above, had deep ties to the Bush Administration”
Calling him a “Christian” is an insult to the very nature of Christ’s teachings. Erik Prince is NOT a Christian. Nor was anyone in the Bush administration.
At what point do we admit to ourselves that we’re the freakin’ new Nazis?
Right after WW2, with the deployment of Operation Paperclip, is when we became Nazis.
these thugs from blackwater are murderers nothing less no wonder america is in the state it is now
Amy reported on DN! this morning on what appears another dark day for whistleblowers, and that the FBI has supposedly identified the “watchlist leaker”.
Maybe like Ed there was never any expectation of lasting anonymity, and Jeremy or Ryan can eventually shed more light on what’s actually happened.
Where are the civil penalties for this person and why hasn’t Blackwater been held to pay for the actions of its contractors. The U.S. pays top dollar for these contractors to work in Iraq and other places throughout the world. It pays top dollar for them to be vetted, get security clearance, and even use U.S. equipment. Its soldiers pay for the mistakes of these people–some of whom were kicked out of the their service branches for just such nonsense.
Then when it comes time for Backwater and other organizations to compensate individuals and taxpayers for their irresponsible behavior–somehow the U.S. is supposed to pay for that too–instead of the founders and managers of these organizations.
None of these actions were done under orders. The U.S. government owes NOTHING to these mercenaries. They were paid to do a job and they failed to do it. We owe them nothing. Its reckless to shield them from civil or criminal penalties.
Except the people in power and the politicians making these decisions DO owe them something, these people are donating millions of dollars to get them elected and re-elected afterwards just incase of situations like these and their government lapdogs come running obediently to do their bidding no matter how fucked up or crazy it is. I don’t think they wake up in the morning and plan on doing these things but they have all kinds of ways to justify what the fuck it is that they’re doing that by now they are all so delusional and fucking stupid that they actually believe this bullshit. It’s incredible really, but luckily I have faith that the human race will one day realize that we’re all in this together. the internet connects everybody in a global, world-wide community that is now more aware than ever that this is going on everywhere basically, and that they aren’t the only ones going through these struggles. Everyday there is another protest, another demonstration of thousands and thousands of people demanding the same things from the same kinds of people and continuously getting the shaft each time. Soon enough people will get tired of killing their ownselves because of the insane, corrupt as fuck actions and inactions of the people “in power”. The power is here with all of us, this shit doesn’t work without all of us cooperating in this bullshit system. It’s time to DO something about it, not tomorrow but now. Have a gander at the crop of 2016 candidates for the presidency in the US, it’s a freak show of the same crazy corrupt bastards that have been running this shit in the ground. Things won’t change if we just sit back and wait until after elections this time, it needs to happen before and we need to get the power back into the hands of the people once and for all!
Gripping description of a terrorist attack by radical Christian fundamentalists against Muslims.
Give it a rest. This has nothing to do with Christianity. Only you liberals can impute so much with so little. Just go ahead and put your worn out template on everything you see.
( FYI I am atheist )
Agreed. The connection is total BS, I am a Christian, and we do not advocate violence. True many churches are corrupted just like many Muslim mosques are corrupted. But true believers and practitioners do NOT advocate violence.
Wow, The Fresh Prince of Hell Air gets another first class free ride. I was really hoping by now every penny from his company would be used to build a new Bagdad complete with an amusement park that you could Water-Board A Cheney for an E ticket.
Look, we all know what a scummy piece of shit this guy really is, and we know he hired other pieces of scum to work for him, but what we need to understand is that the ultra scummy bastards that pay this guy his billions are so much worse than him that he is protected by the uglu suckers with every tax dollar we pay out to our government. We are our own ignorant enemies!
“The company, founded by SECRETIVE RIGHT-WING CHRISTIAN SUPREMACIST Erik Prince, pictured above, had deep ties to the Bush Administration and served as a sort of neoconservative Praetorian Guard for a borderless war launched in the immediate aftermath of 9/11.” (emphasis added)
Watch out, the crusaders are around!
Please do not equate these scumbags to true Christians. They are not Christians.
Yes,they are heretics.
Man,what an evil episode in an evil war,by hell’s minions.
And isn’t this the American way? The ‘untouchables’ get away with murder…literally, and the little guy gets to hold the bag. No morals, no ethics, no conscience.
The US routinely protects its killers in uniform by preempting all judicial process. The miscreants are not tried for their crimes abroad under the laws broken in a foreign jurisdiction, but instead returned to America where their misdeeds are buried in paperwork and by time.
What if American mercenaries cannot expect similar protection? Will they continue to kill because they see killing as a profession with honor, or will they hesitate? Perhaps rethink what gainful self employment means?
So sad.
Sad, sad, video.
I join in: so deeply saddening.
I see a lot of us whining now about war atrocities. We, collectively all of us, went cheering for Bush when he went into Iraq. Remember, he had very high approval ratings in those initial days – from us, right? We did not stop to warn him of the consequences – our Press did not, our Media did not.
Wars are always nasty places to be in. Survival instincts encourage the participants to commit excesses and forget that they are humans. There are also many instances of extreme and selfless bravery. We cannot push all the blame to Bush, Cheney or even Obama. It is we who tell them whether we approve of their work or not. It’s all about causation. We have caused all the problem, and now we are blaming Eric Prince and George Bush and Colin Powell, and even that saintly dick, Cheney.
I attended two dinner parties, just prior to the Iraq invasion. This is separate from the December 2002 Christmas party where a friend told me his hedge fund (heavily invested in the defense industry) was visited by high ranking officials from the Bush administration and given a start date for the Iraq war.
The first dinner party was at the house of an editor of the New York Times. The attendees consisted of people from the New York Times and the New Yorker, who all believed that Saddam Hussein had weapons of mass destruction. I was the lone dissenter and in retrospect I think their belief was more a product of their prep school and Ivy League indoctrination. They were not necessarily bad people, they just believed in the system that had served them so well. Most people succeed in these environments by regurgitating what the powers that be want to hear.
The second dinner party was with a bunch of South Americans. Some worked at El Diario. Many had marched against the war, before it even started. What I realized at that second dinner party, is that though out history regular people never want to go to war.
All I can say, is that I am so sorry for what the Americans did in Iraq. Many of the regular soldiers from Pennsylvania, the Midwest, the South truly believed they were helping the people of Iraq. They have very little economic opportunity, except joining the military. Many of them came back with very severe physical and mental injuries, but they never intended to injure the Iraqi people. Quite the contrary, they were told they were feeing them. These games are played at the top and we’re all just pawns.
Was that comment post a joke? If so it was not even as funny as a heart attack. The world, including “We, collectively all of us” took to the streets in the millions and millions trying to stop the invasion of Iraq.
Kitt, it was not meant as a joke. He’s paid, it’s just his job. Yes, millions of people marched worldwide to stop the invasion of Iraq, to no effect. I was especially struck by a passage from “Sleeping with the Devil” by Robert Baer. He was warned by Muslims the Iraq war would not end well. Many of his contacts in the Middle East agreed Saddam was terrible and had to go. The sons were even worse. But they said who are you to take him out? If we don’t like an administration in your country, can we come and change your government? I think this the essential question. “They” talk a lot about human nature in capitalism…focussed on the greed impulse. But they never talk about the desire for self determination, the right to be free, whatever your choice. No people, no country, wants to be told what to do by a superior power. That is human nature.
My dear Kitt ;-)
Bush had approval rating over 80%. If it wasn’t you individually, it was all your neighbors.
http://www.gallup.com/poll/116500/presidential-approval-ratings-george-bush.aspx
Bush had more than 70% for most of 2002. It did drop down to 60% in the later part of the year, but contrary to what you Kitt say, it shot up to 70% when he went marching into Baghdad. Bush, or Gallup for that matter, weren’t cooking up the approval rating – WE were giving him voluntarily, albeit with some help from the Media. So own up your own mischief, my dear Kitt ;-)
Since yet another lunch with a friend was ruined by a flood of stalkers and a photo session…I’m feeling chatty.
The torture gulags were just a trial run for what they’re going to do us in America. And what they are already doing with a test group. The gulags were basically set up for human experimentation, not to get information. Now they very well may have lied to the agents implementing the procedures, which is why I believe top people who gave the orders should be prosecuted, not the low level people.
Apparently the black torture sites that General Petraeus was running made the CIA sites look comparatively benign. Doesn’t anybody find it strange that his DIA (Defense Intelligence Agency) mistress stalked and harassed a perceived rival? Do you think it’s the first time she did it or do you think it was part of her training or her job?
The first person that I complained too, albeit through a boyfriend from Tampa about being harassed, was General Petraeus when he was the Director of the CIA. I was supposed to be left alone (until I broke up with the boyfriend). What struck me at the time was that General Petraeus (military) seemed to know exactly who these stalkers were. It was early in my harassment and I had no idea what was going on. But there were phone calls and e-mails.
That propaganda works is testimony greatly to the power of propaganda done effectively by the establishment, and only secondarily does it imply the culpability of the propagandized people themselves.
In other words, the establishment is mostly responsible – for both the lies and the lies’ effectiveness.
(Americans – like anyone – generally can be manipulated by movies and TV, how much more can they be manipulated by realtime propaganda?)
The people being desensitized enough to ‘fall for it’ can be laid squarely at the feet of the mass media.
And the mass media is (you guessed it) also the lying establishment.
In other words, the establishment is mostly responsible – for both the lies and the lies’ effectiveness. ;(|
We all lack the courage to own up. It’s so much easy to blame someone else rather than accept the blame and learn from it. I am sure we will be having the same conversation again on another occasion when you will repeat your accusations, having conveniently forgotten this one.
Perhaps you lack courage, no need to project that on others.
Since the time of Edward Bernays propaganda and advertising have been homing the craft of influencing people far beyond most people’s awareness, and as I said the establishment needs to be more held responsible than the innocents being manipulated.
This is not to say the populace has no responsibility at all, whatever conversations you moronically “predict.”
Cindy,
Your courage is delusional and phoney. I expect it will be not long before you will again complain that you were misled – that’s when I will remind you of this conversation ;-). Before Iraq-2 there was Afghanistan, and before that there was Iraq-1, and even before that Vietnam. After Iraq-2 there was Libya, and then the attempted one on Syria and Iran. In between there have been lots of proxy wars and covert ops. You, Courageous Cindy, did Nothing. Now don’t blame Bush and Obama every time and say you are being misled by lies. Every time the bugle sounds – WE all applaud – for proof look at the link to the approval ratings that I posted above. Then, when we see the horrors, we search out someone to blame – and who best to blame other than the ones who protect us. WE the People are the fundamental cause, so own up.
@General Idiocy-
I never said I was misled by anything, you twit. You presume way too much, about Kitt, about me, about almost everything.
Those not propagandized (through virtue or luck or whatever) have been involved in Green/Occupy/Libertarian circles and have tried to help the status-quo supporters out of their haze even while the establishment has manipulated the masses.
I have explained the approval ratings you keep harping on about as the effect of propaganda. They still are, with the new war.
You have no idea what I’ve done to protest.
I am constantly amazed at the direction the TV programming has changed. We now see shows with cops, gov agents, medical and forensic agents with MENSA intellects trotting around using scripts that seem from their banality to be computer generated. I don’t subscribe to cable so am left with OTA programming which consists of cooking shows, the same news on multiple channels that are regurgitating the same info and 50 year old sitcoms which weren’t even watchable in the beginning, ie. Patty Duke, Bewitched, Three’s Company reruns, please.
I don’t know what that baby talk is supposed to mean. I never changed course or verbally allowed for the Iraq invasion/occupation before, during or after. I’m well aware of the polls you’ve revisited with your fucking wink, but that was not the poll pre-invasion. The rest is not worth bothering with, as it has been beat to death for years. But, again, to your direct accusation, you were wrong, and I already stated factually why that is and was.
The reality is that for every Kitt that now says they protested against the war – and I believe you when you claim you did – there were two Kittens that wanted the Great War on Terror. That’s what the approval ratings show.
4 trillion dollars spent on waste, fraud, war profiteering and murder. At that rate, instead of bombing people into submission, we could just build them all houses with a swimming pool and still have money left over to fund healthcare and education in America.
I would be interested to know what percentage of Blackwater’s (aka Academi) business is U.S. domestic and what exactly they do? I understand there are plenty of supervisory surveillance positions available for people with security clearances. Gee, I’ve been followed by so many 6’3″ guys that I doubt they could even fill all the jobs. During one entertaining encounter with one of these ex-special forces/seals etc.. I said “You look like you have 100 kills under your belt”. He said “If you don’t stop mouthing off, you’re gonna be 101″. I’m sure he was kidding…
Say you have been entrusted with lots of public money and you control how to spend it.
Option 1 is to spend it on community development which would make your neighbors as much rich as yourself, and probably put them in a position to determine next time how to spend all the money.
Option 2 is to start an enterprise, such as a war, that would make you the primary beneficiary and give you the perpetual power to keep determining how to spend the public money.
Unless you are someone like Christ or Buddha it is not difficult to guess what your choice would be. And even if you are, a few cycles of Option 1 would put Jorge bin Satan in charge.
That’s what EBOLA and ISIS are all about, the Wrath of Thee Almighty. The changing of the guard will not be pretty or peaceful, but after the storm comes the civility and humanity for all. The West and U.S. coalition forces are just trying to fend off and beat back their expired rule of intimidation, worldwide.
I’ve tried to use Nisour Square as an analogy for what happens when other public sector services and agencies are targeted for privatization, but most don’t know or want to know about it. The only way to get people’s attention in the US is to show how the same shift will effect right where they live. Even abstracting it to economic issues leaves too much room for smoke and mirrors spin. The illustration has to be at their doorstep.
So many services are already captured but that’s just the fourth or fifth ring of hell– Blackwater these services and agencies and we could graduate to ninth.
For instance, the privatization of hospice care. Hospital systems and doctors are now investing in these “palliative death” corporations. Then suddenly there’s this slick right-to-die campaign ramping up– high quality videos with soaring sound tracks, etc.– trying to pitch assisted suicide to the rest of the states that haven’t yet legalized it. It’s very emotional– horrible to think of people having to suffer when they’re going to die of a terminal illness. But it’s not exactly working out in some EU countries and even if there’s an example of it working well, that’s not how it would work here. Americans are now more likely to die from something their doctor does to them or prescribes than in car accidents and we’re in a deregulation freefall.
Right to die is already becoming “duty to die” out of the gate. The following is anecdotal but I’m sure not isolated: less than a week after the recent flashy national campaign was launched, I spoke to the parents of a severely disabled teen who’d had a harrowing encounter with surgical staff in a teaching hospital in the Southwest the previous weekend. Though their child was in for minor surgery (repeat procedure due to complex health issues) and wasn’t at death’s door, staff spent two days bullying the family to let them remove the teen’s life saving medications so that the kid would die of an infection, saying the family was being “selfish” for prolonging the teen’s miserable life. All this while the teenager was singing happily in the background and playing with a touchpad. The family suspects the hospital is invested in for-profit hospice. I would wager the team spirit thrown into pressuring the family arose from a combination of perverse incentives and instrumentalism– the institution has the toys to kill and badly wants to use them. I think that’s something people don’t always get when analyzing these horrors– it’s not just profits. There’s also a kind of psychotic utopian thrall involved, a false and twisted ideology.
Then there’s ALEC– whose corporate board members have already captured HHS and every subagency– pushing to privatize child protective services. CPS is already all over the news for snatching infants and children on crap rationalizations like parents seeking a second medical opinion or use of goat’s milk formula and other nonsense. But the worse the agency looks to the public, the closer ALEC circles to its goal– despite the irony that the agency’s terrifying corruption follows the usual pattern of beltway banditry and capture. In the goat’s milk fiasco for example, the child welfare agency pointed to a study on the USDA website ghostwritten for Monsanto as the reason to remove the infant. Now there’s even talk about Blackwatering the CDC and SWAT forces in Mass are now apparently corporate ventures.
I think what’s happening at home relates to what Noami Klein warns about, and it’s easily coming in on people’s confusion over free market ideology, which many mistake for anarcholibertarianism. Some even think “liberalization” means “liberal.” There’s been a revolving door of industry employment in so many regulatory agencies for ages and, accordingly, these agencies start to suck (CDC losing anthrax vials, flubbing on Ebola, committing study fraud, etc.). The wrinkle again is that the public has been led to believe that these problems are issues of government bureaucracy when in actuality, the glaring flaws and corruption are often due to regulatory capture. But capture is “check” and privatization is “check mate.”
As is the case with
Obama
Bush
Clinton
Bush
Reagan
Carter
Nixon
Johnson
Kennedy
etc etc.
Unspeakable horror. I am normally opposed to the death penalty but in this car I could possibly make an exception.
Says they have been charged but why are we not hearing for how long?
I was hoping the article would make an argument for how and why the CEO of the company could legally be held accountable for the actions of employees that are not under his direct control. There may be an argument out there but this article wasn’t interested in it. Also, using inflammatory words like “christian supremacist” would be fine if what it was alluding to were clear or explained but again, Scahill seems to feel that raw emotion is more compelling than reasoned argument. The first hand account at the end is horrific and damning for all that Blackwater was (or has become) and everyone who was attached to it but again, it tells us nothing about legal mechanisms that would allow Prince to be personally held responsible for the acts of those men that were convicted.
Obama speech, he managed to keep a straight face, when he was mouthing these lies and hypocrisies:
“This is the international community that America seeks: one where nations do not covet the land or resources of other nations, but one in which we carry out the founding purpose of this institution and where we all take responsibility. A world in which the rules established out of the horrors of war can help us resolve conflicts peacefully and prevent the kind of wars that our forefathers fought. A world where human beings can live with dignity and meet their basic needs whether they live in New York or Nairobi, in Peshawar or Damascus.”
Let’s all act as if we didn’t understand your trolling.
Nah.
@ Kelly,
Pulling out the conspiracy theory card, especially in the face of today’s court decision, is all we need to hear from you regarding objectivity and bias. We are talking about war crimes here and your counterargument is the number of contracts this warlord has signed with the Pentagon… What does this tell you about the culpability of state officials all the way to the top? All war criminals are effective in what they do (i.e. killing). Efficiency is not the issue.
We should discard the facts that emerge from serious investigative journalism and simply accept Mr. Kelly’s commanding grasp of truth. For you, mercenary armies are the “PMC industry”. They win contracts, therefore they are successful. Really, what is the planet you are living in? Unless justice is served, it will become the planet we will all eventually live in.
The only thing that would scare the founding fathers more than a standing army is a private corporate army with its own agenda. Be afraid be very afraid.
This is absolutely horrible but this is how government works, people. Government is deadly force. Everything about it is backed by the threat of violence. Unfortunately liberals have this blind spot when it comes to spotting the private in the public. This article goes on about “private war profiteers”, but it’s all profiteering, even when U.S. enlisted troops do it. Who sells the guns, the ammo, and the equipment? Who sells the fuel used to power war? It’s always private. Blackwater just makes it more transparent, but we all know regular troops have done stuff that is far more horrible than what happened at Nisour Square. They have killed hundreds of thousands of innocent civilians, and here we are treating this as something special because a private company did it. There’s no difference. It’s all awful and it’s all done to enrich private individuals. What’s the difference between this Blackwater CEO and the CEO of General Atomics, the company that makes the drones which routinely kill civilians under Presidential orders? What makes Bush and Cheney any different from Obama who has unleashed unmanned killing machines all over the world? All of them private individuals who commit horrible crimes on behalf of their own private aspirations (be it money or prestige or “legacy”, what’s the difference?) because they hold the power of government, and liberals and neocons think that government has a license to violate individual rights, including the most precious and basic right. Government is people. Corporations are people. It’s all the same. We need to prohibit people from killing other people unless done in a purely defensive way. And that means government needs to be reined in. And if you rein in government, you rein in the corporations which work under the umbrella of the government, which feed off it like pilot fish on a shark.
I wish I could believe that this is an aberration but I know it is not. I cried through the story and the video is heartbreaking. How can this go on? What is wrong with the United Stated of America? How did we become this monster?
“Jeremy Scahill: Blackwater Execs Remain Free as Guards Convicted for Killing 14 Iraqis in Massacre”
http://www.democracynow.org/2014/10/23/jeremy_scahill_blackwater_execs_remain_free
(Excellent work. Thank you.)
He also wrote the book on Blackwater:)
I don’t blame Erik Prince. I blame the US government for hiring contractors in the first place to do the work that should have been done by the US military. Why did we allow the state department to hire private contracting companies to operate in a war zone?!? If we have marines defend the embassies, why can’t we have marines provide security for the state department staff?
Everyone was jumpy, the military and the contractors. They were under constant attacks. But the military has to adhere to the military code of justice and private contractors do not – so they (the private contractors) had no business being there at all.
As to this article, I have never heard of Erik Prince being referred to as a Christian supremacist. That makes him sound like a Nazi. I could be wrong, but I believe that is not an accurate description of him at all. Here is his description in wiki:
“Erik Dean Prince (born June 6, 1969) is an American businessman, philanthropist, and former U.S. Navy SEAL officer.”
So I don’t know that the description of him in this article is necessarily fair. I will point out also that when the military killed civilians in Iraq it was by accident. Whereas ISIS is engaging in intentional genocide against entire towns of unarmed civilians.
Another point to make is that I believe President Bush permitted these companies to operate because it was a way of bolstering the military without using a draft, which would have made the conflict hugely unpopular (like the Vietnam war was – where everyone was afraid of getting drafted).
There are numerous articles, books and documentaries on Blackwater. Surely, you are at least aware of Jeremy’s own work on the subject? The first to dedicate a whole book on them? No? I guess Wikipedia is a reliable source for you. Especially the part that calls a warlord “philanthropist”.
But then, why should we be surprised by your comment on Blackwater, when you also believe that “when the military killed civilians in Iraq it was by accident”. WOW. Is Fox News and CNN your only windows to the outside world?
You totally misread my comment:
1) I hate FOX news
2) I believe my point was that the government should not have hired Blackwater to do work that they should have been doing themselves because contractors do not have to adhere to the military code of justice. In my opinion, the marines should have been responsible for providing security to the state department in a war zone.
My other point is that people on this blog can complain about Iraqis being killed by accident by US forces, but right now, with no US military there, ISIS is killing every man, woman, and child they can get their hands on. They were 1000 times better off with the protection of US forces.
Fair enough about points 1 and 2. As fro the rest of your comment, I quote from Wikipedia on War of aggression:
“During the trial, the chief American prosecutor, Robert H. Jackson, stated:
To initiate a war of aggression, therefore, is not only an international crime; it is the supreme international crime differing only from other war crimes in that it contains within itself the accumulated evil of the whole.”
Let’s repeat: The invasion of Iraq is “the supreme international crime”. Those that orchestrated this war are the biggest war criminals of this generation. The death and destruction that followed (including ISIS) is simply a consequence of the invasion. Besides, killing and torture of innocents in Iraq was abundant in the hands of US soldiers too (not just the mercenaries). Since you don’t live under the Fox News veil, you should know this.
“The invasion of Iraq is “the supreme international crime”.
As was Korea, Vietnam, Grenada, Panama…
Chomsky said it best: “If the Nuremberg laws were applied, then every post-war American president would have been hanged.”
They weren’t killed by accident, you moron. They were murdered. Jesus! There’s something wrong with you.
That bit about Isus killing every man woman and child they can get their hands on;Do really believe that obvious BS?They would have no support if that was the case,and its obvious they have plenty of support by the occupants of the territory they hold.The MSM lie serially,and are serial liars,and anything they spew is subject to intense scrutiny,which you don’t employ at all,and swallow their sh*t.
As to this article, I have never heard of Erik Prince being referred to as a Christian supremacist. That makes him sound like a Nazi. I could be wrong, but I believe that is not an accurate description of him at all.
This:
The first sentence was supposed to be blockquoted.
There are a lot of reasons but Jim Risen mentioned one of them in his new book Pay Any Price
I have seen investigations into their meal services (I think it was on 60 minutes) where it worked out to something outrageous like 500 dollars a meal or something ridiculous (I don’t remember the exact price, but it was shockingly ridiculous). We should not have been hiring these people to do that type of work because they charged way too much. Let a grunt serve the meals (as they have done in all wars previously).
But we should ESPECIALY not have allowed them to function like a private army because they are not in any chain of command and they do not have to adhere to the military code of justice – (not to mention the fact that it costs the US taxpayers billions of dollars).
Really impressive!
You americans — yes you, all of you who had no spine, or the stomach to risk being tortured for having one — butchered hundreds of thousands, maimed even more, and displaced millions of people who never threatened you; naturally, you are little tired of the well earned contempt directed at you for all your troubles. BUt all it took was a few beheadings to give you a second wind.
Now your brave pilot-joy-stick controllers are giving a master class in decapitation. Again. I do admire your indefatigable blood-lust.
And this is a country crowding the world with the mantra of freedom and democracy. The United Nations and the people of the world found no way for the United States to pay for its crime in Iraq. It is like they will go away with all these crimes and deaths. It is a shame to the world.
Great DemocracyNOW! show this morning with a long Laura Poitras interview concerning her CITIZENFOUR film, and I believe Jeremy’s also supposed to be on a bit later…
Thank you Amy, Nermeen, Laura and Jeremy!
Once again the hirelings are the fall guys, while the person ultimately responsible, the Dark Prince, remains free (and rich). Forever an ambulance (war) chaser, this GI Joe playing psychopath, armed with his daddy’s riches, is now spreading his particular brand of police state fascism, mischief and mayhem in other parts of the world. The crimes Prince and his organization perpetrated and got away with are astonishing, e.g. gun running, prostitution, tax evasion, the list goes on and on. Blackwater, now called Academi – remains in business today with the US government as a client. The military industrial kleptocracy (aka the US government and its contractors) are thriving, nothing has changed. “The more things change, the more they stay the same” – Alphonse Karr
Yet another brutal article from Scahill. No objectivity or balance whatsoever, just another tabloid quality beat-up on Blackwater and PMC industry. No reasonableperson disputes that Nisour Square was a tragedy and that the employees responsible need to be held accountable. But Blackwater was tasked with protecting its clients in a hostile enviroment – it never lost a client. Thats part of the reason it kept its contracts. Where was reference to that in the article? Oh, that’s right, it didnt fit Scahill’s agenda. Can completely understand why this media venture is crumbling with garbage like this.
They never lost one “customer” you say? Which part of the UN charter on war crimes or international law does exonerate war criminals for not loosing any “customers”? Your comment is infuriating to say the least!
John, clearly you are as prejudiced as Scahill on this topic (as evidenced by your reference to his book as a citation). The point I made was valid, this is an unbalanced and non-objective article. Blackwater was one of hundreds of PMC’s that operated in Iraq during the war. It did a job that was required (and is still required), and in general it did that job well. That is not reflected in this article.
We have clear evidence that Blackwater employees have committed war crimes. In this particular case we even have a court decision. Are you claiming that, in the face of such egregious crimes, responsibility is not to spill over higher in the hierarchy?
You, on the other hand point to no facts, yet you accuse of prejudice a journalist that has done some very serious on-the-ground research on the subject. Jeremy has investigated the company for years. He has written books and made documentaries. What are your credentials? What are the facts supporting you “unbiased” position? No one disputes that Blackwater is an effective mercenary army. That doesn’t mean they are not war criminals, nor that they should avoid facing justice.
John, I cant even figure out your position (save that you’re a Scahill fan and therefore one of those conspiracy theorist, anti-western government, full-time activists with too much time on their hands). Yes, Scahill has investigated Blackwater for many years, investigated with the same level of objectivity as a Glenn Greenwald article on the US Government.
My facts are verifiable, Blackwater was a successful PMC that won (as its successor, continues to win) repeated US government contracts. It does its job, it protects its clients in dangerous unstable environments. What happened at Nisour Square led, rightfully, to criminal charges and subsequent conviction against those employees. John, you should come visit us on plant earth, its nice here.
Why do you go out of your way to troll Scahill’s articles if you dislike him so much? I find that really odd. I mean, if you don’t like this website, don’t like Greenwald, Scahill, etc why come here and start calling people names like “conspiracy theorist” with “too much time on their hands”? You seem to be wasting an inordinate amount of time trolling. Pot, meet kettle. Must feel good cheerleading for Blackwater dude. Maybe you should go back to redstate.com? Or go listen to Laura Ingraham’s radio show?
The invasion of Iraq is the biggest crime of the 21st century. Unless the people responsible for this atrocity are brought to Hague to answer for their crimes, there is little legitimacy for the said court and little measurable content for international law more generally. US citizens are far from innocent in this regard. They reelected the biggest war criminal of our times as their president, even after it was clear enough that he initiated a war of aggression on false pretenses. The whole nation carries the stain of war crimes, until they manage to bring the perpetrators to justice. Instead they reward them with lavish private contracts and book tours…
You hit the nail on the head, for sure. I didn’t elect said president, but he and his administration hired Blackwater, and they run rich and free?
Well, actually, George W. was never elected by the American people. The first election in 2000 he stole from Al Gore; the corrupt SCOTUS stopped a recount of the Florida vote, and brother Jeb helped out by purging the voting rolls.
In 2004, Ohio’s vote was corrupted by dodgy voting machines, run by privately owned companies like Diebold and a voting process that made it extraordinarily difficult for African Americans to cast a ballot. If that election had been honest, Ohio would have gone to John Kerry. Stolen election #2.
Actually, 9/11 was the biggest crime of the 21st century.
So If I gunned you down in the street because you walked too close to the person I was guarding, you’d be cool with that?
Mike, that doesn’t even make sense. I was pretty clear that Nisour Square was a tragedy and that those guys need to held accountable (as they have been).
THE POINT IS, kelljoy, THEY ARE NOT -in general- *ACCOUNTABLE*, period, Period, PERIOD…
WTF are we doing hiring MERCENARIES to do the dirty work citizens are not doing ? ? ?
you are living in upside-down world, where law, morals, and ethics have been turned on their head, and you LIKE IT THAT WAY…
accountability? you don’t give a SHIT about accountability…
let me guess, ex-blackwater murderer ? ? ?
art guerrilla at windstream dot net
“Tragedy?” You pusillanimous coward. It was mass murder. Try putting yourself in the shoes of those people who had the life blasted out of them that day, and their families, you jackass.
Thanks for pointing those things out, art and Tim. Not many think with compassion anymore. People like Kelly are the people who are going to help our society implode because the lives of others aren’t as important as our precious little American lives. Our world is truly f*cked.
I don’t understand your support of Blackwater? I may be naive, but before Iraq, I never heard of our government hireing home grown militias, their contracts paid by our tax dollars. I’m troubled by groups, such as Blackwater, now called Academi, I believe.
Brutal? I wish I could shove your stinking face in a pool of these victims blood…and then brutally beat the shit out you.
It’s not difficult to be biased against Mr. Prince and Blackwater, since they are, by definition and practice, professional killers. The larger question is addressed in other comments to this story: the US government committed, with the permission of our representatives and with our tax money, the supreme international crime. It is condemned by it’s own criminal code that defines terrorism. It has engaged in such behavior regularly since WW2: Korea, Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, to name four in a long impressive list of military operations. We are quite the killing machine. “If the Nuremberg laws were applied, then every post-war American president would have been hanged.”
Yes, those poor Blackwater boys, especially Prince–things go a little wrong, some folks get killed (accidentally!), and that goddamn Scahill goes and writes a book in which he proves what frauds and morally vacuous toadies people like you are. Keep dreaming that The Intercept is “crumbling,” too.
Here’s the four part Keith Olberman series (featuring Scahill)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?list=PL39802699BACCA1B1&v=_FyRZJPB2hw
^ “Blackwater Holy Crusades”
Robert H. Jackson, a former Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States, also said…to the Canadian Bar Association in 1949, in his address entitled Nuremberg In Retrospect: Legal Answer To International Lawlessness: “…I do think that we have forever laid to rest in the minds of statesmen the vicious assumptions that all war must be regarded as legal and just, and that while the law imposes personal responsibility for starting a street riot, it imposes none for inciting and launching a world war.”
There ought to be a law.
One might be inclined to think the government’s relationship with the private sector is a bit too cozy:
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2014-10-22/it%E2%80%99s-not-just-spying-%E2%80%93-how-nsa-has-turned-giant-profit-center-corrupt-insiders
“rein in”, not “reign in” fer chrissake.
Let’s keep eye on big picture, ‘fer crissake.’
ANY personnel fighting on behalf of the United States MUST be made to take this oath prior to serving:
“I, _____, do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic; that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same; and that I will obey the orders of the President of the United States and the orders of the officers appointed over me, according to regulations and the Uniform Code of Military Justice. So help me God.” (Title 10, US Code; Act of 5 May 1960 replacing the wording first adopted in 1789, with amendment effective 5 October 1962).
“I, _____ (SSAN), having been appointed an officer in the Army of the United States, as indicated above in the grade of _____ do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic, that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same; that I take this obligation freely, without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion; and that I will well and faithfully discharge the duties of the office upon which I am about to enter; So help me God.” (DA Form 71, 1 August 1959, for officers.)”
Prior to the word “orders” must be placed “LAWFUL” and that might set us all on the right path, as “lawful” would pertain directly to the U.S. Constitution.
I do believe that lawful part is covered by the UCMJ Article 92.
There is one glaring problem with that oath: What happens when the PotUS is that domestic enemy?
@Jeremy Scahill – I hope you’ll be able to respond to some of the chatter in the comment thread of this Blackwater piece you here posted today.
I’m wondering if a lot of what you wrote in the piece I’ve linked below would be useful to revisit in conjunction with today’s article, especially to bolster your headline, which was:
“Blackwater founder remains free and rich while his former employees go down on murder charges.”
Blackwater Founder Implicated in Murder –Jeremy Scahill – The Nation – August 2009
Mr. Scahill, surely you’re not suggesting that the people responsible for developing and directing the war machine be held accountable for the war crimes their companies or government institution commit. Just the State Department officials alone would be enough to overwhelm the Hague.
Why?
Was Erik Prince there? Did he order this action? Did he pull a trigger? If so, He should face charges. If not, then how is it his fault when an employee(s) go bad?
Did they charge Obama when the guy went nuts at Fort Hood and shot 13 people?
Read the article by Scahill that I linked to in my previous comment, a scroll above this one. Blackwater “employees” don’t “go bad” or rouge, they are trained to the sort or acts that the group in this article in The Intercept today did.
Excerpt:
The two men claim that the company’s owner, Erik Prince, may have murdered or facilitated the murder of individuals who were cooperating with federal authorities investigating the company. The former employee also alleges that Prince “views himself as a Christian crusader tasked with eliminating Muslims and the Islamic faith from the globe,” and that Prince’s companies “encouraged and rewarded the destruction of Iraqi life.”
(snip)
Doe #1 states that “Blackwater knew that certain of its personnel intentionally used excessive and unjustified deadly force, and in some instances used unauthorized weapons, to kill or seriously injure innocent Iraqi civilians.” He concludes, “Blackwater did nothing to stop this misconduct.” Doe #1 states that he “personally observed multiple incidents of Blackwater personnel intentionally using unnecessary, excessive and unjustified deadly force.” He then cites several specific examples of Blackwater personnel firing at civilians, killing or “seriously” wounding them, and then failing to report the incidents to the State Department.
Kitt what are you talking about? You idiot. You’re as lost (or as prejudiced) as Scahill is.
You’ll have to talk to the Blackwater employees in the comment you’ve replied to. They are the ones who said what I quoted. So call them “idiots,” if you like, for telling of what they saw and did.
Kelly, you are as prejudiced as any one that has written a comment against what this site reports. You need to start reading and listening to something besides Faux news. Eric Prince is a murdering, right wing, son of a bitch and Jeremy Scahill has the most balls in reporting his outlier roll in humanity. It gives me great pleasure in notifying you that you must be as slimy and nutless as prince. Now go collect your pay like a good little boy.
Prince has much to answer for. It amazes me he walks free after what Blackwater did. He must be ‘useful’ to the establishment.
The systemic corruption within the US government is now laid bare by great and brave journalists like Jeremy. It’s possible because of the government’s inability to expeditiously react in the face of instant access to information. What the US government has resorted to is intimidating, infiltrating, mass spying, and misadvising the American people to marginalize its blatant disregard for the law, the constitution, and its duty to the American public. The Disappointment-in-Chief has shown that he is no leader – he is a fraud…no better then the idiot before him.
Thank you, Mr Scahill.
Please pass on, if you can, my apologies as an American citizen for which I am truly ashamed, to Mohammad and all those who died. We, US, are fully responsible for this crime. Iraqi’s and others deserve much much more than we can EVER give.
Jeremy; I read your very good book “Dirty Wars”, and watched the film as well. I learned a great deal about about Somalia and other countries in North Africa and about Iraq, Afghanistan, drones, the background of Al-Quida and much more, a lot of this was a revelation to me.
But this posting is quite shattering. Just about as horrible as any event that you have ever reported. Thanks for doing it.
What a horror story! Thanks God it is unique! No other Iraqi civilians went through that. And our brave troops would never unleash this level of gratuitous violence against occupied people. Only mercenaries would do that.
But again, these unfortunate incidents are a small price to pay to get even with the terrorists who dared disintegrate Building 7 with an office fire.
Love,
loved your irony :D
you were very funny!
wow, that was a powerful video and story. I truly feel for Mohammad and his family. No human being should have to ever experience anything like that. Justice needs to be served here and all involved held responsible including the owner of that company for the actions of his employees just like a construction companies owner would be if one of his workers killed someone by negligence.
I agree Jon, on to top it off I feel culpable for this because I am culpable for this. All US citizens, if this is a truly representative republic and not an inverted totalitarian system. The f@cking BUCK STOPS HERE.
“Prince recently suggested that his forces at Blackwater could have confronted Ebola and ISIS. ”
Blackwater mercenaries vs Ebola, Hell they could put that on pay per view. I’d probably buy it.
You’d think by the article’s title that Prince pulled the trigger in Nisour Square, ordered these murderous actions, or created such a violent culture that he basically was to blame for these murderers’ actions and got off scot free. On what grounds should he be behind bars and destitute? What charges should or have been filed? I’m seriously asking, to determine if this article’s title is apt or just demagogic outrage by Jeremy Scahill. I suspect the latter.
Many people found guilty at Nuremberg Trials, were just following orders, too yet we somehow found the “courage” – ah well never mind.
the comparison to Nuremberg here isn’t a very good one. I don’t think they were ordered to murder unarmed civilians
You will note that there is nothing factually incorrect about the title of the article. Now if you infer from it that Prince “pulled the trigger in Nisour Square, ordered these murderous actions, or created such a violent culture that he basically was to blame for these murderers’ actions and got off scot free”, then you may be on to something.
This reminds me of a BS conservative post about benghazi years back: “Obama lied, people died”
The argument went that Obama lied about how the incident occurred (protest vs terrorist attack), and we all agree that people in Benghazi died. Therefore if you believe Obama lied, you could make the exact same argument that there is nothing factually incorrect about this!!
But it doesn’t take a genius to see that by connecting the two themes, there is an implication of causality. People are left with the notion that because Obama (supposedly) lied, people died. Untrue. As is the case here, while the murderers took the fall, the Executives did not. I guess the author just stringed these two thoughts together for no reason!! To ignore the implication is to delude yourself.
KILLING IS MY BUSINE$$ ~ says Blackwater founded and secretive right-wing Christian supremacist Erik Prince
Men trained to kill have lost their humanity. They are trained to kill like machines. These sick men get a rush from killing. The better they are at killing other human beings the more money they make.
These men are not fighting to protect and serve human civilization but to enshrine a dark world of barbarism for money and a trill. Like pirates of old but these pirates are entertained on Capitol Hill and at the White House.
American citizens pay for these killers with our taxes. WE are also to blame as long as we allow this to be part of our government policies and our so-called “American Dream.” Why are we today the biggest killers on the planet? How may of we Americans even care? Have we become so brainwashed and mind controlled that killing is “no big deal”?
I totally agree with you… sick world we live in!
The title of this article is the key.
For improved reader perspective, interested parties might like a historical situational overview.
That can be found in the following article written by Mr. Scahill in 2010:
See: “Blackwater’s Black Ops”
http://www.thenation.com/article/154739/blackwaters-black-ops
Excerpt: “Governmental recipients of intelligence services and counterterrorism training from Prince’s companies include the Kingdom of Jordan, the Canadian military and the Netherlands police, as well as several US military bases, including Fort Bragg, home of the elite Joint Special Operations Command (JSOC), and Fort Huachuca, where military interrogators are trained, according to the documents. In addition, Blackwater worked through the companies for the Defense Intelligence Agency, the Defense Threat Reduction Agency and the US European Command.
On September 3 the New York Times reported that Blackwater had “created a web of more than 30 shell companies or subsidiaries in part to obtain millions of dollars in American government contracts after the security company came under intense criticism for reckless conduct in Iraq.” The documents obtained by The Nation reveal previously unreported details of several such companies and open a rare window into the sensitive intelligence and security operations Blackwater performs for a range of powerful corporations and government agencies. The new evidence also sheds light on the key roles of several former top CIA officials who went on to work for Blackwater.”
Regarding this information: “Prince now has a new company, Frontier Services Group, which he founded with substantial investment from Chinese enterprises and which focuses on opportunities in Africa.”
Pity that it is the same deplorable CIA mission in a different operational theater. The CIA mercenary forces enforce rule of law for the secret U.S. “shadow government” composed of puppet delegates from the world central banking elite. Cut out the eye of economic control and humanity on Earth will thrive with their inalienable birthright to freedom of choice.
Prince (of supreme darkness) and his puppet master rulers are the ones that society should target for extinction.
Thanks for the article Mr. Scahill.
Re: Lyra 22 Oct 2014 at 3:08 pm
I associate myself with your comment and references, and agree that our ‘ship of state’ can not be put back on its course of serving the public good until the forces of private advantage are constrained under proper regulation.
“Work is love made visible.” KG
As Usual,
EA
as always, scahill can be counted on for providing rock solid evidence to support his positions. but to be fair, the entire policy of hiring out contractors was designed to create an accountability gap between the government and the contracting agency. i’m not sure how that gap works between prince and his underlings. perhaps, it is that his total net worth is almost $2.5 billion. or perhaps it is b/c he was a former navy seal and has deep Republican political connections. most likely, all of the above. in the us where money is the greatest good, billionaires run wild.
@Jeremy Scahill, thanks for continuing your great reporting on Blackwater. I’m very interested in the Blackwater Chinese connection. I lived in a small city in central China in 2008/2009 and noticed a few SUV’s with Blackwater logos… How long has Erik Prince been working with the Chineese?
So tragic and so unnecessary. And I have no doubt that people working for these outfits are still being trained to react exactly like those Blackwater operatives did, so the tragedies will continue and those responsible for the training and indoctrination will never be held accountable.
By Prince’s own admission, administrations can go to war without any political support – instead just a few payments to the war profiteers in the private sector. Accountability and democracy are irrelevant.
For me, every democrat, republican, or libertarian candidate is Erik Prince.
They all worship money above all else and funding slaughter is business as usual for them.
Hear, hear. The election cycle in the US is irrelevant. The political “news” is a sideshow that has nothing to do with how the country is run. An office-holder is just that, and their stated political party “beliefs” are less meaningful to them personally than the logo on an NFL helmet is to the athlete inside it.
If a referendum on the PermaWar were held and 98% of Americans voted to end it, domestic surveillance and police militarization would ramp up again, but nothing else would change. This is not our country, we have no say, and our so-called laws and rights mean nothing. The only reason we can still read stuff like this is so the fascists can track who cares. When the real clamp down comes, people who ask serious questions will be turned off like so many light switches.
p.s. I have watched Scahill for years on DN, I follow Greenwald etc etc etc. I don’t always agree and occasionally I choose to express that – respectfully. So to whoever is moderating this, understand you have shown me a side to your organization I never expected to see.
I really doubt you’ve been subjected to moderation. If this was the first time you’ve commented here using the email address you used, it would be held for approval as a spam-prevention measure, and so would take a while to show up. But after that, all comments are good to go immediately.
There’s lots of criticism here, and none is censored. To my knowledge*, four accounts have been effectively banned since this site launched, and all four were due to extreme volume of obsessive junk (like 10-15% of comments), or “crap-flooding.” Not for viewpoint.
*No, I’m not staff. But I know Greenwald’s moderation standards and the decisions he’s made. He’s as laissez-faire as one can get and still have any moderation standards at all.
Re: Mona- 23 Oct 2014 at 1:54 am
Ref:
Greg 22 Oct 2014 at 1:26 pm
Jeremy that’s a fantastic headline but what does the article have to do with Erik Prince? The story is sensational enough, try being a little more professional putting it into context.
Greg 22 Oct 2014 at 1:42 pm
Alarming to see “The Intercept” censoring perfectly legitimate criticism of this article. I see your true color now.
Greg 22 Oct 2014 at 1:42 pm
p.s. Have fun with your echo chamber
Greg 22 Oct 2014 at 1:51 pm
p.s. I have watched Scahill for years on DN, I follow Greenwald etc etc etc. I don’t always agree and occasionally I choose to express that – respectfully. So to whoever is moderating this, understand you have shown me a side to your organization I never expected to see.
-Mona- It appears that the above chronology of “Greg’s” postings verify your thoughtful and cogent attempt to disabuse the contention that some overt form of “..censoring perfectly legitimate criticism…” has occurred in the guise of moderation. Hopefully “Greg” will now feel comfortable expressing what he/she regards as said “perfectly legitimate criticism” of THE//INTERSCEPT and its staff and subscribers; I, for one, would enjoy knowing more about this percieved “echo chamber”. (;-})
“Work is love made visible.” KG
As Usual,
EA
p.s. Have fun with your echo chamber
Alarming to see “The Intercept” censoring perfectly legitimate criticism of this article. I see your true color now.
What exactly is the “perfectly legitimate criticism of this article”?
By having a private military it separates accountability by several more degrees. There is no accountability for the upper echelon of any organization. Reagan’s government committed crimes, Clinton’s the same. In fact the only president not guilty recently would have to be Carter. And he may be guilty of criminal behavior. I just don’t know of any. Then there’s the banks we bailed out ,and AIG, whose upper echelon got bonuses. We have a duopoly and have for years with two tiers of justice, one for the grunts and one for the overlords.
I think we can “assume” Carter did not commit crimes because he did not win a second term.
Carter did start the secret war in Afghanistan which may not be seen as a crime by some, but at the very least it show hypocrisy. I think hypocrisy is part of what sank him. Although had those people been rescued in Iran… maybe people would have forgiven him. I dunno. Hard to say. The point is that while Carter was a better president by a variety of metrics than all the presidents we’ve had since – he still was an establishment candidate with many of the same flaws – flaws that we often attribute to Reagan. — Deregulation, started under Carter. Secret war in Afghanistan is another one. Would have been better had he not allowed that sort of policy through as it taints his record – even if people prefer to blame Reagan for those sorts of things.
Carter not guilty? Sure, as long as you exclude everything the U.S. was doing in Central & South America during his presidency…
The rich and powerful are above the law. Why would anyone think anything else? Public policy isn’t decided at the ballot box – it is decided at the cash box.
Jeremy that’s a fantastic headline but what does the article have to do with Erik Prince? The story is sensational enough, try being a little more professional putting it into context.
Okay, great. So now we have to get down to “specifics” and start naming names! You’re acting like individuals are responsible for their own acts! Let’s act like their private contracting idea was brilliant, and move on. Christ! I agree.
Your “acting” routine is vacuity.
You know, something caught my eye here. Let’s all act like we speak English. Let’s act like that’s important. While we’re at it, let’s act like this guy read the article and served in the military. Let’s act like he comprehended it, understood the material, and served our country. Let’s all prove that we honor his service. Let’s act like that happened.
I speak American. Many do not as first language, fyi
This vacuous twit has been trolling around THE//INTERCEPT planting his seeds of ignorant malignant narcissism and jingoistic pseudo-patriotism for a long time; but he does provide a point of contrast for those still plagued with SPS (Sarah Palin Syndrome), the few who still struggle to discern the distinction between vacuity and veracity.
“Work is love made visible.” KG
As Usual,
EA
Let’s all act like that made sense.
It was crystal clear.
Let’s act like I took offense.