Climate change is urgent, human-caused, and real, yet all but one of the Republican Senate candidates in competitive races this year say they have doubts. If enough of them win to retain a GOP majority in the Senate, ambitious climate-change legislation is presumably doomed.
So why are Republicans so wed to a conclusion that defies science? New Hampshire Sen. Kelly Ayotte’s experience offers a clue. Ayotte is the only Republican senator in a competitive race who acknowledges humans are behind climate change and who backs President Obama’s plan to cut greenhouse gas emissions. Her stance came at a cost: millions of dollars in lost funding from the climate-denial-funding oil billionaire brothers, Charles and David Koch.
In January 2015, senators voted yes or no on whether “human activity significantly contributes to climate change,” and only five Republican senators voted “yes,” including Ayotte.
Back then, organizations backed by the Koch brothers still seemed interested in New Hampshire. Their nonprofit Americans for Prosperity spent $1.2 million in August on ads attacking Ayotte’s opponent, Gov. Maggie Hassan. But in October 2015, Ayotte came out in favor of the Clean Power Plan, President Obama’s carbon emissions reduction strategy.
As money from Koch-backed groups poured into other states, it ran dry in New Hampshire. Here’s how much the Koch network spent on each Senate candidate in the eight states from January 2015 through November 2016:
| State | Republican candidate | Koch network funding |
| Florida | Sen. Marco Rubio | $3,646,059 |
| Indiana | Rep. Todd Young | $2,464,202 |
| Missouri | Sen. Roy Blunt | $1,254,193 |
| Nevada | Rep. Joe Heck | $9,109,342 |
| New Hampshire | Sen. Kelly Ayotte | $0 |
| North Carolina | Sen. Richard Burr | $1,451,053 |
| Pennsylvania | Sen. Patrick Toomey | $9,936,202 |
| Wisconsin | Sen. Ron Johnson | $3,064,603 |
Source: Center for Responsive Politics
The Koch nonprofit Americans for Prosperity did not respond to a request for comment, but has indicated in other interviews that Ayotte’s support for Obama’s carbon emission reduction plan was behind their decision.
Dynamics in Pennsylvania hint at the scope of what Ayotte was denied. The state’s incumbent Sen. Patrick Toomey is, like Ayotte, facing a fierce fight. He voted “no” on the are-humans-causing-climate-change question in January 2015 and is vehemently opposed to Obama’s climate plan. At a recent campaign stop, he told local coal workers, “There are a lot of times when the sun doesn’t shine and the wind doesn’t blow. … I don’t think taxpayers should be forced to subsidize these inefficient sources of energy.”
Koch-backed organizations have shown their support for Toomey with millions in spending on his race. The Koch brothers’ campaign data analyzer i360 reportedly identified 600,000 Pennsylvania voters who were Republican-leaning but either unenthusiastic or undecided. Data in hand, Americans for Prosperity deployed volunteers from across the Northeast, including from New Hampshire, to knock on those voters’ doors.
Many of their targets had likely already seen ads from the Kochs’ Super PAC, Freedom Partners Action Fund, which since last May has been buying space on TV and social media to attack Toomey’s opponent, Katie McGinty. The Super PAC and the nonprofit, along with another Koch-backed nonprofit, Concerned Veterans for America, have together spent nearly $10 million to keep Toomey’s seat red.
The New Hampshire race is the only one among eight considered to be the most competitive that has not benefited from outside spending from the most important Koch-affiliated organizations. Ohio, which is less competitive, has also seen floods of Koch network cash.
To wrestle majority status away from the Republicans, Democrats will need to flip only four seats next Tuesday from red to blue; if Hillary Clinton loses the presidential race, they’ll need five. In an election that falls on the hottest year on record, the fate of the swing Senate races has major consequences for the future.
The reminders come almost daily. On Thursday, the United Nations Environment Programme released a dire report, warning, “Current commitments [under the Paris climate agreement] will reduce emissions by no more than a third of the levels required by 2030 to avert disaster,” adding that if urgent action isn’t taken, “We will grieve over the avoidable human tragedy; the growing numbers of climate refugees hit by hunger, poverty, illness and conflict will be a constant reminder of our failure to deliver. None of this will be the result of bad weather. It will be the result of bad choices by governments, private sector and individual citizens.”
President Obama’s carbon emissions reduction strategy, the Clean Power Plan, was created by executive order, yet the Republican-controlled Senate has done what it can to block it. In November 2015, the Senate approved two resolutions that would have halted the plan. Obama vetoed the measures, and the rule continues to be fought in courts.
The Senate races feature a who’s who of climate policy obstructionists. North Carolina incumbent Sen. Richard Burr introduced a 2011 bill that would have eliminated the Environmental Protection Agency, merging it with the Energy Department. Last May, Missouri incumbent Sen. Roy Blunt introduced a resolution against a possible carbon tax, even though one wasn’t being formally debated. His current legislative director, Tracy Henke, used to be chief operating officer and executive vice president for Americans for Prosperity.
In Nevada, home of outgoing Koch arch-enemy Democrat Sen. Harry Reid, $9 million has poured in from Koch-backed organizations to be sure he won’t be replaced with Democrat contender Catherine Cortez Masto. And in Florida, the Koch-backed non-profit Libre Initiative, which spreads its message by providing “everything from English classes to drivers’ license classes and citizenship classes,” is one of several Koch groups that have together spent $3.6 million to make sure incumbent Sen. Marco Rubio wins. This spring, Rubio claimed, “As far as a law that we can pass in Washington to change the weather, there’s no such thing.”
The Sierra Club’s legislative director Melinda Pierce disagrees. She points to an infrastructure plan Clinton has promised to send to Congress within her first 100 days in office as the type of climate-related legislation incoming senators may be able to influence. The plan would include efforts to strengthen communities’ climate resiliency. “Control of the gavel, and control of the Senate is critical in order to make any headway on a legislative agenda,” Pierce said.
The Koch brothers have a material interest in preventing that. The University of Massachusetts Amherst rated Koch Industries among the top 25 corporate emitters of climate-warming greenhouse gases in 2014. Meanwhile, the Kochs continue to be the biggest organizing force for political donations outside of the parties. A recent report from the Brennan Center showed that the majority of the outside money pouring into the 10 most competitive Senate races falls into one of three categories: the Democratic party and its “shadow party groups,” the Republican party and its shadow groups, and Koch-linked Super PACs and nonprofits.
In the end, Ayotte did not lack outside spending in her favor. The Republicans’ swing state shadow group, the Senate Leadership Fund, came to her rescue. It has raised $75.6 million to be spent in competitive states, including Pennsylvania, Nevada, Indiana, Florida, Missouri, North Carolina, and New Hampshire. The fund filled the cash gap left open by the Koch network in New Hampshire by donating $19 million to the Super PAC Granite State Solutions, more than it spent on any other Senate race.
The Senate Leadership Fund has attracted millions in fossil fuel donations, so it’s clear Ayotte didn’t entirely alienate the fossil fuel industry — or even the Kochs. A month after her statement on the Clean Power Plan, David Koch and his wife Julia donated $10,800 to her campaign, which has received $341,065 in total from the oil and gas industry, according to the Center for Responsive Politics.
Top photo: Sen. Kelly Ayotte on an escalator at the U.S. Capitol in 2013.
Prophetic, since she lost. Thanks for the article and dissection.
“Climate Change” as a public policy is an absurdity. The very fact that the original name of that scam had to be changed from “Global Warming” to “Climate Change”, and the reason it had to be changed, is vivid evidence of it’s absurdity. As long as people like you keep spewing that nonsense, you will never be taken seriously. Now stop thinking and acting like a high school reporter and come into the adult world. LOL
Well no, that`s incorrect. The reason it has changed to climate change is that one of the causes of global warming is melting of the ice caps which causes weakening the gulf stream or lesser heat being transported to Northern Europe (Where I`m currently living). Therefore one cause of global warming is Europe/northern Europe getting colder. A common misconception of climate change is the notion that every part of the world gets hotter and I hope I`ve shed some light on why this notion is incorrect.
Well since the Earth’s CO2 level is currently at 404 ppm, and since we are not even remotely close to enacting the (far too late and pathetically lame) Paris Agreement, and even if The Industrialized World did enact it all tomorrow we might see environmental improvement by like 2085…I think it’s safe to say the battle to combat climate change is concluded.
Perhaps Kelly Ayotte did take a principled stand on this one bill. However, her overall record on environmental issues is dismal. She wants to “rein in the role of the EPA” and has approved her party’s efforts to eliminate the power of the EPA to regulate greenhouse gasses under the Clean Air Act. She has voiced an opposition to prioritizing green energy projects as well as the Commuter Rail Project. She has gotten a dismal 23% score on environmental issues by the League of Conservation Voters. So on most environment issues — as well as most other issues — she adheres to the conservative Republican line. It is no wonder that she continues to be supported by outside conservative Republican Super Pacs.
Climate change (as long as we’re not using that term in place of global warming) has been going on for over 4 billion years on earth. Hot to cold, cold to hot, more carbon dioxide, less carbon dioxide and nearly every other possible combination of conditions has been going on (like i said) FOR 4 BILLION YEARS.
How anyone can assert that the current conditions are better or worse for the planet reaches a spectacular level of hubris. Earth, which all the hysteria is trying to save, is not capable of caring whether humanity, cheetahs, whales, spotted owls, delta smelt, etc., survive.
Earth has seen tens of thousands of different life forms become dominant and then disappear into extinction. And if the Earth really cared, wouldn’t it have done something about it by now?
So let’s get the argument straight: What the climate alarmists are really all about is exerting their vision of how the rest of us should be allowed (or not) to use what resources the planet currently provides. It’s a form of tyranny just with the global do-gooders in charge instead of oil execs or wall streeters or military industrial complex or whatever “bad-guy” scares you the most. And don’t doubt that the climate change group won’t be as bad as any of the others.
How do i know that? Look at their tactics. They’re not even capable of honesty at the highest level of their plea: Save the Earth! Earth doesn’t care…only people care. So their message is that deniers or agnostics are too stupid to be trusted with running the planet. Hitler felt the same way about the Jews, Stalin felt the same way about the Bourgeoisie. That all worked out really badly for the rest of humanity.
I don’t care what you believe, it’s entirely your business. But try some critical thinking every now and then
” their message is that deniers or agnostics are too stupid to be trusted with running the planet” Considering how laughably moronic your comment is this is a fact, kiddo
It should be pointed out that there are Democrats who are pro-fossil fuels too (southern IL is full of them, they keep running such Dems for the IL-12th Congressional District). They recognize that human accelerated climate change is real, but they want to continue our civilization’s addiction to fossil fuels which, in my opinion, is even worse than flat out denying it.
If one wants REAL progress on this issue, vote Green and convince as many people as possible to vote Green. We need Greens in Congress to better demand the progress needed to salvage the situation.
Not enough data, compared to age of earth. Plain and simple
Cannot prove either way.
She’s Trojan. Just like Ron Paul, Bernie sanders etc etc
Good article
It’s difficult to tell who are the most gullible rubes on either side of this battle of titans between the rich oily Koch or the rich green snake-oily Gore factions. The Deniers seem to be saying they don’t believe in the Big Green Corporate snake-oil agenda but they have to keep things simple for our sound-bite media and just deny everything. The Warmers line up with their lying scientists and slick technocrat to sell their, consume without guilt, green industrial revolution which is certainly industrial but may not be very green.
We may be saved from ourselves and our greedy overconsumption if these scientist wizards and their technocrat industrialists ever perfect that badly needed car that runs on snake oil which seems to be our most abundant resource.
the most gullible rubes are the ones that thing a worldwide scientific conspiracy is even possible. jesus.
“It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.”
you don’t need a conspiracy. just replace salary/grant
Excellent point, Chip and I would never claim that all or many of the climate scientists who have documented the valid data on GW were involved in falsifying their reports. The few who did were the leaders of the climate change organization in the UK and they had political agenda reasons for their crimes.
All the data and simple observations show clearly that GW is a undeniable fact but these scientists wanted a clean line on their graphs showing a linear progression of increasing temperature while nature is erratic and messed with their agenda driven presentation of the facts.
GW has continued to increase since that time and erased any significance of those few years of declining temperature. The reputation of the Warmer scientist community, especially the leadership, has been damaged because they were serving the Big Green corporate agenda not trying to educate the public.
The “worldwide conspiracy” is easy to come by when so many of the other countries declare they are too poor to make the changes. Then Obama tells them that is not a problem because the US is going to foot the bill. Another step towards worldwide control with Obama and his socialist buddies in charge.
Hillary Clinton on the Dakota Access Pipeline, the militarized police, the beatings and the mace and the arrests and strip searches: Silence as load as Donald Trump’s. Both are tied into the financial interests behind this, Hillary Clinton via her donors (like Warren Buffett, who has $6 billion in pipeline partner Phillips 66), and Donald Trump via a direct $1 million investment in the partners. What a farce; I’m very happy I voted for Jill Stein.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hPbvWG-Vnwg
If she is in the band wagon of climate change, I will suggest to her to read more about the subject, and not to let herself be used by the left wing advocates that accuses human kind of all kinds of abuses in this planet. One thing she has to have in mind, we cannot control Mother Nature? And many so ” called” scientist are pushing false information on weather conditions.
Yes, please give her and us this reliable reading matter.
Yes, please enlighten us.
Republicans on climate and fossil fuels: “Climate science is bogus. Let’s burn more coal!”
Democrats on climate and fossil fuels: “Climate change is a problem. Let’s burn more oil and gas!”
Obama opened up the door to U.S. oil exports for the first time since the late 1960s; he signed all those offshore oil leases in the Gulf of Mexico, green-lighting the BP Deepwater disaster; he stalled and stalled on the Keystone Pipeline (which his boss, Warren Buffett, was in favor of) despite massive public opposition; then he quietly greenlighted the Dakota Access Pipeline while nobody was looking, and is “letting things unfold” while militarized police violently assault protestors on the pipeline route.
Obama, Clinton and Trump – all loyal tools of bloated fossil fuel interests and the banks and funds that are their shareholders. See Susan Sarandon on The Young Turks with Cenk Uygar for the details:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ngXuEVXjkWA
Her suggestion: everyone pull their money out of the funds and banks with fossil fuel investments – put it somewhere else, a credit union, a renewable energy investment fund, etc. That includes all the investors in Exxon, Chevron, Phillips 66, Conoco, Sunoco, etc. etc. etc. Here’s the twitter handle for this movement:
#bankexit
If we are not permitted to survive global warming and prosper with green job stimulus which would end the recession. WE WILL at least, take horrifying revenge. The nihilist Koch brother betrayers will be out of the way, but we will take it out on whoever speaks nicely of their memory.
Cool story, Erdogan…
I don’t think we can trust our children to be responsible stewards of the environment. So the only option is to burn up all the fossil fuels now, so they aren’t faced with that temptation. Left without the option of burning fossil fuels, they will be forced to use renewables.
Renewable energy has some drawbacks. It makes it harder to fight resource wars, since solar and wind are widely distributed and you can’t focus on a single region like the Middle East. But people will find other things to fight wars over. Whatever the future brings, I think that three species are likely to survive – rats, cockroaches and human beings.
Sorry Alleen Brown, my comment could be off-topic but it ought to be said.
From looking at this website front page, there is no way of telling, there is a US presidential election in 2 days.
Obama’s answer to climate change is spraying Indians in the face with mace and setting dogs to attack them. He’s been at the Bull Connor playbook again.
I’m not sure the President has ever been to India… ;)
If he has not been to India, it is only because Michelle didn’t want to vacation there. :)
It is getting easier to become well informed due to the alternative media. One still needs discrimination and critical thinking. I would definitely warn people to take care at this web site as it seems to lean in a liberal direction where liberal is vague and ill defined—it is not at all like it was up until around 1965. Perhaps Joseph Paul Watson is correct when he says liberal is a form of mental illness. As far as I can tell the NYD did find a file labeled IntimateXXX on Weiner’s computer in which there was a lot of incriminating information including photos and perhaps videos. It would appear Hillary is into pedophilia and trafficking of children . . . This is in the Wikileak emails though in code language. The sources for this are various. Eric Prince. FBI agents. Clearly the Justice Department wants to suppress this. Now there are three evils: the emails, the Foundation and the pedophilia. Which is the lesser of these three evils? Why no article on this site dealing with these things? Who is seeing to it that nothing so lurid will appear? At least someone could define liberal. It does not mean anything like what it meant when I was at a university.
‘code language’ that presumably only you and Alex Jones can decypher.
There’s enough genuine ‘dirt’ on HRC w/o having to make up utter rubbish.
“There’s enough genuine ‘dirt’ on HRC”
We wouldn’t know this from reading this website.
Genuine dirt like this
https://wikileaks.org/podesta-emails/emailid/49435
You may explain what is in that WikiLeaks email.
Conservative, what is conservative? Prejudice? Nihilism? Hatred of American youth?
She would have lost my vote also if she wasn’t running against such a hard line Liberal as Hassan. The BS which is MMGW is nothing more than the attempt to tax everything we do,buy and own. The people who started this whole scam have said as much,if anyone actually takes a minute to do some research. We actually are entering a long period of cooling due to sun inactivity….Cooling BTW will be MUCH worse than whatever a couple fractions of a degree in warming might do….
MORE!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wMHIAOJXNDM&feature=youtu.be
Totally shocked, and disgusted. Why are the mass media ignoring this? Very interesting that the video states that the coup de grace is still to come from Wikilealks.
Here is some more :
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oA9aR1zY-yI
Why are the mass media ignoring this?
After MUCH thought and reflecting i noticed something – pretty bad too. Wanna hear this?
The zion rothschild club has control of the US currency, monetary system and economy with domination and control of their corporats via their stock holdings thru many avenues. China, Venezuela, Russia, Germany, Switzerland, and India have acquired mountains of gold to back their currencies. The USD is in the toilet, bonds are shit, and i believe the US economy is fixing to crash very soon – regardless how soon, it will. China Russia India developed and econo pact, philippines wants in and is about to force US out at gunpoint. EU mainland is swamped with people problems and south of the US border is a complete disaster.
Wallstreet thieves know the end is near and have decided to make a final play for their game of world domination by getting Hellary the whore elected for their TPP crap and war to the north. Meanwhile, in preparation for the shit-fan-tango, wallstreet thieves have already looted America like slumlords and, extracted billions for Israel for their protection dome and weapons arsenal. Israel already has 600+ nukes. Israel is clearing the land around them for a buffer zone and they want Hellary to help them finish the job.
PLAN A. Hellary is elected. The z-club will get their whore to finish their mop up around Israel. IF that is accomplished AND they get their TPP, they will use the US over more time to rob and abuse a lot of other countries to increase their middle east stronghold. There are a few scenarios around this but they will persist with their slumlordisation of America as long as possible. In other words, bleed US to death.
PLAN B. TRUMP IS ELECTED. This is the “why not media” part. The Z Club and friends are prepared to take refuge in israel (where they hijacked the govt and some people as well) and let the US crash. They will have whatever defence in place, blame the US for everything, and threaten the world that should any country take aim at them, they will blow up the planet.
That is what i suspect they are up to. In any event, when the shit-fan-tangos, they are gone, sayanara, hasta la vista baby.
May the Koch brothers rot in hell that will be even hotttttter.
EVIL
Evil is a very simple concept.
Evil is that which willfully breaks a commandment (of the 10+2)
Willfully is by will but should not be confused with *want*. Will is a matter of ownership which implies consistency. The Kochers will appears owned or possessed by another force – which pays no attention to the 10+2.
Here is the rationale for persons who destroy lives of others. I paraphrase as if i were a kocher –
That is the scenario the planet and all its people face today – the real enemies of life on this planet, our home – monsters of wealth and/or power *willing* to destroy our home. Monsters who would melt our icecaps and rise our seas, monsters who would declare enemies and spark off world war 3, monsters who would hijack the grain supplies and end the propagation of self seeding, monsters who would claim all the fish in the sea, monsters who would cut forests for farming, monsters who would build without end to overpopulate the planet to feed their growth demands.
i lay it out for you. i tell you the truth, life recycles, you shall be born again. WHAT DO YOU WANT TO RETURN TO?
i can prove it. simple physics.
Here is a prayer i conceived for you to get started seeing more..
say this at nights with sincerity before bed.
And in the meantime:
Clinton’s charity confirms Qatar’s $1 million gift while she was at State Dept
http://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-election-foundation-idUSKBN12Z2SL
How the hell does she get away with all of this? One law-breaking and rule-breaking after another. The establishment media is so in the tank for her it’s outrageous. Well, if Trump does get elected at least the press will suddenly start remembering its investigative and muckraking past.
The establishment media sold Americans WMD and the invasion of Iraq.
They are obedient to that which owns their will.
And just what did Qatar buy with all this money? Did Hillary endorse any nebulous pro-Qatar policies? I don’t remember any! Could it possibly be that most of these so-called questionable donations to the Clinton Foundation were made by persons, corporations or governments that wanted to improve their public relations image and not for the purpose of swaying any important US government decision? If Qatar wants to give 1 million dollars to a foundation to improve access to health care in poor countries, great! As long as no questionable government decisions are made as a result. In the future I think that it would be prudent of the Clinton Foundation to reject donations from corporations and foreign governments — which it has said it intends to do — but unless someone can point to decisions that were influenced by past donations, I think it is grossly unfair to charge either the Foundation or Hillary with “law-breaking” and “rule-breaking.”
All these Republicans screaming that Hillary is crooked and should go to jail over some emails should take a good look at their own leadership first….
Koch Industry has been running commercials to let us know we would not have toilet paper without it.
I never thought of the Koch brothers in terms of wiping my ass.
I have.
I bet Venezuela is thinking of toilet paper these days, its manufacturing and distribution.
get a water flusher. cuts toilet paper use by 90%. no smeary aftersmell.
AIPAC has been doing this for generations. There is no more clueless people in the developed world than Americans. The ones who know what’s going on are doing fine and don’t wanna upset the Apple cart but Artificial Intelligence will soon take your jobs too and no one will stand up for you than, Mr., Mrs real middle class. Think millions who drive for a living including the Uber fools. Think algorithms diagnosing illness, reading imaging and robots doing surgery for a start. It’s happening at light speed. Now, the wealth could be shared; you think it will be……. 1.6 Billion new Air Conditioners coming on stream in the next few years leaking HFCs which are 10,000 as bad as CO2. Glads I lived through the good old days!
oh, global warming > more air conditioners > more warming > more ac’s >….
whoa. Yer gonna need a bigger air conditioner.
“CLIMATE CHANGE IS urgent, human-caused, and real”
Ignorance is strength…the science is settled!
once the ice caps are melted, it will be too late to make the turn. civilisation of humans, and mamals, will be dead, the food chain cut, horrors abound.
however as the good people have free will (free as in owned by self), changes can be made now. ANYONE who figures we can build machines to remake air and temperature and weather etc are certifiably mad.
One would have to be equally ‘certifiably mad’ to take these hyperbolic claims at face value, based on pseudo scientific extrapolations.
Free will is often usurped by coercion and emotional manipulation.
If only someone could tax us into a solution!
could be easy, could be
we need to get lawyers, whores and Dumbers out of gov decision positions
elect science minds
The Coup.
http://www.stevepieczenik.com/us-takeover-may-be-near/
mexico has designs on the US thru occupation as a coup.
this tide must be reversed.
we must not be robbed.
Allthem coal miners know when the “sun doesnot shine and the wind blows” you can still start your chevy, ford or ram bc it has a BATTERY.
They also arenot using acrank or dial phone, enjoy better dentistry than their grandparents did, have cental heating and appreciate progress.
Kochs deny people opportunity.
Better to have a party that doesnt take Exxon Mobil’s or Goldman Sachs’ money. Vote green, stay green after the election, to build political force for change. It will not happen within the Rep. or Dem establishment parties, funded by Exxon Mobil. https://youtu.be/snzhIJi35FY
https://youtu.be/cehrFL8fP4A
The most damaging Wikileaks :
http://www.mostdamagingwikileaks.com/
thanks, looks like an excellent up to date list and summaries…helps to follow these as they flow out!
Secret World of US Election: Julian Assange talks to John Pilger (FULL INTERVIEW)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_sbT3_9dJY4&feature=youtu.be