At least 15 companies with financial ties to Oklahoma Attorney General Scott Pruitt, Donald Trump’s nominee to run the Environmental Protection Agency, have faced hundreds of EPA enforcement actions, which are the basic tool the agency uses to enforce environmental rules and laws.
Among the Pruitt donors with enforcement cases against them in recent years are Continental Resources, an oil company that contributed to Liberty 2.0, a pro-Pruitt Super PAC; Murray Energy, which was a co-party in eight of 14 lawsuits Pruitt filed against the EPA and contributed to his political campaigns; and Devon Energy, which raised money for the Republican Attorneys General Association when Pruitt led it and whose lawyers penned a letter that Pruitt sent to the EPA. Peabody Energy, whose executive Fred Palmer contributed to Pruitt’s 2014 re-election campaign for Oklahoma attorney general, is the parent company of 12 separate coal companies that have faced EPA enforcement actions. In addition to the energy companies, the agricultural company Monsanto, which contributed to Pruitt’s 2010 and 2014 election campaign, has been named in 96 formal administrative cases, according to EPA records. It’s impossible to tally a complete list of the enforcement cases filed against Pruitt donors because some donations, such as those to the most recent pro-Pruitt PAC, Protecting America Now, can be made secretly.
Some of the enforcement actions were small, such as the investigation and citation that led the EPA to fine Chesapeake Energy $500 for discharging oil into a waterway flowing into Kentucky’s Cumberland River — that was one of four cases brought by the EPA against Chesapeake. And sometimes the agency’s efforts to enforce the rules fail, as they did when the EPA lost its 2013 suit against Oklahoma Gas & Electric over emissions from two of its plants that, according to the complaint, violated the Clean Air Act. Oklahoma Gas & Electric contributed to Pruitt’s 2002, 2010, and 2014 re-election campaigns.
But other enforcement efforts were much larger, such as the one that resulted in a settlement with Southern Coal and 26 affiliated mining companies in 2016. Southern Coal is a division of Southern Power, which has been co-party in four of Pruitt’s 14 suits against the EPA. (A Southern executive, L. Ray Harry, contributed to Pruitt’s 2014 re-election fund.) An EPA investigation of Southern Coal found numerous violations of the Clean Water Act at its mines in Appalachia, which according to EPA records impacted waterways, killing fish and endangering the health of local communities. The EPA’s response, which included instituting preventive measures, data tracking, and training of mine workers, cost some $5 million and eliminated an estimated 5 million pounds of pollution from being released into local waterways.
Whatever their size, enforcement actions are “the backbone of our environmental program,” said Cynthia Giles, who stepped down from her position as assistant administrator of the Office of Enforcement and Compliance Assurance, or OECA, on January 20. “Enforcement is how we make the protections of environmental laws real on the ground. It’s everything from taking on the big multinational corporations who are cutting corners at the expense of public health to the very local small matters that are hugely important to local communities.”
Yet these actions, which are necessary to keep pollutants out of our air and water, will likely be severely scaled back if and when Pruitt takes over the EPA. Pruitt, whose confirmation may be up for a vote in the Senate this week, dismantled the environmental protection unit in Oklahoma in 2011 and as attorney general largely abandoned environmental regulation in that state. The Trump administration’s plan for the EPA involves not just installing a proven opponent of environmental enforcement as head of the EPA, but possibly shuttering its enforcement arm, according to a recent report from Inside EPA.
While the vote on Pruitt’s nomination has been delayed as a result of a Democratic boycott, the ACLU and the Center for Media and Democracy sued the Oklahoma Attorney General’s Office in an effort to obtain more than 3,000 of Pruitt’s emails with energy industry groups and corporations, including Koch, Exxon, and Murray. On Friday, the Oklahoma Attorney General’s Office released 411 of the emails, which document frequent communications and regular meetings between Pruitt and energy companies and industry groups. Today, the Center for Media and Democracy amended its lawsuit in an effort to obtain the thousands of remaining emails. An Oklahoma judge is scheduled to hear the case on Thursday, according to the center’s Nick Surgey.
Eliminating OECA, which was established in the early 1990s, would be in keeping with how Pruitt handled environmental enforcement as Oklahoma attorney general. According to Giles, it would also be a “colossally bad idea.”
Top photo: Loaded Norfolk Southern Coal trains at Lambert’s Point Coal Terminal in Norfolk, Va., on Nov. 26, 2013.
no worries. Gas fracking is destroying the shock absorbers under the entire state of oklahoma and the deadly chemicals going into the ground will leach into the water supply of drinking water and agriculture water. In the coming years the state of oklahoma will be no more and Scottie Prunomore will have some ‘splainin’ to do as to how he helped real living human beings who were forced to birth under his tyranny.
I’m from Oklahoma, so I’ve had to watch this dude ruin everything for years. Just last year, he rewrote Oklahoma’s successful medical marijuana ballot initiative to make it sound like a recreational marijuana ballot (in order to dissuade voters), then arbitrarily denied it a place on the 2016 ballot (despite the ballot initiative meeting all of the state’s deadlines).
It took activist groups multiple petitions and several years to get enough signatures, and he just waived it all away with the stroke of a pen. Considering he’s also the dude who tried to sue Colorado for the grave sin of having medical marijuana (http://www.denverpost.com/2016/03/21/supreme-court-denies-oklahoma-and-nebraska-challenge-to-colorado-pot/), I guess none of that should be a surprise.
Anyways, under his environmental leadership, the fossil fuel industry has been allowed to completely trash the state. Thanks to excessive fracking and waste water injection wells, Oklahoma now has more earthquakes than any other place in the world (http://www.ecowatch.com/its-official-oklahoma-experiences-more-earthquakes-than-anywhere-else–1882119660.html).
So, um, on behalf of Oklahoma, sorry y’all.
I’m from O&G.
Do any number of worm holes in your front yard cause earthquakes?
Neither do drill holes.
Earthquakes happen because of massive shifts tectonic plates several miles deep into the earths crust.
The earth is just like a liquid filled golf ball. A liquid core surrounded by several hundred rubber bands surrounded by a kryptonite shell.
At least people are making a profit while destroying their environment. It would be such a waste otherwise.
I think I’m gonna start a company that takes the waste water generated by the refineries, bottles it, and sell it as vitamin water. I’ll ask DeVos to market it in charter schools and Paul Ryan to hawk it on his fitness vlog.
What a CAD you are. The Chicago public school system is pathetic. All the union wants is more $ for them and their retirements. I serviced pc’s for them, the teachers were in a back room while the kids were lets say doing horse play. The school board lost $55 million when they gave the $ to a guy who lost it, but he made big bonus for doing it. $ gone. Charter schools are GONE now in Chicago and the kids pay the price. One of 1st things DC did was get rid of Charter at prez0 insistence. Now 0 charters. Both systems are hurting ids 4ever.
BFD.
I’ve been in the board rooms of O&G companies.
The EPA shit is just that: Shit. It’s a tax.
When an OG company needs to do something, with a well, for instance, they figure out how much money the well will make. They consider the costs of EPA compliance. They figure the amount of tax (aka fine) if they don’t spend a billion dollars preventing a drop of oil from touching the ground.
SImple math: Gross profit – tax (fine) < EPA compliance….
Pay the tax. Bureaucrats are happy.
BELIEVABLE! It is a sad day when I am no longer surprised by the corruption big money can buy! We have got to get this BIG money out of government. Our capitalism is at it worst… I believe it is evolved to corporatism!
Death Race, 2050