GOVERNMENT SURVEILLANCE IS not an abstract thing, says Hamid Khan, coordinator for the Stop LAPD Spying Coalition. For the communities Khan works with in Los Angeles — from transgender people to recipients of government benefits to the homeless on Skid Row — surveillance is a daily reality that impacts their lives and exacerbates other societal ills, like mass incarceration and police violence.
Khan’s coalition works to track, publicize, and ultimately dismantle the highly intrusive ways the Los Angeles Police Department surveils the area’s citizens, using an infrastructure of advanced intelligence gathering linked to federal government counterterrorism initiatives.
The LAPD uses big data for “predictive policing,” street cameras with highly accurate facial recognition capabilities, Stingrays, and DRT boxes — which imitate cellphone towers to track nearby phones or jam signals — automatic license plate readers, body cameras, and drones.
“How many different ways are our bodies being constantly tracked, traced, and monitored, not just online?” Khan asked in a phone interview.
Khan, originally from Pakistan, will be speaking at a much-anticipated Georgetown University Center on Privacy & Technology conference on Friday devoted to “The Color of Surveillance: Government Monitoring of the Black Community.”The Stop LAPD Spying Coalition had already been around for two years before the world learned about Edward Snowden and his trove of documents about the NSA’s spying operations, Khan said.
It started in the summer of 2011, when the coalition started inviting different groups of people to meet and talk about what surveillance — and “being a suspect” — meant to them. Meetings like that still take place every first Monday of the month.
In March 2013, the coalition published a “People’s Audit” of the Los Angeles Police Department’s information sharing, suspicious activity reporting, and predictive policing tactics — the first of three reports.
The group has since published a diagram of the entire visible “architecture of surveillance” in L.A., which they say is driven by a hunger for data, aggressive and predictive policing, and corporate profit from surveillance technology.
Whether you’re in a public park picked up on a video camera, tracked through use of your Electronic Benefit Transfer card at the grocery store, or someone reports you for vague “suspicious activity” without any evidence — the regime of total monitoring takes shape, Khan explained.
Many of the policies adopted in L.A., he says, were originally developed to fight terrorism overseas — including predictive policing methods first funded by the U.S. military to track insurgents in Iraq and Afghanistan. Now they’re “becoming a part of local policing,” Khan said.
The coalition discovered that the National Suspicious Activity Reporting Initiative, launched in 2008, gives LAPD license to “write up secret files on individuals based on speculation and hunches.” The group learned from an LAPD inspector general report in 2014 that over 30 percent of these reports are written about black people in L.A. — where less than 10 percent of the entire population is black. Khan says the LAPD argued those numbers weren’t troubling, because the number of reports overall wasn’t that large. But the group argues it’s still disproportionate.
And according to intelligence-gathering guidelines published in 2012, the FBI can embed informants in political group advocacy meetings for up to six months based on a tip alone, or an “initial lead.”
Technology is a big part of the pervasiveness, Khan says. “The surveillance has always been there, but the rate of technology and information sharing” has outpaced what’s reasonable.
Sometimes, surveillance and harassment are essentially one and the same. One man featured in a video the group produced explained that police officers will linger nearby Skid Row and wait for people to leave for a few minutes, then seize their property as if it were abandoned.
Currently, the group is investigating the practice of surveillance of public benefits programs involving the Department of Children and Family Services — conducting interviews with people who receive public benefits and submitting Freedom of Information Act requests for more information, to determine the extent of the monitoring and how it might affect particularly homeless and poor people.
The group is also trying to learn more about the LAPD’s predictive policing and the information used to inform the algorithms, to determine what factors indicate to police that a certain neighborhood or person might become dangerous.
Besides actively challenging surveillance tactics employed by local police, Khan says the group wants to “de-sensationalize” the language of surveillance. We want to “bring it down to every day, 24/7,” he told me over the phone. Because for many in L.A., “privacy is not a right but a privilege,” he said.
Most people he works with, he said, “don’t care much about encryption” — because physical privacy alone is so far out of reach.
glad i’m not american, and not living in the police state. Although the american style of militarized police is creeping everywhere else.
USE TOR BROWSER – TAILS OS – DISCONNECT APP ON IPHONE WHEN ON WIFI – USE SIGNAL ** BUY AN FARADAY IPHONE CASE**
Police departments are at the lower end of the STASI minion pole. This is going on globally, members of NATO. In the u.s. includes DoJ.
Well, if you are walking around with a phone you are on a leash. If you are using wifi at home, you are on a leash. If you have that capability in your car, you are on a leash. If you aren’t using Tor, you are on a leash. Woof Woof folk’s. Get rid of anything and everything that is wifi capable. Use Linux Mint or another open source OS. That is at least a start but still and all we are coming apart at the seams.
TAILS
Los Angeles is where all the voyeurs and filmmakers go. They want to see everything. That metro is a very strange place sometimes. The culture is constantly posing, acting, projecting. You don’t know what is real or who is real. The unions drive out innocent people. Agents are constantly power-tripping becuase they don’t where their next multi-million production budget is coming from. People don’t know if they’re going to make rent in a Hollywood closet with a toilet and 2 roommates. It’s insane. The cops are part of that balmy distorted identity. They go to acting classes. Federal agents plant people in parks so they learn how to trail people. Actresses stand on corners and pretend to be agents of the law. Its not an easy place to figure things out. I know I never really felt private or safe there.
Understood. We live in a mutant contrived society that produces nothing and is oversaturated with entertainment of fantasies and political power addicts with lies. What could possibly go bad?
Go to the dentist, have some deep fillings….. without novacaine. This is the current state of surveillance. The people of America are getting drilled without the pain relief.
Surveillance was supposed to be here to keep people safe. But the people in charge of it are not really concerned about your life because if they were, they would be providing the pain relief of homelessness, hunger, and joblessness. The reality is, surveillance is here to prevent the people from having their voices rule the government they are supposed to own but which is owned by predatory wallstreet corporate thieves.
If they were truly using these tools to ‘keep us safe’, there would be nearly no premeditated crimes.
bingo
ALPR should never be used on American roads. The risk to personal privacy is too great. see http://www.sunflexzone.com
A YT clip of Khan back in 2013:
https://youtu.be/Lf-ZjtLpHTM
Thanks, Jenna. I hope that you’ll keep pressing forward. There’s so much more to this story. There’s Pulitzer material for someone enterprising and smart.
But when I go out to fly my toy helicopter everyone is up in arms and hysterical that their privacy is being “violated”.
Even though they are in a public area.
Idiots.
Something seems to be missing from this article, like a strong perspective. It reads more like an abstract.
In addition to: ” street cameras with highly accurate facial recognition capabilities, stingrays and DRT boxes — which imitate cell phone towers to track nearby phones or jam signals — automatic license plate readers, body cameras, and drones”, you forgot to mention the LAPD’s networking database which makes a networking map on everyone within LA county. This networking database makes a networking tree about who everybody contacts & knows, all with the blessing of the FBI and presumably the NSA.
The next time any of you go to Disneyland, Santa Monica, Knotts Berry Farm, Magic Mountain, or Southern California, be aware Big brother is watching.
The same Big Brother that gave you: The Rodney King beating, PDID, Rafael Perez, David Mack, & all the other “Rogue cops” of the Rampart Division.
What’s next for the LAPD? Water-boarding & (Dick Cheney’s favorite) Anal re-hydration?
There are so many problems in california that it will probably degrade into a country like nigeria or uganda, or egypt, or syria eventually. Sad to say the only thing that will bring people toether in that state is a huge quake.
“Down to earth” is something more like this: http://www.b12partners.net/wp/2014/05/04/city-of-chicago-emergency-management-surveillance-vehicle-was-uploaded-to-flickr/
Now can someone ask the person on the video whether the LAPD vehicle looked like that, or is their identity known only to LAPD and whoever made the video?
So, um, how about some predictive policing for police killings, yeah?
Woah….. You just blew my mind S
I am not well satisfied with the video. Oh, I’m sure the LAPD and the NSA know who these people are, but I don’t know them from Adam, so what’s the point of making me download 46 megabytes of crap just to hear a few sentences of allegation?
To be clear, the allegation about police watching people on Skid Row and seizing their stuff is serious and needs to get investigated. It is especially important because it emphasizes the double standard of surveillance when it comes to abusing people. If the police are going to watch people, track their faces in city-wide software, keep lists of who is on Skid Row, and target them for bullying, then they should not get away with claiming that “oh, we found this abandoned property, gee, we didn’t know whose it was.” When you start playing god you have to stop playing stupid!!! And that also applies if they see someone is sick, if they see someone is freezing. If they’re going to put all this money into watching what goes on, then they have an obligation to help when they see something bad is happening.
“When you start playing god you have to stop playing stupid!!! “
profound.
Welcome to the most over policed and over incarcerated community in America.
Coming to your community very soon!
The insanity is beyond compare unless we go back to 1790 france.
Stupid me, i just had thought this was the 21st century.
Stupid me, i just thought human beings could learn.
Stupid me, i just figured that christians actually followed the teaching of Jesus.
Probably a good place to start is in listing the Intelligence units at play in LA. The LAPD probably has an intelligence unit to aggregate all the collected intelligence. It then likely shares this with an FBI unit. Look for a DHS Fusion Center.
It would be nice to see a map of the units involved and their relationships.
http://www.thenewamerican.com/usnews/item/16942-dhs-creates-new-fusion-centers-taking-control-of-local-police
America is the new apartheid monster having learned by the adoption of zionista principles of treating the population like palestinians.
police forces in the U.S. are the American IDF.
Tracking people without a significant investment in technology domestically.
Suspicious Activity Reports. False accusations by anonymous parties in your permanent record.