Organizers for the Stand Together Against Trump rally in Cleveland had planned for 5,000 participants. The march, a peaceful demonstration that “America’s fundamental ideals of liberty and equality are greater than Trump’s incessant scapegoating and bullying,” was supposed to close out a week that some had predicted would overshadow the 1968 Democratic Convention in Chicago, which came amid nationwide civil unrest and race riots and exploded in violence.
But there was no mayhem in Cleveland.
On Thursday, hours before Donald Trump took the stage to accept the nomination, a couple hundred people showed up for what had been expected to be one of the week’s largest events. The event did in fact turn out to be one of the largest in a series of relatively unimpressive ones — a fitting end to the massive protests that never were.
I feel like I'm crossing the Sahara… And there's a protest on the other side of it #RNCinCLE pic.twitter.com/w92JNSPRpv
— Alice Speri (@alicesperi) July 21, 2016
It's like Trump's wall went up in Cleveland overnight #RNCinCLE pic.twitter.com/I9ZKgInPKy
— Alice Speri (@alicesperi) July 21, 2016
Abandon all hope ye who enter #RNCinCLE pic.twitter.com/PW8qXCvfiR
— Alice Speri (@alicesperi) July 21, 2016
Those who made it to the rally — trekking out in scorching heat to a designated parade route a half-hour walk from the convention center — were unrelenting. On a long bridge overpassing a desolate industrial zone, nowhere close to the buzz of the convention center but also far from cars, passersby, or really any sign of life, they carried hopeful signs claiming “We’re better than this” and “Love trumps hate” and chanted “Vote your conscience” in a nod to Ted Cruz’s words the night prior.
People chanting "Vote your conscience" #RNCinCLE pic.twitter.com/fAC8luf8Fo
— Alice Speri (@alicesperi) July 21, 2016
But their physical isolation in a deserted section of the city sent a stronger message.
A line of bored police officers on bikes — a trademark of the convention — stopped the protesters, without too much enthusiasm, as soon as they came in sight of the city’s downtown skyline.
Guess we're not allowed through here? #RNCinCLE pic.twitter.com/VaiRvbLWxC
— Alice Speri (@alicesperi) July 21, 2016
Surrounded by metal gates on one side and a dirt hill on the other, demonstrators shouted, unironically, “This is what democracy looks like.” Then they turned around and went back to where they came from — an empty lot that the ACLU, which sued the city over the remoteness of the official parade route, called an “industrial wasteland.”
Last glimmer of resistance crossing the Cleveland desert #RNCinCLE pic.twitter.com/SGaBRomIXA
— Alice Speri (@alicesperi) July 21, 2016
Thanks to the ACLU lawsuit, which led to a settlement with the city easing up some of the restrictions on protest, not all rallies this week were confined to a highway in the middle of nowhere. But even those that took place downtown struggled to make a mark, and the drama on the convention floor far outdid that on the streets.
“Last night was a quiet night,” Cleveland Mayor Frank Jackson told reporters at a Thursday morning press conference, repeating what he had said every other morning this week. “We don’t have much to report on.”
In total, 24 people were arrested in convention-related incidents as of Friday morning, most at a flag burning protest on Wednesday. But while legal observers denounced those arrests, and delays in the processing of arrestees, as “troubling,” the final count was significantly lower than what most expected, with the city having announced ahead of the convention that it was prepared to “handle upwards of 1,000 arrests per day.”
With hours to go to the official nomination, the mayor and Cleveland Police Chief Calvin Williams seemed both relieved the week had passed without major incidents and mindful not to jinx their good luck before it was really over. “We still have an entire day to go through,” Williams said. But in a sign that the fear of chaos had largely passed, he spent the rest of the time talking about the heat expected in the city for the last day of the convention — well into the 90s.
“If you’re a protester, bring some water with you,” he said. “It’s going to be hot.”
The heat didn’t stop a few last attempts at resistance. On Thursday afternoon, a small group of protesters, including a handful with masks and bandanas over their faces, briefly spilled into the streets, chanting, “Our streets,” while a couple of rival protesters shouted back at them, “Socialism sucks.”
"Don't touch me!" #RNCinCLE pic.twitter.com/rSWzsNuJgF
— Alice Speri (@alicesperi) July 21, 2016
The arguing group circled around one of the downtown areas designated for protest a couple of times, swarmed by dozens of reporters and followed closely by even more officers on bikes. A few verbal confrontations ensued, as journalists, protesters, legal observers, and even a handful of police officers recorded every move on dozens of cameras and cellphones.
Then, as quickly as it had erupted, the last short-lived burst of protest ended at a nearby park, where volunteers with the Food Not Bombs group handed out apples and water to exhausted anarchists, Trump-supporters, and reporters alike. The RNC was almost over.
Rod Webber, an artist who came from Boston for the week and said he had been to 173 protests and political rallies this year alone, handed out yellow daisies to fellow protesters of all views — “offering a flower for de-escalation,” he said.
He and other activists staying at a house outside the city were raided by the FBI earlier this week, the latest in a series of similar incidents that civil rights advocates say have seriously stifled dissent and had a direct impact on the low turnout at the convention. And while the response to protesters didn’t escalate to the levels seen elsewhere, Webber denied it had been peaceful.
“Sure, no one has been shot, so it was peaceful in that sense,” he said, adding that protesters were sometimes pushed around and officers put guns “in people’s faces.” “I don’t want to have higher expectations for violence,” he added. “Any level of violence is unacceptable to me.”
Especially when you shoot them at people #RNCinCLE pic.twitter.com/T4KceiUHsp
— Alice Speri (@alicesperi) July 21, 2016
For Anna Fisher, a high schooler from Youngstown, Ohio, holding a “Guns save lives” sign, this was the very first protest.
“I thought it would be a little more violent,” she said, echoing what seemed to be a widely held sentiment.
By Thursday evening, Cleveland’s Public Square, which throughout the week had been home to preachers of all ideologies, anti-war grandmothers, gay bashers, supporters of black and blue lives, open carriers, and wall opponents, was filled with children playing in a water fountain and reporters napping on benches next to helmets and flak vests they never had to use.
A couple of locals walked around in shirts reading “Make America Cleveland again,” and out-of-towners started talking about next week’s Democratic convention in Philadelphia, sure it would be “bigger.”
We got a million people to march on Bangkok and kick out our corrupt government. THAT’S HOW YOU DO IT. Glenn loves his Arab Spring, but that was wank too. People knew what they wanted in Thailand, they knew how to get together and they knew how to get it. Western people are just too “meah” in body and soul.
Hillaryous;Its obvious the Clinton campaign said stay home,you’ll only hurt HRC,as Sanders was done in by Move on from the Hell Bitch,and their thug riots.
The so called progressive media has done everything ion its power to avoid covering progressive issues in a positive light. No articles about Stein and the Green party, no mention of secret speeches to the enemy and white noise, no coverage of e-mails that would have put anyone but a politician in prison.
They don’t call it the progressive media, they call it the liberal media, and that’s exactly what it is: it propagandizes for the liberal end of corporate America.
Progressive is an unclear and less than honest term anyway. On that end of the spectrum, you’re either liberal or radical on an issue, there’s nothing in between.
These Milquetoast protests are absolutely useless. If protestors don’t put the fear of god into ruling politicians or whomever they’re protesting against, the protests are failures. With protests being limited to designated areas, this is impossible, so we have to find new ways of putting fear into them. Continuing to play the same losing game only results in more losing.
Put the fear of god into them by voting third party in November. We know that either Trump or Hilary is going to win, but we want them to win with an embarrassingly low percentage of votes, like 39%.
POTUS? Fear? Unless you have intercontinental nukes or biological weapons, you’re outta luck on that game.
> Surrounded by metal gates on one side and a dirt hill on the other, demonstrators shouted, unironically, “this is what democracy looks like.”
If any sentence captures this whole bizarre, ridiculous, and rather humorously anti-climatic affair, it’s that one right there. Nicely done.
Having a protest march exiled to the outer reaches of nowhere is tantamount to disallowing allowing it. The protest organization should sue the City of Cleveland and the RNC for infringement of civil rights.
Your right to protest was effectively denied by limiting your access so much. If this is the trend, then every future protest should only be allowed to march in some secluded 100 sq ft. block out in a desert where no one can see or hear you.
—Delete the “allowing” after the disallowing…..typing too fast again….oopps.
Or better yet, your protest can only be held in your own home or in some arena you rent out.
Agree with your first sentence (as you amended it). Isn’t the whole purpose of a) exiling protests, b) raiding homes, etc., of protesters, c) tracking protesters/potential protesters on social media —- to CHILL dissent?
We’re in trouble…
It’s no surprise that so few showed up, given that protestors are in “Freedom Pens” so far away from the convention that the very people they are protesting will never see them, let alone the rest of America.
What a parody of freedom this really is.
Not to mention threatened with tear gas, pepper spray, a criminal record, and whatever other punishment they feel like. Even without being gunned down with live ammunition as in the past, protesting in America is dangerous business.
Well, Alice….you have a lot to learn. I am not “demon-ishing” or tarnishing your efforts. Just think for a second. How would YOU have planned these efforts differently.? You mean that Pokeymon GO can spread more quickly than the efforts and message than these “protester’s” issues? How many monsters where in this “vast Cleveland Wasteland” compared to the utopia of Philly next week..?
THAT is…the intercept news that is not being reported.
WAKE UP …Alice..!! I would highly wager that if you would watch a re-run of “Alice” and start chewing gum like Flo …….you may have a better conversation around the Intercept “pokeymon realm”. How do you think the Benghazi protesters in Philly next week will tag a few “Pickachu” jihadists..?
Your readers are waiting on your thoughts…….game on, Alice…game on.
What if they declared a police state and nobody showed up?
I for one am thrilled that the majority of dissidents refused to play the cop game. It will be very amusing if this trend continues to see the police demanding giganto budgets and new equipment for the purpose of “protecting” the cities at these events from
n o b o d y
Your comment makes no sense. The entire point of the police state is to discourage more people from coming. The fact that relatively few protesters showed up to this RNC shows that the police state is effective.
The jokes on you, not them.
luda says go play the cop game.
Go do cop theater with cops. Go get detained and maybe beaten up by cops. Go not get covered by the media while getting detained and beat up by cops.
Go justify cop budgets.
Go give cops the opportunity to try out their cool new technology on you. What will it be now? Sound weapons? A cool new kind of tear gas? Some kind of new tasers?
Go help the cops by being willing stooges for their R&D. I’m sure you are doing good under some weird definition understood by luda.
When Clinton is the alternative, it takes the gas out of any movement.
just because you can’t think outside of the binary doesn’t mean everybody else can’t
Where was the MSM coverage of the protesters and their views. I waited for and expected it as a counterbalance to the Convention. This could have helped compensate for the “planned” isolation. I may not totally agree with a message but I want it heard and I want to hear it loud and clear.How else do I stay informed and aware. The first amendment is as dear to me as all the rest. This sends a bad message you must comment chaos to be heard.
Same as yesterday: Blah blah. NOTHING today about Jill or Green in Alternet, Common Dreams, Truthdig, The Intercept, Think Progress, Mother Jones. and The Nation. How many days in a row is this? This is the progressive media. This is one more reason that the fabric of our society is scorched and burning. This is why the media is passe.
The reason why Jill doesn’t have much support is because her supporters are a minority voice. It has nothing to do with the media.
Blaming the progressive media for societal ills is literally no different than Sean Hannity blaming HRC for societal ills.
“NOTHING today about Jill or Green in Alternet, Common Dreams, Truthdig, The Intercept, Think Progress, Mother Jones. and The Nation.”
It’s shameful. One might think they were all conspiring to protect the duopoly.
The first sentence of your post is what is known as a “circular argument.”
That’s a step up for you, though.
Circular or not, she got .36% of the vote in 2012 and she won’t likely get much more in 2016. Blame the progressive media for not promoting her enough if you so desire, I simply disagree with that.
Because my opinion is .36% different than yours, that justifies an insult tho! Liberals are just like all humans. We can be assholes also.
Jill is currently polling at 5% dummy. This is a different election. Get that through your thick skull.
Your circular argument is dopey regardless of your politics or my politics. It is always dopey to write things that amount to “candidate x doesn’t have much support because candidate x’s supporters are a minority.” No kidding! What an insight!
But it is curious to see you piling on the foolishness, earnestly claiming that the media has no impact whatever on voting.
All that campaign advertising and media spin gone to waste, apparently…..You should let them know they can save all that money….
Also a factor in why she’s not being talked-about as much as Gary Johnson: ballot access. The Greens, last time I checked, are only on ballots in something like 15 states (my own, Missouri, is not one of them), while the Libertarians are on the ballot in most if not all states.
These so-called progressives — whatever that means, we should return to the more honest and clear labels of liberal and radical — are falling all over each other to get us to vote for Clinton, because they’re so scared of Trump. So the machine has worked perfectly: put up a candidate who’s so awful that the sheeple will vote for the other candidate who doesn’t seem so awful but who will advance the agenda of the rich and powerful, to the detriment of the Earth and everyone else who lives here.
I have totally lost respect for people I used to respect, like Michael Moore, who are now freaking out and admonishing people to vote for Clinton. I have one thing to say to these people: just because the people, non-humans, and planet that would be harmed by Clinton are not on your list of pet issues doesn’t mean that they aren’t as or more important than your pet issues. There’s no way that Trump would be as bad as Clinton on huge issues like war and trade, so choosing between these two piles of dung is a waste of time and effort. If you are anything beyond liberal, you should be voting Green, period. And even more important, you should be doing things that have far more effect than these phony elections, starting with how you live your own lives (for example, if you want to help the climate change problem, don’t drive or fly) and continuing to working on issues that you care about.
When did journalism go from posting a picture with a cut line that identified those in the photo… to publishing your twitter photos / snarky comments?
Why can’t you just report the news instead of trying to get more twitter followers? Your snarky twitter comments are not journalism, Alice.
You did a decent job at adversarial journalism with past assignments. (Your attributed quotes told the story you wanted to tell… clearly biased but still technically journalism.) Keep doing what you did… don’t evolve into another Mackey.
Quotations in a journalistic article are supposed to be from other people at the event, not from the reporter themself. Unless this is supposed to be filed under “blogs”, i would suggest The Intercept send this back to author for a rewrite. Even as a blog it is a bit self-serving to quote your own twitter feed…
The ult. we punked you; I’d be there were some LEOs itchin’ to dole out a good ole smack down on some protestors.
Meanwhile back Texas: http://www.nydailynews.com/news/crime/texas-police-officer-slams-woman-ground-video-article-1.2720928
And the 1st amendment goes out in a whimper.
“Free Speech” zones are for suckers and sheep.
Under plutocracy, complete committment to non-violence == complete submission to the 1%. Protests like these make Our Fearless Leaders truly that, since the 1% fears only one thing: that the rest of us (who they have called “The Mob” for centuries) will take their stuff. History shows, empirically, that when any oppressed minority foregoes even the *option* of violent resistance, they will first be kettled, then ignored. Cases for study include India and South Africa: in both, Tolstoyan/Gandhian non-violence failed before violent uprisings (the Indian National Army and Umkhonto we Sizwe, respectively) forced regime change.
India was before my time, but I was actively involved in anti-apartheid protests against the South African government. What forced regime change there had nothing to do with violent uprisings; the change was caused by a worldwide financial boycott of South Africa that finally made its government cry “uncle.” And the worldwide boycott in turn was produced mainly through nonviolent actions.
I am not nonviolent and fully agree that at least the threat of violent revolution must be maintained in order to have rulers at least respect us and our demands. (No such threat currently exists in the U.S., BTW.) But saying that violence is necessarily the only way is simply not true, and violence should always be the last resort.
Glad to see someone caught a Taxation is Theft sign