As police unleashed streams of icy water Sunday night against Dakota Access pipeline demonstrators, Linda Black Elk, a member of the Standing Rock Medic and Healer Council, was helping care for injured demonstrators. The council estimated that 300 people were treated for injuries, including 26 who were taken to area hospitals.
“What it was like was people walking through the dark of a winter North Dakota night, some of them so cold, and sprayed with water for so long, that their clothes were frozen to their body and crunching as they walked. So you could hear this crunching sound and this pop-pop-pop, and people yelling [to the police], ‘We’ll pray for you! We love you!’” Black Elk said, describing the scene as police sprayed protesters with water and fired tear gas and rubber bullets during the more than six-hour standoff.
“All of a sudden there were these bright, blinding spotlights, so you could see each other, but you couldn’t see [the police],” she said. “Every once in awhile you could hear someone scream who had been hit by a rubber bullet.”
In the midst of the clash, the Medic and Healer Council, which was set up to provide health support to those fighting the pipeline, released a statement pleading with police to halt the use of water cannons. “As medical professionals, we are concerned for the real risk of loss of life due to severe hypothermia under these conditions,” the statement said.
The standoff began after pipeline opponents attempted to use a semitruck to remove two charred military vehicles from a bridge. The vehicles were serving as a blockade between the large encampment known as Oceti Sakowin, which has served as a base for blocking the pipeline, and construction sites accessible farther down the highway. Beyond the burned-out vehicles stood cement road barriers topped with razor wire, behind which police and other security officials have been standing guard since the end of October. Their presence means a detour for those traveling between the Standing Rock Sioux reservation and the city of Bismarck, including emergency medical services.
In a statement on Sunday, the Morton County Sheriff’s Department explained the bridge closing, saying, “North Dakota Department of Transportation has closed the Backwater Bridge due to damage caused after protesters set numerous fires on the bridge October 27. In addition, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers has requested Morton County to prevent protesters from trespassing on [U.S. Army Corps of Engineers] land north of the camp.”
According to the sheriff’s department, approximately 400 people were involved in the protest. When asked in a press conference Monday about the use of water cannons, Morton County Sheriff Kyle Kirchmeier said, “We don’t have water cannons,” explaining, “This is just a fire hose.”
“It was sprayed more as a mist, and we didn’t want to get it directly on them, but we wanted to make sure to use it as a measure to help keep everybody safe,” he said. “We’re just not going to let people and protesters in large groups come in and threaten officers. That’s not happening.”
The department characterized the protesters’ actions as “very aggressive,” saying that projectiles had been thrown at police, injuring one officer. Medics on the ground said the demonstrators they observed were unarmed and largely nonviolent. The department said it had requested additional assistance from law enforcement around the state, and that border patrol would be providing support.
Noah Morris was another medic at the scene. “They were just hosing people down with their water cannon that continued for the entirety of the four hours I was out there watching,” he said. He said that earlier in the week, the rivers and creeks nearby had started to crust over with ice. As he and his team flushed the eyes of people sprayed with tear gas, the water and milk of magnesia they used turned to black ice on the ground.
Morris said he knew of multiple people that had been hit in the head with rubber bullets or bean bag rounds. In a statement, the Medic and Healer Council described injuries including an elder who lost consciousness before being revived on site, a man who experienced a seizure, and a woman whose eye was injured when she was shot in the face by a rubber bullet.
A 21-year-old woman from New York, Sophia Wilansky, underwent surgery Monday after her arm was severely injured by a concussion grenade, according to the council.
In a statement on Tuesday, her father, Wayne Wilansky, said she would need multiple surgeries to regain functional use of her arm and hand. “All of the muscle and soft tissue between her elbow and wrist were blown away,” he said. “She will be, every day for the foreseeable future, fearful of losing her arm and hand.”
In a statement to the Los Angeles Times, the sheriff’s department denied using concussion grenades and suggested the injury was caused by explosives allegedly used by protesters. The Medic and Healer Council responded, “These statements are refuted by Sophia’s testimony, by several eyewitnesses who watched police intentionally throw concussion grenades at unarmed people, by the lack of charring of flesh at the wound site, and by the grenade pieces that have been removed from her arm in surgery and will be saved for legal proceedings.”
Some of the injured were transported to the Oceti Sakowin camp, which lies a few minutes’ walk from the demonstration site. There, thousands of people have convened in an effort to stop the Dakota Access pipeline from threatening the drinking water and cultural resources of members of the Standing Rock Sioux tribe and others living downstream. If completed, the pipeline will transport oil from the Bakken shale fields in North Dakota to a transfer point in Illinois, dipping underneath the Missouri River just to the north of the Standing Rock Sioux reservation. Tribal leaders are fighting in court to stop it, but the corporation behind the plan, Energy Transfer Partners, has argued the opportunity to reroute the pipeline has already passed. In a recent interview with the Associated Press, the company’s CEO, Kelcy Warren, declared, “There’s not another way. We’re building at that location.”
At the camp, the injured were treated inside winterized structures that have been erected alongside less-protected camping tents. Other demonstrators were taken to a nearby gym, where medics attempted to raise body temperatures with blankets and hot beverages.
Black Elk, a resident of the Standing Rock Sioux reservation, has been involved in the fight against the pipeline since last February, when community members first learned of plans to build it. She’s an ethnobotanist and instructor at the local Sitting Bull College and has served as a cultural liaison for the Medic and Healer Council. She said she’s seen police reactions to the protests become “progressively more militant, more violent.”
Morris recalled a protest at the end of the summer when police provided water to a thirsty protester who was attached to construction equipment. He says things have changed since then.
“We are standing back in a state of disbelief,” said Jesse Lopez, a surgeon based in Kansas City, who has traveled to North Dakota multiple times to support the Medic and Healer Council. “I maybe could see pepper spray, maybe rubber bullets, maybe tear gas, but water cannons? That’s done to inflict deliberate, severe, life-threatening harm.”
Update: November 22, 2016
This piece was updated to include details of Sophia Wilansky’s injuries.
Top photo: Dakota Access Pipeline protestors amassed on the bridge leading to the construction site on Nov. 20, 2016.
Jimmy Dore published a video today covering Dakota Access #StandingRock, mostly using this article for reference and quotes.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jXXx4BxoNj4
I was raised in ND, and the mind-set of White Power there is of the sickest possible variety. Now I’m feeling the urge to take a little trip back…. af
If you’re looking for Occupy, the urban movement that energized common decency, at least for a while, I think it’s forming again, not in the city, but in wind-swept North Dakota at Standing Rock. So many heroic people in one place. This time, the New Occupy is addressing the most important issue facing everybody on earth. Is this the beginning of something big?
Springfield, Oregon
Jay, I think it is the beginning of something very big.
Be watching on December 5. At latest count, we have 2,100 U.S. military veterans from all over the U.S. rostered to take the place of the native Americans on the front lines at Standing Rock. We plan to occupy the construction site in a battalion-size formation and look forward to the police arresting us all. Rep. Tulsi Gabbard and other veteran members of Congress will be there. See earlier coverage of this forthcoming event at http://www.mintpressnews.com/veterans-joining-forces-standing-rock-protestors-north-dakota/222513/
A successful GoFundMe effort has thus far raised over $282,000 to pay for veterans’ travel costs, supplies, legal fees, and anticipated court-imposed fines. If you’d like to contribute, go to https://www.gofundme.com/veterans-for-standing-rock-nodapl (updated news about the event there too). If you would like to contribute financially, that would be great! But we’re also looking for donations of cold weather coats, body armor, protective masks, hearing protection (both plugs and mufflers), sleeping bags, rainsuits (for the water cannon), long underwear, cold weather gloves or mittens, etc. If you would like to donate any of these items please email veteranstandingrock@gmail.com (.) We’ll try to arrange for your donated items to be collected and picked up by veterans traveling to the event.
Follow up veteran events in support of the water protectors at Standing Rock are in the planning stage but may begin as early as the week beginning December 11.
The last time around, we veterans served the government; this time, we serve the People.
Best regards to all supporters,
Paul
Oh shut up.
Wesley Clark’s son–Wes Clark Jr–is no revolutionary. He’s a reactionary conformist, a mis-leader.
look at this post: https://www.facebook.com/WesClarkJr/posts/10154044744538715
from his facebook page above:
November 10 at 6:03pm
the more the police are desensitized through such barbaric acts, the more easily the police and state forces will carry out mass executions of civilians in the US. The Nazi holocaust didn’t start with the gas chambers and death camps.
Individual and collective armed self-defense is both right and responsible.
There is no evidence to demonstrate that the expressions of “love” and the endurance of suffering by the nonviolent Water Protectors is transforming the hearts and minds of the oppressors.
Continued inadequate self-defense, combined with the deliberate Beltway media blackout, escalating brutality by the fascists, and the trickle of supplies, resources, and civilian reinforcements will lead to demoralization and ever greater atrocities.
thank you for this report. I hope it will help to get people into action to fight for human rights and stand together against the injustice done by government and police. prayers and love to standing rock from germany!
They sprayed “mist” as a way to “keep everybody safe!” If you want them safe, stay the hell off their land!! GREED, GREED, GREED!!!!!!
Shades of Birmingham.
I had the same thoughts.
They use water the very thing the people are trying to protect. IV never seen one video of an officer hurt by a protester not one. They were behind all the razor wire with guns gazers etc. Than they say they were worried about being harmed they clearly are full of s… I have not seen one reason for them to attack. I did hear the police deny using water on people only to see a video proving that they did.
Thank you for covering this issue. I am concerned about the use of the word “clash” in the various reports I see. Using that word implies that there is violence from both parties involved in the incident. This is certainly not true and leaves a mistaken impression.
The NY Times published an editorial
http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/23/opinion/power-imbalance-at-the-pipeline-protest.html
this morning calling on Obama to pressure the police to stand down.
Will he stand up for the rights of the oppressed or simply pretend to care as usual?
This should be investigated as a War Crime by the US against the Sovereign Nation of the Sioux.
Call the WH situation room now and repeatedly to demand an immediate end to the violence being done to the Water Protectors
202-456-9431
Police use water cannons, tear gas, rubber bullets, and other weapons against unarmed, nonviolent Dakota Access Pipeline protesters
http://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2016/11/22/dako-n22.html
“The current buildup of tremendous force at Standing Rock should be understood as a military invasion of a sovereign nation on behalf of a foreign oil company.”
– Steven Salaita
Agree
Kind of like Libya.
“We came, we saw, he died! Ha,ha,ha.”
No-one has perfected the use of victim language like the militarized police. Very few people can enter the property of others and commit horrible acts and still be considered the victim, no surprise most of the worst of these are trained in Israel, the most racist victim-nation on earth.
Thanks to Teri B for this
Security Firm Running Dakota Access Pipeline Intelligence Has Ties to U.S. Military Work in Iraq and Afghanistan
http://www.desmogblog.com/2016/10/28/private-security-firm-dakota-access-iraq-afghanistan-blackwater
https://drive.google.com/file/d/0BwOpxUHbJI1hUFNvdW1FMlpwSm8/view
usa_naziland; cares not for peoples property & rights
If I were building a pipeline against the indigenous wishes I’d worry more about it being sabotaged after I left. Seriously…they know it’s not wanted now. Do they honestly think they’ll leave it alone once you pack up your water cannons and go home? It doesn’t end for them once you go home.
Unfortunately, if they sabotaged it after they finish and leave, it will cause the exact thing they are trying to prevent. There is no way to do anything to do it after it’s done that wouldn’t doom the environment around it. They know this.
North Dakota needs to order law enforcement to stand down and quit subsidizing ETP security with public resources. This would be a great time for wikileaks to aquire and publish communications between North Dakota officials, DAPL, ACOE, Tigerswan Security, Morton County Sheriffs Dept., National Guard, the feds and anyone else involved, call it ” Thanksgiving Surprise”! In the meantime, we can expect to see bills like this http://dougericksen.src.wastateleg.org/ericksen-bill-criminalize-economic-terrorism/
popping up around the nation.
You’ve obviously never been to the Dakotas. The white people there hate Native Americans and don’t give a damn about the environment. North Dakota isn’t going to order anything except more attacks on the water protectors in service of oil.
There is live footage for hours that does show the truth https://www.facebook.com/kevin.happychappy/videos/1806825289589975/
If this link is not posted, to the editor, please watch it.
Cant they leave the standing rock alone it the natives land not the companys that is bulding the pipeline.
This whole situation, just basically proves time and again, the majority of Native Americans are the most maligned, mistreated, and oppressed people’s, since 1492. If anything Americans in this day and age could learn something about community and perseverance from the Natives. As far as the people of Standing Rock go, I support you, keep it up, you are all inspirational.
Yes, and what the First American people and their many supporters are doing is protecting land that belongs to all American’s. Protecting ‘the’ water and mother earth. Surely it’s time that the oppressor slaves – the police and security firms involved and the mainstream media, the silent government – wake up and realise the bigger picture.
Obama’s Legacy: Oppression, the assault on dissent, or maybe we should we call it Hope-pression.
wtf are you talking about?
How much more abuse are these protesters going to take before a few of them start shooting in the opposite direction?
How about all of us decide to visit Caddo Lake and see if we can run a pipeline through that? Kelcy Warren seems to think it is fine for him to destroy the waters in North Dakota and the Army Corp of Engineers seems to think the same thing, since they are both only interested in TX and could care less about other states. I think it is time that we start a protest at Caddo Lake and start fracking and shaling around the area.
Talk about a hypocrite check this out “The Kelcy Warren Foundation supports the Caddo Lake Institution, an organization with the mission of protecting the ecological, cultural and economic integrity of Caddo Lake, its associated wetlands and watershed” Also why are military vehicles being used to guard a corporation? Read it for yourself http://www.caddolakeinstitute.us/paddlefish_project.html This to him is more important than preserving Indian burial grounds. Guess he won’t mind if we dig his family up and toss them into a landfill or even into Caddo Lake.
Anyone READY for a PROTEST of a RACIST and Bigot ? Army corp of engineers should be DISBANDED due to lack of over site. They will protect fish but DESTROY BURIAL GROUNDS. Does this VULTURE know what a DEPLORABLE human being he is? I hope he drops dead of a heart attack or better yet, somebody needs to spray the SOB and leave him out in 20 degree temperatures. Would serve him right.
Maybe we should all start calling his company and complaining to them. If they can do what they want, why can’t WE THE PEOPLE stand up for what is RIGHT?
Wondering if America won’t see increasing use of police in a country with an authoritarian ruler like Mr. Trump?
OBAMA could stop this CRUEL AND UNUSUAL PUNISHMENT. THESE ACTIONS ARE “DEPLORABLE” THIS IS WATERBOARDING IN SUB ZERO TEMPS. THIS IS THE VERY DEFINITION OF TORTURE. Waco is looking like a playpen these days. I have just loss all respect for Otrama .
More of the same of what Obama allowed, what Bill Clinton championed.. and of course we know all about the Bush’s.
“That’s done to inflict deliberate, severe, life-threatening harm.”
I applaud the continued stance of prayer and peace, against mounting violence, by “The Man”!
Information is non violent,
who exactly is shooting protesters in the eyes?, spraying the elderly covering them in ice?
What is their name?
Who is the supervisor?
Who deserves to be voted out of office?
In this age of digital technology, document who came to work, and agreed to “bust some heads”
Thank you for covering the protest and documenting the human rights abuses.
This is the 21st century version of Wounded Knee. Monstrous.
This is not a “clash”, it’s an “assault”.
What are you doing Obama “letting it play out”. You coward!
So protesters were told not to cross a bridge, and they tried to cross a bridge, with a semi truck, to run a security blockade?
While I sympathise with the protestors, I’m really not sure what the police were supposed to do to push them back, other than use live ammo, which would most certainly be worse.
You are protestors, not warriors. Don’t run security blockades. When you try and push through a security blockade you will get shot, you will get gassed, you will get hosed down with fire hoses.
We can’t legitimately expect the police to just let these protesters drive through the blockade with a semi truck, so that they can burn the pipeline camp to the ground. That’d be anarchism.
What do you call DESTROYING A BURIAL GROUND? I call those anarchists.
” Don’t run security blockades. ”
Don’t erect security barricades against civilians.
Using water cannons in sub-freezing weather is a life-threatening tactic.
You should really watch the livestreams or video footage coming out instead of taking the cops at their word. There are so many fabrications being made.
Sieg heil! You would have made a great Nazi.
They were not attempting to cross a bridge in a semi-truck and run a security blockade. They were trying to use a truck to move burned out vehicles that had been left on the bridge, thus blocking vehicles from coming and going. That includes emergency vehicles. The cops left the burned out vehicles on the bridge in order to not only make coming and going that way more difficult, not just for the Water Protectors but also for anyone who lived around that area and used that road, but also to punish them by making it hard for them to get ambulances there should they need them. In the videos, they say that the cops had said both that they would remove the burned vehicles themselves, and that they had been left only because the bridge was “unsafe”, but you can clearly see in the videos that there is nothing wrong with the bridge. All they wanted was to clear the road.
Furthermore, they do consider themselves warriors because the front line of the protest has clearly become a warzone. But they are nonviolent warriors engaged in a peaceful protest characterized largely by peacefully standing around and chanting, and prayer. They weren’t wanting to destroy anything. They haven’t destroyed anything. They wouldn’t burn the pipeline camp to the ground, partly because they don’t want the violence of that, and partly because it wouldn’t help anything. They are not eco-terrorists. They are peaceful protesters trying to protect EVERYONE from the dangers of the pipeline.
If anyone wants to understand how the right hand of the majority can use the left hand of the minority to kneel to its knees. Read he Half Has Never Been Told by Edward E. Baptist, 2014. He discusses the issues that the Enslaver used torture to execute a response from its hand’s that did the work. This book tries to explain the mindset that the Enslaver’s, here it is a corporation, use to exert their opponents to bend to their will. The more times change the more they remain the same.
ETP pays big dividends. This company must be extremely profitable
The US has no doubt studied the example of the Arab Spring. The regimes that survived were those which ruthlessly suppressed their protestors. If a government shows a hint of weakness, or tries to accommodate the demands of protestors in any way, it is toast. This may seem inhumane, but is the only way for the United States to avoid becoming the next Libya.
So protests by indigenous Americans against an oil pipeline that may despoil their land and poison their water is equivalent to the protests that brought down Libya? I guess the original colonists who fought to throw off British rule were also nothing but dirty anarchists, as well. (We engineered the overthrow of Libya’s government, by the way.)
Thank you for being a voice of sanity!
quote”This may seem inhumane, but is the only way for the United States to avoid becoming the next Libya.”unquote
Spare us blathering crap. People got hurt asshole. I hope someone slaps you silly some day.
It’s sarcasm
No, this is North Dakota, USA. It is not the next Libya Benito. $hillary Clinton isn’t Secretary of State arming the rebels to overthrow a political leader of a sovereign nation, hence creating a vacuum of leadership and absolute chaos.
Your comments are as asinine as the handle you have chosen to extract yourself from meaningful dialogue by remaining anonymous as you cower from any accountability for your ridiculous and ludicrous statements.
Benito if in fact you knew anything about history, you’d realize that it was dictator Benito Mussolini’s brutal military expansionism in Libya first that laid the groundwork to enable an authoritarian dictatorship like Kadafi’s to subsequently to take control.
Everybody CALM DOWN!
Benito Mussolini is the greatest commenter on this chat. As DocHollywood said, “it’s sarcasm.” Read his other posts, and you’ll get it.
by becoming the next North Korea?
Your Excellency, both those who revile you and those who explain you as a satirist have got it wrong. A prophet in his own country is not understood and appreciated. At least in today’s comment you are not being ironic. You are saying it plain about the mind behind the overwhelming police force at Standing Rock. As soon as the sheriff backs down one inch, North Dakota and maybe the rest of the country will slip back into the hands of the people who were here before the First Thanksgiving. Obama and all the other people in charge of the complicated machine called the USA can’t let that happen. What we most need is stability as we zoom off the cliff.
what can police else does?
….why are concussion grenades being used against unarmed civilian protesters?
http://www.desmogblog.com/2016/10/28/private-security-firm-dakota-access-iraq-afghanistan-blackwater
The neoliberal drive to construct transnational transportation and energy infrastructure from source to consumer is essential to fulfilling constitutional requirements of existing and future free trade agreements. Beyond that however, it is the mean by which access to energy reserves can remain constant as a necessary precondition to facilitating growth, and sustaining economic stability, in emerging regional trade blocks. “The World Economic Forum refers to transnational infrastructure as ‘a physical backbone of this regional integration,’ which will ‘open up regional markets, link production clusters in different countries, facilitate the free movement of goods, services and people, and foster political stability and peace.’”
(see May 28, 2014 article entitled: Transnational Energy Infrastructure as Backbone of Potential ‘Regional Power Pools’ in Africa; By Roman Kilisek)
A similar vision of integrating transnational energy infrastructure across North America was addressed in a Wilson Center publication entitled “Integrating North America’s Energy Markets: A Call for Action.”
https://www.wilsoncenter.org/sites/default/files/Integrating%20North%20America's%20Energy%20Markets.pdf
In February 2014, the leaders of the three North American nation met to discuss a range of measures to enhance regional competitiveness, including new initiatives on transportation infrastructure, borders and research cooperation. In the attempt to coordinate regional efforts to make it a net exporter of energy, the study calls for “an expert group, drawn from business, academia and think tanks, to come together to map out North America’s energy present and future.” As an interesting side note, the study makes a point of emphasizing the fact that the proposed integration of regional transportation and energy infrastructure should not be interpreted as precondition for establishing a “supranational body” akin to the European Union:
Thanks much Karl – this is critical information!
I am glad that you appreciate my contribution. Understanding the overarching aims of the neoliberal elites who have long been tasked with collaboratively constructing and implementing domestic and foreign policy platforms of numerous nation states is essential to evaluating the relative benefit derived from said policies by the common man.
In short, you must first learn how something actually works before presuming that it is broken and needs fixing.
You can clearly see in the videos the “police” are shamelessly LYING about the use of the water cannons, so why not point that out? Not just that they used them, but HOW they used them.
Sioux are good guerilla fighters the government may wish to cease the lethal action.
“but we wanted to make sure to use it as a measure to help keep everybody safe”
this is why water cannons to hose down toddlers in freezing weather are installed at all day care centers. It’s just common sense.
BWHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHA… HOHOHOHOHOHO… HAHAHAHAHA HAHAHA HAHAHA….
zing!
Benitio… you’re an amateur.
The RCMP are scum. ????
They indiscriminately kill Canadians and yet hardly a peep in the news, or just a tiny article in the back pages of a newspaper.
Best of luck to all protesters, fight the good fight. You and the actions of the RCMP will not be forgotten.
It is terrible that we are seeing history repeat itself in that water cannons are being used against the “other side” except in this case it is not just people fighting for their rights but people fighting against corporate greed. It is so sad that we allow corporate lobbyists to overrun the rights of people to a safe environment for their children to grow up in. The police should be getting arrested in this case, not the protesters.
America needs a democratic revolution to introduce binding citizen initiated referendums to and the Constitution as in Switzerland, as described in the ‘Direct Democracy’ PDF on the HRCA website – http://hrc-australia.org/projects.html You might also like to read the PDF titled ‘American Revolution 2.0′.
The Standing Rock protest goes beyond the indigenous struggle to safeguard their diminishing lands and water from unrestrained capitalism. It represents the increasing struggle between Humanity and and the “Empire.” The main stream media are avoiding this struggle so kudos to the Intercept for covering it (despite that last “fake news” story on Syria). Nevertheless, that struggle will grow to such an extent that even those people people living in their neoliberal/neoconservative bubbles will have to choose one day between Humanity and the Empire. Those on the right and those on the left have a common enemy; an enemy that does not respect the sacredness of life but rather perceives everything on this planet as exploitable for maximum profit. An enemy that see’s it justified to destroy millions of lives for corporate shareholder returns. An enemy with no spirit, no soul, no ethics – a machine – a Borg of capitalistic greed. I stand with humanity. I stand with the people of Standing Rock who are on the front lines of that global struggle between Humanity and the Empire.
The Intercept is sounding more and more like Stenography/MSM. Confirmed! DAPL & Morton County Police shot Sophia Wilanski an unarmed protector with Concussion Grenade last night at Standing Rock, she’s in a Minnesota Hospital facing arm amputation! #NoDAPL #StandWithStandingRock.”
You’re right about the pipeline being unsafe & an environmental hazard! The pipeline running from Houston to New York IS LEAKING INTO THE SOIL OF SEVERAL STATES! BESIDE THE FACT THAT THE LAND IS YOURS, AND SACRED PLACES WILL BE DESTROYED!! MAYBE WAR BONNETS ARE GOING TO BE NEEDED.
One problem with treating protesters like insurgents and the poor like insurgents is that sooner or later they may become insurgents. The American government has taken on a policy of instigating and aggravating the public, and it bears fruit in ugly ways. Now let’s be clear — the idiots who are going out and shooting random cops are not the good guys – they’re just turning the wheel of greater crackdowns and further violent retaliation. The proper answer is for enlightened cops and enlightened protesters to put aside the cycle of violence and follow a more Christian path that combines resolution and forgiveness. But police, just like protesters, need to recognize that pursuing the alternative is not good for them.
Seldom is this more obvious than in the case of pipelines. There are oil and gas pipelines all over the United States, and the companies that own them can’t be bothered to spot when they’re leaking or being exposed as Louisiana erodes away. They sure as hell can’t actually protect them if they ever give people something to be madder about than damage to the environment. So that awful picture of tendons blown out of an arm, the news about a woman shot in the eye with a rubber bullet, the people being attacked by dogs, the potential for death by hypothermia — every time they do this they are rolling the dice. Whose wife, whose mother, whose best friend are they going to kill, and in the process turn someone who was a diligent protector of the environment into someone who doesn’t care if the whole Missouri runs under a layer of oil as long as the company might end up paying the cleanup bill? They ought to be thinking about that NOW.
I don’t know the details of the standoff. I do know that the Govt under the last several presidents has been our enemy. There was ZERO need for this kind of treatment of citizens. How many were paid provocateurs? Zero reporting on that.
Just like the Oregon protest where Levoy Finicum was shot dead. No Investigative Journalism on that episode.
The comparison between whiny white boys in Oregon and actual decent Amercans is repugnant…but it’s SO you.
Don’t forget this is a Warren Buffett project, with $6 billion invested in it via Phillips 66; ever since too many of his “oil bomb” BNSF trains started exploding, he wanted the pipeline – for export of oil out of the United States. Since Obama and Clinton are both tools of people like Buffett, they’re not going to protest violent military-style assaults on pipeline protesters. Pretty sickening.
Video: #NoDAPL Protesters Face Water Cannons in Below-Freezing Temperatures
The Obama administration is responsible for the permits and reviews that have allowed this pipeline, and the Obama administration has done nothing to stop this vicious oppression of concerned protesters.
Is this a picture of the arm of the 21 year old New York girl?
https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=227313064368537&set=a.141783596254818.1073741827.100012695355013&type=3&theater
Can anyone explain to me why reporters aren’t actually on-site during these protests? It seems like every account I’ve read of this entire protest is second-hand. There are no videos or first person accounts available on traditional/corporate sources.
Why aren’t people being shown what’s happening on the ground? (I’ll pretend like I don’t know the answer)
Perhaps the media do not care- or are on the side of oil.
One hopes the sovreign tribes can see that the federal government will not protect them. Perhaps they can begin to assert their sovreignty over their lands.
If you’ve been depending on the mainstream news media outlets, print and TV, to report on this, you’re correct that you’re getting not only second hand, but also stenography of what police say, such as what the lying sheriff Kyle Kirchmeier was reported to have said in this report. But TYT Politics has been reporting on The Water Protectors #NoDapl #StandingRock extensively, much of the reporting being on sight and first hand. Also Their mother website, TYT, has also been reporting on it as has Jimmy Dore. Please check out all three of those.
Look up Amy Goodman @ Democracy Now! Her pipeline reporting went viral back in October when DN! released her story and a video featuring private security guards using German Shepherds to attack the demonstrators.
Here’s a link from TYT Politics which includes multiple videos which are exclusively about the fight against the Dakota Access Pipeline.
TYT Politics — Native Americans Fight Dakota Access Pipeline
Jordan Chariton of TYT has been on-site often, as well. TYT and Democracy Now! are relatively on top of it
If you don’t mind becoming ‘a brainwashed Putin slave’ by learning about what is happening in the US, you could check out RT.
I guess the police blockade on what already seems like a remote region is partly to blame. But yes, now I actually wish TI would have someone on the ground there, as they did during the Fergusson protests IIRC and some other occasions.
These displays of brutality and indifference on the part of governments are vile and disgusting. Shades of Bull Connor. This country went to war against the fascism of other countries in 1941. We have yet to join the battle against fascism in our own country.
I actually know someone who is protesting there. She’s a black college student who thinks she’s Cherokee (from a well-to-do family)… and she’s got a really bad chip on her shoulder. She hates everyone.
I think the water cannons and tear gas might knock that chip off her shoulder.
OR the water cannon might just kill her.. Either one is fine by Truth Seaker.
I don’t wish that stuff on anyone.
Under the circumstances, someone needs to knock it off her shoulder.
See… she’s part of the Cult of Obama. YES, this is absolute fact… she hangs out in DC… gets funded by [whomever]… she utters repetitive soundbites… has no idea what she’s ranting about… nada!
It’s actually pretty sick. I knew her before she joined the “Cult.”
And the point of this comment is…?
She’s part of a liberal *** cult ***.
The leadership of that cult is no different than Jim Jones. Remember him?
Recommend testing victims for heavy metals and radioactive isotopes.
It’s almost as if Morton County Sheriff Kyle Kirchmeier has no idea there are video cameras there.
http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2016/11/21/standing-rock-police-attack-protesters-again-he-just-smiled-and-shot-both-my-kneecaps.html
Thank you for reporting on this Alleen. It’s been a bit of a drought on this story here. Please keep up the pressure.
Putting a face to the name
Thanks for this article, but it leaves out Obama’s cowardice in confronting the oppression here. If this was occurring under Trump, it would be rightly declared to be his responsibility – but Obama gets a pass, it seems, and you don’t even mention the fucking bastard once.
Ben Norton reports:
Declaring the police actions “nothing short of horrific,” she asked Obama to “step in to stop the pipeline and end the violence immediately.”
This is Obama’s America, his gift to Trump.
“This is Obama’s America, his gift to Trump.”
This needs to be said over and over and over again. He’s not going to stop this pipeline, he’s not going to pardon Manning or Snowden or Sterling or anyone else he has victimized. His legacy is a joke.