John Podesta, the Clinton campaign chairman whose hacked emails have exposed countless Democratic secrets to the world, was warned in 2008 to start protecting sensitive documents “by at least encrypting them.”
The warning came in an unencrypted email chain forwarded by Denis McDonough, then a top Obama campaign aide and currently the White House chief of staff, to Podesta, who at the time was running Obama’s transition team.
McDonough initially sent the warning to Obama economic adviser Daniel Tarullo in an email on November 3, 2008, the day before President Obama’s election victory, presumably in response to a detailed November 2 memo Tarullo sent around about the upcoming G-20 meeting President Bush had called to discuss the ongoing financial crisis.
McDonough wrote:
I was struck by the memo partly because it was first I had heard of it but much more because it was a sensitive doc bumping around on public email addresses.
There is a very real threat to the security of our documents (particularly sensitive ones like the one you worked up), and we need to protect them by at least encrypting them.
Tarullo emailed back:
I had never heard anything like this from either the campaign or the pre-transition effort and, in fact, have been receiving things of equal or greater sensitivity for some time from both sources. You guys are presumably much more likely to be made aware of such issues, so when the economic side of the transition gets named, you should probably get in touch with them to give guidance on this.
McDonough then forwarded the thread to Podesta, with the following comment:
Hey, John,
I know I’m like a broken record on this, but I think we should arrange a briefing on the cyber threat for all associated with your effort.
We have a real security threat on our stuff here. I would gladly work up something with our techie. We’ve developed a lot of expertise in this, unfortunately.
The email, ironically enough, showed up in Thursday morning’s release of the latest batch of Podesta’s emails being published daily by WikiLeaks. Their source is unclear; U.S. intelligence officials say they have evidence they were hacked by people working under Russian government supervision, but they have not made that evidence public.
The emails have spawned countless news articles, about Clinton’s private speeches to megabanks like Goldman Sachs, her campaign team’s coordination with Super PACs, internal squabbles about Clinton’s use of a private email server, how the Clinton Foundation enriched the Clintons, and many other subjects.
The earliest email from McDonough to Podesta about security seems to have come on October 12, 2008, when McDonough noted to Podesta, who was already well along in planning the transition: “we gotta figure our security. Our tech guy is in wdc tomorro.”
The fact that foreign actors were actively trying to hack U.S. presidential campaigns as well as the U.S. government was hardly a closely-held secret. As The Intercept reported in May, incoming members of the Obama administration were explicitly warned by the Office of the Director of National Intelligence that “foreign intelligence services have been tracking this election cycle like no other.”
McDonough himself is the sender and recipient of numerous nonencrypted emails in the trove, including many discussing personnel choices for top security and intelligence jobs.
Podesta, of course, continued to email in the clear at least through March 2016, when he was hacked, even when his communications included sensitive and embarrassing communications and passwords. We recently offered him some security tips.
Top photo: Then-White House counselor John Podesta (left) with Chief of Staff Denis McDonough in 2014.
“Look at me I am glorious, striding the world with my Mighty Mistress! Oh, shit, I am a zero…” Welcome to our world, bozo.
When the Wizard’s curtain flutters in Oz, the dull, sad, unimpressive people that deign to rule over us are revealed. But like drug dealers, take one down, give another his big break. The only way to stop either of them is to stop buying into their shit and brace for their hate-filled backlash.
I noticed there were no comments permitted on the lengthy Hillary advertisement called The Trumpdown about how well she handled her emails. What a shock. I’m glad that’s all settled now thanks to Intercept.
Yes, have noticed likewise in “progessive” venues– horrid hate Trump prose– where they ope the dictionary and list all possible words– with no comments or consideration.
Regardless of who is elected, their readership and support will have shrunk considerably.
Drsigned so that people do not engage in any thought other than what they want? Good, you can pay for the open borders and to support WS along the $hopeand$hange left jingling in you pockets!
The Empire Files: Abby Martin Exposes John Podesta
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9fat63bqvG8
Will a non- MSM link work this time???
http://www.globalresearch.ca/u-s-elections-november-chaos-what-youre-not-being-told/5554954
Thanks!
Most emails are sent across the internet in the clear. They are more like post cards than like letters anyone between you and the destination can read/save them. The NSA reportedly has over 100 taps into the internet backbone for precisely this reason.
Securing the internet is something institutions should be doing. It shouldn’t fall on individual users to secure things, it should be built into the system. Imagine if the US Post Office provided secure email services to all US citizens by law and it required a court order to unlock their emails. Instead, the government has deliberately made its citizens including Podesta insecure and now paying the price. For example, the new Chinese drone resembles American drone design in amazing detail. The same goes for their new stealth fighter.
It is kind of funny though. Podesta’s reason for not encrypting is probably something like, “Hey, I’ve got nothing to hide. Why bother?”
he was sending sensitive documents that weren’t protected, repeatedly, despite being warned. did you not read the article?
“McDonough initially sent the warning to Obama economic adviser Daniel Tarullo in an email on November 3, 2008, the day before President Obama’s election victory, presumably in response to a detailed November 2 memo Tarullo sent around about the upcoming G-20 meeting President Bush had called to discuss the ongoing financial crisis.”
it is very much “up to” people who work in positions dealing with sensitive and classified material not to expose that material on the internet. the government didn’t make podesta disregard these warnings.
Yes. Ditto your own personal info. You donot handle it the same way as you do other information.
It is not the governments responsibility to do anything.
The internet is very convenient but it may not be the proper tool for certain communications.
There have been photos of the Sr71 for quite sometime; it ishow old?
Also the form an function and technology reduce the designs to resembling each other: humans built structures on different continents yet they are quite similar.
From reading The Intercept, one can be certain that Clinton related email leaks exist.
Not groundbreaking journalism, is it?
Of course, this means the Intercept coverage of the the email leaks has been pathetic. Subservient. Muzzled. Stifled. Sterile.
Disappointing and shocking but not unexpected in this era of controlled press.
So which super pack do you work for
The IT allows comments with MSM links but not alternate site links?
Journalism deflection continues.
For secutiy
Security from what? The Truth?
No. electronic links safety. Dingdiong!
Really? Is this “alternate” enough to qualify?
World Socialist Web Site
How about the scary-crazy, vile and vicious, armed and dangerous, “alternate” as it gets fuckers over at. . .
Stormfront
???
Maybe you need to work on your linking technique.
You devil, you!!
… was warned in 2008 to start protecting sensitive documents “by at least encrypting them.”
Oh sure. Save your emails in an encrupted format, like at gmail? ymail? hotmail? Oh sure. What would the nsa have to say about that? Oh sure. Keep your business information encrypted private so that wallstreet thieves cant steal it and Dumb&Dumber of the USG – the whores for wallstreet – will make that illegal.
We got geniuses running the country, yeah, into the ground.
btw- not to imply anything negative about aging, but does JP look like he died 10 years ago, lost his teeth, and could be the star of a new reality show – GUMMERS THAT LIVE?
Well, the Intercept has this going for it–it’s not the Atlantic:
Why Is Hillary Clinton So Widely Loved?
http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/11/why-is-hillary-clinton-so-widely-loved/506402/?utm_source=atltw#article-comments
Widely-loved is an odd way to describe a politician whose most recent RCP average favorable-unfavorable rating is about 42%-54%.
Anyone wanna bet what the responses would be if the 42% were asked the followup, “How much do you love her?”
Wow. Just wow. Just forced myself to read this. What craven,ludicrous, false propoganda from the Atlantic.
The most horrifying thing of this election for me has been seeing how the liberal media–Atlantic, WaPo, NYT, etc pumps for Hillary as zealously as Pravda.
And the same with all my well-intentioned, decent liberal Facebook friends. All upper class comfy liberals. All blindly repeating the false b.s. that Hillary is the victim of misogynist conservatives and, oh, Russian hackers. Complete nonsense and they’re all pushing it. So depressing.
CBS: FBI finds emails related to Hillary Clinton’s State Department tenure on Weiner’s laptop.
http://www.cbsnews.com/news/fbi-finds-emails-related-to-hillary-clintons-state-department-tenure/
arising this AM i was immediately knocked right back down onto the bed upon seeing (as i was rising) an endoresement of Hellary from Pharrell stating (parafrasing here) “HELLARY IS THE BETTER LIAR”.
okaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay
>>> Podesta, of course, continued to email in the clear at least through March 2016, when he was hacked, even when his communications included sensitive and embarrassing communications and passwords. We recently offered him some security tips.<<<
TRUE STORY: A lawyer once said to me, "I don't understand that stuff!!! That's why I became a lawyer!!!!"
sure. The criminal minds of Dumb&Dumbers always looking within the colony and figure their best protection is not real talent but real threats. Sure, the public needs a better operating environment so what do Dumb&Dumbers do? They help their backers rob the public then threaten the public with legal prosecution for screwing up their criminal games of war, deprivation, dilapidation etc.
In real times the population would have rebolted and probably kneeled all of them but the Dumb&Dumbers instead passed the NDAA to rendition citizens and draft them into their pimps’ wars.
Agreed, xcet the Dumb ‘nombre’. Anything but.
Another Wikileaks revelation, this one released Thursday: Podesta had warned Hillary to stop talking about sensitive data on unsecured gmail chat accounts.
Intent? Why no, of course not.
Sloth in the face of clear warnings arises only from clear intention.
Nah. It may also arise from slothful arrogance.
The reasons not to vote for Clinton :
http://www.mostdamagingwikileaks.com/
This is his brand. This is his business model. He is a carnival barker. I’d vote for my cat fluffy over him. http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2016/11/trump-tower-goes-bust-canada-214412
As election tightens, Clinton steps up right-wing appeals wsws.org
http://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2016/11/03/elec-n03.html
Finally a relevant article,but total propaganda,unfortunately.
There is no evidence to tie Russia to any leaks,and the fact Snowden is silent as a clam in Russia,would underline that.
Are there possible people of Russkie ethnicity hacking insecure American idiot’s servers?Could be,but when the world’s citizens hate you,it is to be expected.
Poor poor Hillary,the moron who would be queen.
How about some revealing emails,and remember that wikileaks is doing the job you fifth estate posers aren’t,revealing facts about the most corrupt criminal people in the USA,the demoncrat apparatus, the Clintons and their co conspirators,the MSM,who have damaged and are trying to destroy democracy in America.
Notice the silence re content of leaks from almost every MSM and alleged progressive outlets?3 dollar bills.
>>> How about some revealing emails,and remember that wikileaks is doing the job you fifth estate posers aren’t,revealing facts about the most corrupt criminal people in the USA,the demoncrat apparatus, the Clintons and their co conspirators,the MSM,who have damaged and are trying to destroy democracy in America.<<<
Look up criminal syndicalism in your state. Some states offer the death penalty. That's what's going on here.
The media should be aware of their complicity. Accomplices go to the gallows, too.
wallstreet whore media sold America on WMD and tens of thousands killed, murdered, and worse.
wallstreet whore media walked away from America and got back into line with their criminal supporters when wallstreet robbed the economy of jobs and homes
wallstreet whore media loves Hellary because she will love them back and screw everyone else.
3rd World USA
>>> wallstreet whore media loves Hellary because she will love them back and screw everyone else.<<<
Literally. "Members of the club" means "fellow pedophiles." DC is linked from coast to coast via Hollywood pedophile club. It's so bad…
Nihilism. These lowlifes would blow up the world to avoid being on the "other end of the fork."
Here's circumstantial evidence of their "inner psyche" … (podesta even has human sacrifice portrait on the wall of his campaign office.
https://twitter.com/laissez_claire/status/794623045440798721/photo/1
Time Magazine: TITLE: MEET THE MAN BEHIND HILLARY CLINTON CAMPAIGN
http://time.com/4308369/hillary-clinton-john-podesta/
Watch closely.
I shit you not.
In an e-mail sent from Comcast after Clinton was interviewed by NBC’s Matt Lauer, Lauer came under fire after questioning Hillary on the e-mails, according to the technical crew after the show Hillary proceeded to pick up a full glass of water and throw it at the face of her assistant and then the screaming started, she was in full meltdown, she came apart literally unglued, she is the most foul mouthed woman I’ve ever heard, and that voice at screech level…”If that f—ing bastard wins we all hang from nooses! Lauer’s finished and if I lose its all on your heads for screwing this up”. She screamed “she’d get that f—ing Lauer fired for this”.
Donna Brazile was singled out by Clinton..”I’m so sick of your face, you stare at the wall like a brain dead buffalo while letting that fucking Lauer get away with this. What are you good for really? Get the f–k to work janitoring this mess..do I make myself clear”. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_NfFAaPZqs8
While many would love to believe and spread such a story, it is not credible without some sort of recording and witness statement. “Unnamed NBC staff” sources wont cut it, in this case – it can be dismissed as a fantasy.
Cell phones, unless they are not allowed in certain restricted areas of studios.
Oh I don’t know, it sounds well within character. Here is some well documented “fantasy”.
1. Hillary said if Iran attacks Israel, I will OBLITERATE Iran.
2. On assuming the Presidency I will impose a no fly zone over Syria, which would mean the downing of Russian aircraft and the start of WW3.
3. She would face down China, in the South China Sea, “and make them pay a price”.
Go on vote for the psychopath.
Spreading rank and fake horror show scripts of lies isn’t the way to convince anyone but the most foolish–such as apparently yourself–to make decisions of substance. Hillary Clinton has years and years from which to pull out real horror shows from without making up crass and ridiculous garbage like what you’ve posted. Maybe you should take your show to venues where you’ll be in the company of people who are a combination of dishonest and gullible as you are.
“Good morning, ma’am,” a member of the uniformed Secret Service once greeted Hillary Clinton.
“F— off,” she replied.
That exchange is one among many that active and retired Secret Service agents shared with Ronald Kessler, author of “First Family Detail,” a compelling look at the intrepid personnel who shield America’s presidents and their families — and those whom they guard.
Kessler writes flatteringly and critically about people in both parties. Regarding the Clintons, Kessler presents Chelsea as a model protectee who respected and appreciated her agents. He describes Bill as a difficult chief executive but an easygoing ex-president. And Kessler exposes Hillary as an epically abusive Arctic monster.
“When in public, Hillary smiles and acts graciously,” Kessler explains. “As soon as the cameras are gone, her angry personality, nastiness, and imperiousness become evident.”
http://nypost.com/2015/10/02/secret-service-agents-hillary-is-a-nightmare-to-work-with/
Your supposed quotes sound utterly ridiculous and not at all plausible. I won’t open the link to the youtube video you posted the link to without at least knowing who is the youtuber who posted it. If you make that information clear, allowing myself and any other readers who are of a similar mindset to check that out on youtube so that we can see who it is without opening that specific link I might consider it. I don’t like to feed numbers into a link, only to discover that some vile and dishonest person or entity has profited from my adding to their number of views.
http://www.snopes.com/hillary-clinton-threw-a-tantrum-with-matt-lauer/
False
Latest email disaster for Clinton: FBI’s Peter Kadzik is a personal friend of John Podesta and was in communication with him on private email to give a “heads up” over House Judicial inquiries.
https://www.mintpressnews.com/wikileaks-podesta-emails-highlight-strong-ties-doj-clinton-campaign/221999/
CSM also reports that
Reads like an organized crime family with FBI agents on the payroll, really.
Wasn’t just the DOJ coordinating with the Clinton campaign; see also this on State Department contacts:
http://www.dw.com/en/new-emails-suggest-coordination-between-state-department-and-clinton-camp/a-36240962
“Reads like an organized crime family with FBI agents on the payroll, really.”
The Capone organization never went away.
40 years ago I read a Capone biography and it spelled out the process of bribing or blackmailing EVERYONE. They had so much money they couldn’t give it away fast enough.
J. Edgar was in Capone’s pocket with bribes and blackmail pics of Hoover in drag with young male hookers 5-6 years before the creation of the FBI.
Yes, the FBI was created to give the impression of crime-fighting, and they do go after plenty of criminals, especially bank robbers, but they steered away from the families. That is why we will never win “the drug war”; it is the biggest cash-cow ever.
America is awash in corruption.
oyeah. The f…b…i… and the d…o…j… and the s…e…c… (and probably others) are all on the payroll of wallstreet thieves.
3rd World USA
Peter Kadzik wasn’t with the FBI but the DOJ Office of Legislative Affairs. Your own article makes this clear.
Kadzik informed Podesta of a congressional meeting, which was publicly known, and his belief that the officials providing testimony would be asked questions about the Clinton e-mail issue. He also shared some information on a FOIA lawsuit against the State Department.
Only in the fever swamps is this a “disaster” or akin to organized crime. The phrasing of the e-mail (heads up) and nature of how this information has been revealed (via leaks) makes it look sinister.
What makes this e-mail damaging to Clinton is not the outcome of the “heads up” or any impropriety but the appearance that DOJ officials are tipping her off, regardless of the significance of the information provided.
Absolutely! Hellary’s qualifications for president are listed here!
http://www.mostdamagingwikileaks.com/
Not having 2FA on a gmail account and on one’s appleid should be considered a disqualification for an office in the White House.
…
The truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.
It. Was. The. Russians.
I genuinely can’t tell if you’re being facetious. Poe’s Law strikes again!
Putin must be rollicking with uncontrolled mirth that Americans could be so incredibly naive as to either say or believe such things.
If the Russians did it, they’d make it look like NSA did it. And vice versa.
i had some coffee this morning and it wasnt quite what it usually is. Could be the ratio of water to grounds but i am hearing it was the Russians again. And who do you figure put that dust on my car, eh?
Since Mackey is bound and determined to put up the most inane posts on The Intercept without any comments, readers have to boil over and pollute some bystander authors’ comment sections just to express their disdain…
The notion that some bozo scrawling graffiti on a burned-out building around Halloween could get national news attention is laughable. Seeing it in The Intercept though, is pathetic. Oh, it’s not that I’m some great Trump supporter — I just don’t want the anti-Trump message stepped on with this kind of nonsense. It says nothing about Trump, or even his supporters, but just one troll, like as not a local kid with a moment of boredom who now is in Fear of the FBI. The reason to vote against Trump is the torture thing. The place for psychopaths and war criminals is in jail, not with a finger on the nuclear button. I don’t need to leaven that argument.
“The reason to vote against Trump is the torture thing. The place for psychopaths and war criminals is in jail, not with a finger on the nuclear button.”
Agree, completely.
Maybe you prefer radiation poisoning for 6 months of slow death… including more than 50 of fallout for your grandkids?
The reason, as in…singular!?
And I’m very sorry you cannot express your disdain over Mackey’s reporting directly to him.
sniffles
However, there is this thing called Twitter and the guy has an e-mail address.
In the last week I must of seen(TCM or DVDs)about 10 movies where torture was intimated or carried out in some form.It happened then,it happens now.
It is intrinsic to man.As long as violence is the answer for various problems,it will continue,and Trumps statement is just reality.
Same with the family collateral damage;It is current policy.
The hillaryous one is totally on board with torture and family of terrorist murders,btw,and its not Trump who started the WOT,but she and her masters.
Hopefully he’ll end it,one way or another.
It could also be an incident of what is vulgarly known in the current vernacular as “rat fucking.”
>>> The reason to vote against Trump is the torture thing. <<<
Trump will come to his senses.
You gonna vote for Hillary? She's already said that she was going to declare "total war" (economic, political, and military) for even a "cyber attack".
In her puny little mind, a "ping" or DNS query is a cyber attack. She'll end up running out of nukes as she launches them into every home, city, country, and continent of the world.
How do you win a cyber war? That's easy…. turn off the router at a transatlantic cable point of presence site. OR, just turn off your computer.
You gonna vote for that crazy copulating shedog?
Intent: clintonemail.com to talk to criminals.
Yea.
Tell me why not?
Security services have always hacked e-mail servers. The difference is that Wikileaks is making those e-mails available to the public, who represent a much higher threat level than a foreign security service. While foreign governments may sometimes wish to depose a particular leader, they generally can agree to cooperate in the common goal of maintaining the current leaders in power. The citizenry does not always share this goal.
However, Mr. Podesta does not really have anything to fear. Citizens want their leaders to be corrupt since they interpret that as a measure of competence. Enthusiasm for Mrs. Clinton has grown, as people examine the evidence of how she has skillfully used the Clinton Foundation to exchange favors with foreign leaders in order to ‘get things done’.
Of course the deep psychological reason why we want out leaders corrupt and incompetent is that it makes us look better by comparison. Just as the democrats thrived for 100 years in the South by repressing the blacks so that the po white trash could feel good about themselves, we in the new millennium need assurance of self worth. How better to achieve that than by electing a president who is utterly clueless?
In the present election the Party has generously allowed us to select between two different varieties of cluelessness; in one case a person who surrounds herself with people lacking the technical competence to employ a can opener, and in the other a person whose philosophy of government derives from that of Genghis Khan.
FYI, ALL incompetents are tyrants.
Look at some of your past jobs and the various levels of management … and the incompetence that saturates the hierarchy.
The competent, proficient ones rarely make it up the ladder very far. Most people are promoted to the point of incompetence. Psychopaths who want to rule the world like elected offices — cuz they are the masters of deception.
Please update to include Assange’s recent repudiation of the claim that Russia was source of leak in interview with UK Dartmouth Films.
This site is kind of pathetic. Why is Greenwald even here?
link?
There is something out there called a search engine. It’s a really nifty aid when you’re looking for info. You oughta try it sometime.
https://www.rt.com/news/365164-assange-interview-wikileaks-russia/