The National Security Agency and its closest allies planned to hijack data links to Google and Samsung app stores to infect smartphones with spyware, a top-secret document reveals.
The surveillance project was launched by a joint electronic eavesdropping unit called the Network Tradecraft Advancement Team, which includes spies from each of the countries in the “Five Eyes” alliance — the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, New Zealand and Australia.
The top-secret document, obtained from NSA whistleblower Edward Snowden, was published Wednesday by CBC News in collaboration with The Intercept. The document outlines a series of tactics that the NSA and its counterparts in the Five Eyes were working on during workshops held in Australia and Canada between November 2011 and February 2012.
The main purpose of the workshops was to find new ways to exploit smartphone technology for surveillance. The agencies used the Internet spying system XKEYSCORE to identify smartphone traffic flowing across Internet cables and then to track down smartphone connections to app marketplace servers operated by Samsung and Google. (Google declined to comment for this story. Samsung said it would not be commenting “at this time.”)
As part of a pilot project codenamed IRRITANT HORN, the agencies were developing a method to hack and hijack phone users’ connections to app stores so that they would be able to send malicious “implants” to targeted devices. The implants could then be used to collect data from the phones without their users noticing.
Previous disclosures from the Snowden files have shown agencies in the Five Eyes alliance designed spyware for iPhones and Android smartphones, enabling them to infect targeted phones and grab emails, texts, web history, call records, videos, photos and other files stored on them. But methods used by the agencies to get the spyware onto phones in the first place have remained unclear.
The newly published document shows how the agencies wanted to “exploit” app store servers — using them to launch so-called “man-in-the-middle” attacks to infect phones with the implants. A man-in-the-middle attack is a technique in which hackers place themselves between computers as they are communicating with each other; it is a tactic sometimes used by criminal hackers to defraud people. In this instance, the method would have allowed the surveillance agencies to modify the content of data packets passing between targeted smartphones and the app servers while an app was being downloaded or updated, inserting spyware that would be covertly sent to the phones.

But the agencies wanted to do more than just use app stores as a launching pad to infect phones with spyware. They were also keen to find ways to hijack them as a way of sending “selective misinformation to the targets’ handsets” as part of so-called “effects” operations that are used to spread propaganda or confuse adversaries. Moreover, the agencies wanted to gain access to companies’ app store servers so they could secretly use them for “harvesting” information about phone users.
The project was motivated in part by concerns about the possibility of “another Arab Spring,” which was sparked in Tunisia in December 2010 and later spread to countries across the Middle East and North Africa. Western governments and intelligence agencies were largely blindsided by those events, and the document detailing IRRITANT HORN suggests the spies wanted to be prepared to launch surveillance operations in the event of more unrest.
The agencies were particularly interested in the African region, focusing on Senegal, Sudan and the Congo. But the app stores targeted were located in a range of countries, including a Google app store server located in France and other companies’ app download servers in Cuba, Morocco, Switzerland, Bahamas, the Netherlands and Russia. (At the time, the Google app store was called the “Android Market”; it is now named Google Play.)
Another major outcome of the secret workshops was the agencies’ discovery of privacy vulnerabilities in UC Browser, a popular app used to browse the Internet across Asia, particularly in China and India. Though UC Browser is not well-known in Western countries, its massive Asian user base, a reported half billion people, means it is one of the most popular mobile Internet browsers in the world.
According to the top-secret document, the agencies discovered that the UC Browser app was leaking a gold mine of identifying information about its users’ phones. Some of the leaking information apparently helped the agencies uncover a communication channel linked to a foreign military unit believed to be plotting “covert activities” in Western countries. The discovery was celebrated by the spies as an “opportunity where potentially none may have existed before.”
Citizen Lab, a human rights and technology research group based at the University of Toronto, analyzed the Android version of the UC Browser app for CBC News and said it identified “major security and privacy issues” in its English and Chinese editions. The Citizen Lab researchers have authored their own detailed technical report outlining the many ways the app has been leaking data, including some users’ search queries, SIM card numbers and unique device IDs that can be used to track people.
Citizen Lab alerted UC Browser to the security gaps in mid-April; the company says it has now fixed them by rolling out an update for the app. A spokesperson for UC Browser’s parent company, Chinese e-commerce giant the Alibaba Group, told CBC News in a statement that it took security “very seriously and we do everything possible to protect our users.” The spokesperson added that the company had found “no evidence that any user information has been taken” — though it is not likely that surveillance of the leaking data would have been detectable.
The case strikes at the heart of a debate about whether spy agencies are putting ordinary people at risk by secretly exploiting security flaws in popular software instead of reporting them so that they can be fixed.
According to Citizen Lab Director Ron Deibert, the UC Browser vulnerability not only exposed millions of the app’s users to surveillance carried out by any number of governments — but it could also have been exploited by criminal hackers to harvest personal data.
“Of course, the security agencies don’t [disclose the information],” Deibert said. “Instead, they harbor the vulnerability. They essentially weaponize it.” Taking advantage of weaknesses in apps like UC Browser “may make sense from a very narrow national security mindset,” Deibert added, “but it’s at the expense of the privacy and security of hundreds of millions of users worldwide.”
The revelations are the latest to highlight tactics adopted by the Five Eyes agencies in their efforts to hack computers and exploit software vulnerabilities for surveillance. Last year, The Intercept reported that the NSA has worked with its partners to dramatically increase the scope of its hacking attacks and use of “implants” to infect computers. In some cases, the agency was shown to have masqueraded as a Facebook server in order to hack into computers.
The Intercept and CBC News contacted each of the Five Eyes agencies for comment on this story, but none would answer questions on record about any of the specific details.
A spokesperson for Canada’s Communications Security Establishment said that the agency was “mandated to collect foreign signals intelligence to protect Canada and Canadians from a variety of threats to our national security, including terrorism,” adding that it “does not direct its foreign signals intelligence activities at Canadians or anywhere in Canada.”
British agency Government Communications Headquarters said that its work was “carried out in accordance with a strict legal and policy framework, which ensures that our activities are authorised, necessary and proportionate.”
Australia’s Signals Directorate said it was “long-standing practice” not to discuss intelligence matters and would not comment further.
New Zealand’s Government Communications Security Bureau said that it has “a foreign intelligence mandate” and that everything it does is “explicitly authorised and subject to independent oversight.”
The NSA had not responded to repeated requests for comment at time of publication.


IRRITANT HORN –
– Propaganda
– Misinformation
– Spyware
– Surveillance, including exact location
Ministry of truth –
– Propeganda
– Misinfrmation/Rewriting History
Compare them both
Which is worse ?
You are saying that we can no longer trust the information we are getting from anywhere?
Spying just ain’t what it used to be. James Bond was so much cooler than some IT hacker person with Doritos breath hopped up on Mountain Dew.
The plan of the electronics hacking is good for doing such as that, godly work for the safety of individuals. It is been written in the book of words, that god use the man knowledge as it is the way of boring all kind of sin. As in it in proverbs, with acts of deeds. To revelation.
Wonolo, the perfect app to rehabilitate as a ti, no workplace mobbing,
Thankyou google for fucking me some more in the interst of jeffery johnson.
P.s. it would be nice if i could connect to youtube to get my first release of my tape that i put on my account with the other recordings. (Redding oct or nov 2013 shasta libary)
I think they fucked with my stuff on my laptop so they could say im schizophrenic, lucky thou cyclothymia dont last for ever and i understand the “game” good enough now to maintain sanity.
But how can we be sure they did (not) do this, and how can we protect our smartphones from this hijacking?
You can’t protect your smartphone in reality . You may have a chance if you root it and never use your home router wireless
After reading the thread in its entirety, WAKE UP! Do you really think Bradley Manning was so capable? More importantly, the day he was ARRESTED our Harvard Law School educated President stated “He is guilty and will be punished accordingly ” . WAIT – IN US YOUR INNOCENT UNTIL PROVEN GUILTY. Basic law.
Sounds like a pretty smart idea. I don’t see any indication that it was actually deployed.
This is why I do not GO with App stores; if I had a cell phone, I’d rather use some other site to get a ringtone or download music or just put the music on there manually by myself. It’s why I won’t use nor log, nor get app store accounts even via Computer. Screw the NSA! That’s illegal spying! Why is it Christoper Boyce and Edward Snowdan are charged with Treason, but NSA is allowed to spy on the US Citizens? Really, NSA?! Seriously!? Everyone there should be arrested for conspiracy, as well as the NSA should be shut down for this reason alone!
“But methods used by the agencies to get the spyware onto phones in the first place have remained unclear.”
One method is to get hold of your phone. The agent bumps your car with his/her car then asks to use the phone to call it in. Then calls a phone special number or browses to a attack website, which automatically hacks your phone. Call it “Bump N hack.” They can do the same thing in conjunction with a StingRay device.
Reporters need schooling, as in fish schooling. Get a bunch of identical phones under a general contract then switch SIM cards once week and do a phone reset once a month. If you are on a special case, pull a spare phone from the crib and sync personal//professional data to a corporate server.
I’ve been cleaning up my online profile for a bit now:
1. Started using LastPass add-on for Firefox to generate and save secure passwords ( other add-ons like Ghostery and Cookie Manager are also nice )
2. Use FireFox Tor Browser when I need extra secure browsing and downloading.
3. Installed Bit defender antivirus
4. Ran Spybot search and destroy to get a good base line.
5. Moved personal data to TrueCrypt encrypted volumes on Google Drive and DropBox (I’m going to experiment with Bitlocker doing the same)
6. Got a HushMail account You actually CAN send encrypted emails (it sends a link to the encrypted email which is kept on the Hushmail server)
7. Changed passwords on most of my important accounts using LastPass Password Generator.
8. Got a VPN account with PIA, they also offer a Proxy server no extra cost, TorGuard is supposed to be good also, They have secure email.
9. I use DuckDuckGo and StartPage for searching. DuckDuckGo has a nice Terminal Theme.
It isn’t just the NSA. McClatchy DC website had 36 trackers on its webpage. Remember, a lot of your private info is for sale. The NSA can simply buy you. Some might think that it’s too late to start moving toward a more secure compute environment, but the thing is, information will “age out.” Google has several years of data on me but soon it will be out of date and fading into the past.
Now I’ working on a solution for Amazon and YouTube.
Hey si1ver1ock. Not trying to be rude here, but I would advice anyone against following some of your tips above.
Not sure that recommending LastPass, Ghostery, Bit Defender and Spybot is actually a good thing. Let’s have a look :
– LastPass : it’s a time saver for spy agencies as it’s located in the US (should be trivial to get the salts) and breaching one LastPass account can yield them dozens of passwords. I’d be targeting services like those myself.
– Ghostery : trusting an advertising company for blocking ads and tracking through a closed source software huh ?
– Bit Defender : quite honestly I wouldn’t trust any anti-virus software. If you don’t do crazy / stupid stuff, it’s going to be hard to breach your computer. And, if you are the victim of a zero day exploit (arbitrary code execution through your browser for instance) then the people doing that will not make Bit Defender go off, I guarantee it… It’s much better to use a harder to breach OS than using Windows and a useless / dangerous anti-virus.
– Spy Bot : same as Bit Defender. Also why use both ?
Some things you mentioned that are worth looking into :
– Using Tor – although it’d seriously advice using the Tor Browser Bundle instead of the Firefox extension
– Using TrueCrypt – although their developers “abandoned” it and they advice using alternate volume encryption solution – and why put it on Google Drive where it can be used straight away by agencies ? Consider storing valuable data, even encrypted (especially encrypted ?) on safer hosting solutions.
– Using Hushmail – you could also try Proton Mail which is a very good alternative
– Using a VPN – although, if you have the necessary knowledge or if you are willing to learn, you should rent your own servers and set up your own service instead of trusting a company
– Using DuckDuckGo
It’s good to see that people start to care about their privacy, but you still have to be careful. As the – not so recent – leaks show : privacy and security softwares and services are target #1 for spies and have often been breached or plainly backdoored with the consent of the company. And – that’s always been the case – security softwares are often more about stealing data than protecting it. So make sure you double check who’s behind what and always prefer opensourced software.
Thank you for the article, was a good read.
“3. Installed Bit defender antivirus”
What makes you think they haven’t hijacked the links to the A/V software vendors? I have solid reason to believe they did just that to my Kapersky A/V. Got in through the “update” links.
Bit Defender allows you to scan downloads on demand by right clicking the file. But you are right, Windows is inherently insecure. However, the NSA isn’t the only privacy problem out there. I’ve actually become concerned with my ISP hi-jacking things. If a webpage returns 404, my ISP inserts an error page along with a list of adverts. I seem to recall the US Post Office being recruited to spy on US citizens, which leads to the idea maybe my ISP is likely doing the same.
Other problems:
1. My VPN keeps dropping out more or less randomly.
2. Configuring Windows 8 to use a system-wide Proxy is problematic.
3. Changing email accounts and passwords is/was time consuming.
4. StartPage actually turned out to be too secure. You can’t hit the back button to get back to the original search page.
5. Checking to see if everything is working is a problem. I’m using a Public IP add-on to tell me if my VPN is working, but it only updates once per hour.
Some things worked well right out of the box like the FireFox Tor Browser. It is slow though. I think we are going to need a legal remedy for Amazon. We need to make them put a privacy policy about user data in clear English and put time limits on how long this data can be saved or resold. I may simply have to stop doing business with them. Even NetFlix seems to be tracking and selling my personal data for some unfathomable reason.
A few more tips. How do you know your VPN is safe ? A few years ago, it was said that the NSA hacked more than 300 VPNS. I guess by now they should have expanded their hacking list to a few hundreds more.
For what I read, your are more protecting yourself from Google spying and collecting data on you, but certainly not protecting yourself from the NSA, which was the subject of this article.
It doesn’t secure the endpoint where they can fake code and it passes
Well, in your explanation, you still didn’t explain us what you did to solve the initial problem. Did you stop using Android for an alternative ROM such as Cyanogenmod ?
Done all and still got thru Tor, Bitdefender Trend Micro etc
Can we just over throw this shitty not trust worthy government already?
CSEC “does not direct its foreign signals intelligence activities at Canadians or anywhere in Canada.” Sounds like the quintessential non-denial denial. What about its domestic signals intelligence activities?
Canada spokesperson: “[we do this] to protect Canada and Canadians from a variety of threats to our national security, including terrorism … [we do] not direct [our] foreign signals intelligence activities at Canadians or anywhere in Canada.”
Um…if you’re doing surveillance to protect CANADIANS and the national security of CANADA, wouldn’t you think it made MOST sense to surveil INSIDE Canada itself?
How DUMB do they think we are??!
Sadly, it seems, most people ARE that dumb. They can’t even think, let alone think for themselves, due to the constant barrage of fear- and sensation-based information streaming in front of their eyes as they eat addictive fattening poisonous fake food in front of the television dumbing them into as passive stupid.
They ARE that dumb. We commenters here are the EXTREME minority.
(A great concept coined the other day for this is ‘the crisis of the now’ – read mike adam’s article on it on naturalnews dot com from just the other day, it’s very insightful and spot on.)
Technological surveillance is a slowly rising nightmare of our time which sadly will not make the average citizen realize and experience its true tyranny and oppression until it is too late (…for them and their permanently-recorded data of their entire lives when they could have done something about it). The blocks are firmly in place, the infrastructure locked down, the trivially utilizable security vulnerabilities flourishing as normal, the increasingly disturbing types of data and sensors (increasingly biometric in de-anonymizing people) increasing month by month, the storage technology for the archive getting cheaper, the computer algorithms for making sense of the big data stream getting smarter every day (and being worked on by highly-remunerated genuises, surely), and the incentives for funding and building more and more storage, computing power and interception resources for the whole thing in general, only getting greater.
(Data is becoming the no. 1 resource of world power play now, if Big Oil can decline thanks to people like Elon Musk and Tesla Energy.)
They are not an absolute power but it’s about realizing just what IS easily within their power, money and resources, and what they CAN do behind closed (AT&T listening room) doors, because whatever that is – Snowden has shown us that they ARE doing it, and of COURSE, will continue to do it no matter what sleight-of-hand laws take place to placate gullible sheeple into ‘feeling better’ so they can go back to feeding their lives 24/7 to the state at their unbeknownst (or simply ignored) oppression.
OH GREAT, THEN CRIMINAL CHARGES SHOULD NOW BE PENDING, CORRECT?
I hope to God that they will someday catch that worthless traitor Snowden and hang him till he’s dead!
Are you mad that the NSA cannot only spy on everybody, but also harass people they do not like, kind of Gestapo / KGB / STASI ?
If Snowden didn’t disclose FB wouldn’t be getting sued for billions right now in Ireland by governments and private non US or Canadien citizens since they sold our info to US and we “agreed” to it !
I can not live in a place that is constantly at war with human beings as the united states is. I guess if I was the worst terrorist organization in the world i to would be paranoid about what citizens may think or say. The answer would be to app killing people but even or people beg for a constant diet of orher people’s blood.
Relax! The solution has been here all along:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VDqk8o6y13Y
lol
And Jeb Bush opposed Rand Paul’s attempt to stop Lying Mitch and B.H. Obama. What does it take to awaken the leftist progressives of the Democrat Plantation and the RINO Grand Old Peculators? Are they really in cahoots to destroy a free USA?
Was this before they started cooperating or after? Once they became “Friend” there was no need to get into this subterfuge, unless this was a rehearsal for trying out the trick on Baidu.
The NSA is a HOAX……. And we have the proof….. Google this…… Wellaware1.
What happened to freedom of speech? I didn’t want to even use my name real name, but you gotta enter an email address too.
It’s pretty bad when you fear your own government taking you out, for telling it like it is.
WE THE PEOPLE are SO MUCH bigger than those thugs who we elected. But how does one person convince millions to come together and kick em ALL out on their heads? … Then start fresh with people who love this country.
At some point, if this is allowed to continue, we must reconsider the legitimacy of the Federal Government and govern OURSELVES accordingly.
Well could we expect anything less from our dumb-ass Government ? Big brother has been watching all we do for a long time. But screw them and the jackass they rode in on !!!!!!!
Wow.
Congratulations, Mr. Gallagher, and this shows yet again the value of the Snowden documents, and TI’s publication of them. The only question now is how much economic damage this prank has caused; if anybody can hack app stores, it’s a question of whether the hack leaves the store vulnerable to other hackers. It’s almost like investigators breaking a warehouse lock and then leaving it broken. There’s also the question of what this costs Google and Samsung in sales.
Oh, and the app stores don’t just service smartphones. Samsung, for instance, sells flat-screen TVs, DVD players and other entertainment devices that also use downloadable apps. We already know that voice-recognition devices, including TVs, can read and maybe pass on whatever voices it hears, and consumers may start getting leery. I wonder if Samsung and Google have gone silent because they’re cooking up a major lawsuit?
I wonder if Samsung and Google have gone silent because they’re cooking up a major lawsuit? That might be one of the funniest things I’ve read on this site ever. Google is part of the government and Samsung is just as beholden of it. They are silent because they have been complicit.
Complicit, maybe, but they just might care about their profits. It’s not the gummint that buys all their flat-screens and DVD players and apps. If there’s anything about a gangster mentality, it’s that they don’t like it when the other mob starts chiseling. I still would like to see a big lawsuit, it’s the romantic in me.
Yes and No. I know, how wishy washy could I be? Business, after all, is what all the players are engaged in. All of it is designed to pick the pockets of us to give to them. Every business, complicit or competing, will take exception when that flow of money is impeded. The fact that CBC gave credit to TI in their report shines a tantalizing ray of hope in an otherwise utterly depressing, corrupt, adverserial, oppresive form of governing we find ourselves living in. I have to admit to sometimes feeling like that horse drawing the cart with a carrot dangling in front. Can’t go back though. Thanks Ryan.
I don’t understand what you mean by this or what you are getting at by this:
Of course CBC gave credit to The Intercept in their report. They could not have done the report without The Intercept. What is it that you find even remarkable about CBC acknowledging The Intercept in their article? They simply stated how the report came to fruition: CBC News analysed the top secret document in collaboration with U.S. news site The Intercept, a website that is devoted in part to reporting on the classified documents leaked by U.S. whistleblower Edward Snowden. And why does CBC haven done that cause you to celebrate a ‘tantalizing ray of hope’? Seriously, I don’t understand your thinking on any of that.
Google Samsung Government
All bedfellows.
You forgot FB. The US buys info from them all. Funny when the US sued Google and FB a few years back case was dismissed???
FBI Cointelpro 2015
FBI Stingray cell spying is
capable of installation of
mal ware directly.
man in the middle
IMSI Catcher
And while we’re reminding people of covert activities, here’s an article on the Navy’s experimentation with electromagnetic weapons — which I too have been subjected to.
http://www.truth-out.org/news/item/28009-documents-show-navy-s-electromagnetic-warfare-training-would-harm-humans-and-wildlife
Okay. Thanks for pulling that all together. Surveillance using stingray has met with new rules from FBI-DOJ saying they need a warrant effective now. Some people think that’s a form of codifying surveillance. If you can target an individual and delete the rest as ancillary information, that’s a decent call for the justice system to make. The outlying problem may be local PDs who are not in federal jurisdictions are still in murky waters with zero regulatory conventions. Their use of IMSI is held up only by purchase orders and a gear contract. In those cases, I’m really happy to tell the world evidence collected for prosecution will get thrown out without a warrant based on precedents.
What I’m afraid of is, what happens when the NSA hackers who are paid to do this all of a sudden decide that they no longer want to work for the NSA and want to offer their expertise in this sort of activity to the highest bidder? The first mass-hacking cyberterrorist incident will not be fun.
As an actual threat to your average American, Canuck, Kiwi, Aussie and Brit, terrorism ranks up there with lightning and shark attacks.
All this effort, and meanwhile the real threats… identity thieves, economic hackers, Wall Streeters, etc. are flourishing.
Spook budgets need to be cut by 90%, with the rest redirected to renewable energy, cancer research, education, etc.
Do the same for military budgets, and we’d have a world with far fewer problems and far fewer people motivated to blow shit up.
Every word makes sense. Except that politicians need money to seek office. And the most prolifogate with money are those weapons/military/surveillance merchants. Even Rand Paul recently supported more budget for military, which is criminal. So until we get rid of Citizens United and return limits to campaign spending, absolutely nothing is going to change.
He said he would support more military spending only if we cut elsewhere, namely entitlements. He was trying to make a philosophical point while at same time deflecting attacks from hawks that he is weak on defense.
Uh, profligate.
Even before Citizens United, politicians were selling out to the military builders/contractors and other interests
You are absolutely correct. We do not need a military. China is growing its own military by leaps and bounds and will protect us from those bad old Aussies.
Edward Snowden is a hero. Our Government has become so tyrannical,it has to be completely overthrown ,and every single elected official tried and punished severely for their crimes against the constitution &the American People.We will have to start from scratch and rebuild this once great Nation.Otherwise,the FEMA camps await all true patriots.
For decades all the offices of the administrations (our government) have been doing what ever they want. Now that what they our doing something to its own people in their country, they want to speak up. How self centered. No wonder the Europeans are moving towards hate of the US. These things have to be stopped immediately when discovered. We the people are truly leaderless here and its time to have someone step up and lead for what’s right or its time to build a new system.
do you ppl really believe this? like NSA would need such tactics. This website should rename to National Enqirer or something as lome
I took my own stand on the matter, because this is only one small part of the Patriot Act and even if it’s not renewed we all know they’re going to keep doing it. Besides they have passed things like the John Warner Defense Authorization Act and several NDAA’s since that only expand their powers and as a law abiding citizen in a country whose government no longer is, I know I need to protect myself.
So, I got a signal blocking hard case and a pager, that way if the wife or the office needs me, they just page me or send me a text or email to the pager; it’s up to me to call them back when I want to. Honestly, it’s kinda nice, no more electronic leash around my neck. The messages sent to the pager aren’t “encrypted” (not like that protects you either) so the messages are really basic, “pick up milk on the way home”, “the contracts are ready to pick up when you get back to the office” “Alex, Gary called looking for you”, etc.
I tried 4 of the soft cases on the market and they are totally unreliable, they may be cheap, but they don’t work. The signal blocking hard case I purchased did exactly what I paid for it to do and I’ve tried it right next to the cell towers and it still blocks everything; texts, calls, email, etc.
If you’re a law abiding citizen of this country, take a stand and protect yourself from a system that no longer adheres to the law: get a signal blocking hard case.
Aren’t Google and NSA supposed to be friends?
Note that only one member of Congress, Rand Paul, is standing against all this.
Noted!
Your gov is corrupt beyond repair. Nothing will correct this orwellian mess and restore the constitution as the law of the land until after the collapse when we drag every single one of them from their bunkers and hang them for treason!
Agreed 1000%
Now this is why I agree with Rick: this morning on NPR’s Marketplace, Diana Farrell spoke of a report she had compiled on the precarious financial situation of most Americans today — except both she and the cretin on Marketplace neglected that she profited greatly from bringing about this horrible situation she has the utter, amoral and criminal audacity to speak on!
Farrell, who has literally helped offshore millions of American jobs, destroying countless lives in the process, and forever miaming many others, has established the JP Morgan Chase Institute for the public good (and negative, I am not being facetious!).
She was the director at McKinsey Global Institute, with Rajat Gupta a partner (for a great summary of what they were about please see pp. 139-140 of the book, The Billionaire’s Apprentice, by Anita Raghavan) and gave most enlightening talks on offshoring or direct investment, as portrayed in the Youtube below (although you never see the audience, composed of the young elites from China, India, Vietnam and Bangladesh):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ETvt4_uI81o
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diana_Farrell
Formerly, she was with Goldman Sachs, and doing much the same thing she did at McKinsey (and probably why Obama appointed her to the economics council, and her being a non-economist):
http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Goldman_Sachs
The NSA is a bunch of wimps. They either don’t have the balls to spy on our real enemies or they just don’t have the technical wherewithal to be able to hack folks like the Chinese or the Russians. So they go after the easy targets, the US public. Think about it, your taxes are paying for the NSA to spy on you.
“Through under-the-table agreements to collect everything on each other’s citizens (but not wittingly their own) – and then throw all that over the fence, so to speak, it might be that technically no crime occurs.”
I think you nailed it here – and you can see it in the Canadian response (they didn’t spy on their citizens, but you can bet one or more of the other Five Eyes members did and passed that information back to the Canadians).
Follow the law to the letter of the law while intentionally doing the opposite of its intended purpose – sounds like what you’d expect from the corrupt out of control intelligence/military apparatus of a 2 bit banana republic, but its actually the U.S. intelligence apparatus (and friends) who have totally gone off the reservation.
I was meditating last night on something I had read in the Bible years ago, and I am sorry if being a Christian offends anyone, and something finally made sense, an epiphany, if you will. Jesus was calling out the scribes and Pharisees for following the letter of the law, who strain out a gnat and swallow a camel, while ignoring weightier provisions of the law, justice and mercy. And there’s the trap of the law. The law must be written in our heart. It took watching my own government stretching the credibility of the letter of the law to the breaking point, to finally get through my thick skull. Once again, apologies if my faith offends, and if it does, try to look past that offense and see the lesson to be learned.
If you think this is anything but a continuation of the law as a weapon of mass destruction, please see the monstrous decision rendered by the monster himself, Oliver Wendell Holmes, in Buck v. Bell:
http://www.encyclopediavirginia.org/buck_v_bell_1927
Any agnostic or atheist who cannot or will not acknowledge the power of any word, especially one believed by millions of people, shouldn’t be judging anybody. Mankind’s stories, myths, parables, and allegories all have a lot to teach us. Some of it is maybe “bad” but there are universal truths in all religions that deserve at least the respect of consideration. The bible may have been a book decided upon via committee but that doesn’t mean that it has nothing to teach people (as does the Quran, the Bhagavad Gita, the Tao Te Ching, and most other forms of “scripture”). I am most assuredly not a Christian but nor are most “Christians” posing as “Christians” (including many if not most of the US’s political leaders). Anybody that’d dismiss you based solely on your religion completely and totally misses the point of faith (as opposed to religion) in the first place.
Totally OT but your reticence saddened me to read. All systems, including religion, are broken (or will be) but anybody arguing against basic values like compassion and using that against you as though your source makes it more or less valuable has a lot to learn. What’s funny is how much Christianity, Islam, and Judaism have in common when it comes to their original core values, including compassion, at their roots. Mankind, as a rule, corrupts meanings — just like the NSA does with laws and the Constitution — and poisons the whole orchard.
i don’t think that people are offended by Christians, it’s just that there are so many OFFENSIVE Christians, and that gets people going. There’s Westboro Baptist Church and that Pat Robertson person and the crazy minister man in Florida that just had to burn a Koran. And a lot of people in government don’t seem to be able to understand the 1st Amendment.
If the Jesus person existed, there were some nice thoughts and ideas there, but then, he is actually quoted as saying that , who is not with me is against me, and GW used that to go to Iraq.
All religions have good and often similar ideas, but too many of all religions hide behind words and then do their covert actions which seem to be fascist a lot of the time.
America should probably meditate on NOT bearing false witness. : )
The smartest and truest thing I ever read was from a guy named Hillel who was asked to explain the meaning of the Torah while standing on one foot, and he said to treat others the way that you want to be treated and everything else in the Torah is commentary.
That sounds right, although that religion has some pretty screwy things in it too, plus running off with other cultures stories and acting like theirs were the first. ( i.e. Noah) I like the Unim and Thurmin ( sp? ) idea, because it’s really Star Wars style, the flashing colored breastplate of answers. : )
So, please don’t apologize, because you seem like a smart and good person, and all religions share those people too. : )
I am sure that I’ve offended some people too by writing this, but no one should ever apologize for using free speech—-maybe that’s what”Use it or lose it,” really means in the 21st century
I agree! The LAW OF THE LORD SHALL ALWAYS COME FIRST. I WILL NEVER APOLOGIZE FOR OFFENDING SOMEONE BECAUSE I AM A CHRISTIAN! THE PROBLEM IS THE “LAW MAKERS” ARE NOW THE LAW BREAKERS!! I THINK THIS IS THE MESSAGE JESUS WAS MAKING. IF YOU FOLLOW THE “LAW OF MAN” ,I.e.YOUR HEAD, YOU WILL NOT FOLLOW THE “LAWS OF THE HEART”, ! CHRIST KNEW THIS OVER 2000 YEARS AGO WHEN HE TURNED OVER THE TABLES OF THE ” TAX COLLECTORS “, . FUNNY HOW THAT SAME PRINCIPAL APPLIES TODAY!! CHRIST KNEW THEN WHAT CORRUPTION THAT ” THE TAX COLLECTORS, (GOVERNMENT) WOULD BE CAPABLE OF AS THEY THOUGHT WITH THEIR HEADS & NOT THEIR HEARTS. NOW WE HAVE THE GREATEST NATION MAN HAS EVER KNOWN, THE TAX COLLECTORS WILL ALWAYS BE CURRUPT. SOME MAY ENTER WITH BA HONEST HEART THINKING THEY COULD POSSIBLY CHANGE THIS CORRUPTION, BUT ONCE THEIR IN THE BELLY OF “THE BEAST”,: THEY FIND OUT THAT EITHER THEY STAY & JOIN THE CORRUPTION, OR THEY ARE OUT OF A CAREER! FINALLY, I BELIEVE (& THIS IS NOT A CRITICISM OF CATHOLICISM), BUT THIS IS WHY THE POPE WHO STEPPED DOWN JUST AFTER A SHORT TIME, FOUND HIMSELF AMONG THE VERY SAME ” TAX COLLECTORS “, & MADE A VERY WISE DECISION. HEAVEN IS BETTER THAN HELL!
Title is misleading. This is click bait as usual. The App Store belongs to apple. Title trying to misguide you into thinking this effects apple devices. Wrong, very wrong. And this just shows why apple is light years ahead of Google and Samsung in user security.
America needs another revolution. The federal government is the enemy of liberty.
Why is it the government wants to take away all of our rights and spy on us to keep us safe from terrorism, all the while letting in Muslim radicals and having them teach at our universities. They also let the borders with Mexico remain unchecked where Muslim radicals filter in on a regular basis. It is a game to take away our freedoms and control us. Obama hates America and his main goal is to reduce us to a third world, bankrupt country. As Obama’s friend said, “God damn America,” and Obama wants to help his god proceed with this destruction.
Even that pro-surveillance d!ckhead Eric Schmidt will be pissed about this one!
Eric Schmidt probably gave them the idea. Schmidt is a Fascist who only cares about his own greedy appetites. What a pig he is — along with rest of tech gods. Even Apple’s Tim Cook isn’t concerned enough — if he were he’d make iphones with removeable batteries.
I’d settle for a 5-cent hard power switch.
James Clapper: not wittingly.
Once again making me exceedingly happy with my decision to keep everyday life as low-tech as possible, though I do prefer power tools to the manual kind. And more and more, Mr. Gallagher, I’m beginning to now believe in that international bulk-collection “reach-around” I once jokingly described – as a very real thing, especially within Five Eyes. Each story like this one, with its very carefully worded statements concerning their data collection, further convinces of the possibility they could skirt every law ever written on the subject in their respective countries. Through under-the-table agreements to collect everything on each other’s citizens (but not wittingly their own) – and then throw all that over the fence, so to speak, it might be that technically no crime occurs. Devious bastiches…
Exactly!!! Devious Hypocrites all.
But please keep in mind, even though one keeps their lives as low-tech as possible, the gov’t contracts for surveillance include those automotive computer systems such as OnStar, those cams at toll booths, those pay-per-view at motels and hotels, plus an enormous array of sensors at every conceivable level, plust they’ve owned our landlines since around 1973-74.
You’re not wrong, sarge, Onstar could be used as a gps lojack or mic even if not paying for the service. In some older cars you can just unplug the mirror though, but you’re right it won’t make any difference under blimp sensors.
Doesn’t military have technology to make planes invisible to radar? Time to bring that product down market.
This type of data spying / sharing between countries has been going on since at least the 1980’s. Suggested book: “The Puzzle Palace” by Bamford
So if this is a report on a possible attack to Google and Samsung, what is the Apple logo doing in the image associated with the story?
Spook gangs are criminals and enemies of the US Constitution.
They are known to have been involved in blackmail, commercial espionage, spying on their own countries, and narcotics trafficking.
Why are they not all in prison? Is there any reason beyond their remarkable ability to blackmail judges and lawmakers?
People are not familiar with the power structure of this country. Unbelievable as it sounds but true. WE THE PEOPLE have the power, the ultimate power, but few people will actually hold those rights violators accountable. I would love to walk in to D.C. And arrest the whole lot but I would need hundreds of thousands behind me.
You’re damn right Phil! It’s high time that people in this country remembered who we are and the power we really control in this country.
There are thousands to hundreds if thousands working for this machine. That so few have blown the whistle is the most frightening. How has the population become so poisoned? As the campaign against me continues, more and more neighbors are bought out with financial incentives. I would have never in a million years done to these people what they have done to me. Even if I didn’t know or like them — I’m not a disgusting spy. And where are the reporters and lawyers? All dining with Brennan at cocktail parties?
The propaganda machine starts working on you from birth, and it’s a finely honed weapon.
You make excellent points and I concur “That so few have blown the whistle is the most frightening.”
And since 9/11/01, we know there was just one whistleblower, forced to resign, at the DIA (Julie Sirrs), and five reliable FBI agents who tried to warn of the impending attacks (Cowleen Rowley, Harry Samit, Kenneth Williams, and several others), and not a single CIA type!
use https://f-droid.org/
Every single time that “Five Eyes” intelligence agencies have been caught with their eyes inside all of our devices they’ve released the same boiler plate response:
a) Because terrorism.
b) Everything we go is legal.
c) There’s oversight.
d) We don’t violate our own citizens rights, only everyone else’s.
What the AU, US, CA, NZ, UK is doing is:
a) terrorism – Terrorism is commonly defined as violent acts (or the threat of violent acts) intended to create fear (terror), perpetrated for an economic, religious, political, or ideological goal, and which deliberately target or disregard the safety of non-combatants (e.g., neutral military personnel or civilians)
What the AU, US, CA, NZ, UK is doing is:
b) illegal and violates universal human rights law as well as local laws, with the exception of laws they’ve created and enacted specifically to violate our rights. It’s legal because though it used to be illegal, we made it legal.
What the AU, US, CA, NZ, UK is doing is:
c) completely without restraint and accountability. No matter who is elected, no matter what laws or bodies are put in place to curtail their power grabs, they are untouchable. Even when they are caught committing felonies they are never held to account.
What the AU, US, CA, NZ, UK is doing is:
d) blatantly lying. Yes, all of the “Five Eyes” ARE violating their OWN citizen’s rights, AND they’re doing it by proxy. The US spies on UK citizens, AU spies on UK citizens, etc.
Until we get money out of politics, hold public officials accountable for their crimes, and on and on and on… we’re on the highway to hell.