How Obama’s Asia Pivot Nudged China Toward Pakistan but Helped Aggravate India

U.S. efforts to restrain China's influence in East Asia have helped galvanize Chinese investments in Pakistan, its western neighbor.

Photo: Farooq Naeem/AFP/Getty Images

After many disastrous years spent trying to shape the Middle East, the Obama administration has refocused its foreign policy toward defending U.S. interests in economically wealthy East Asia. President Obama’s “pivot to Asia” is widely perceived as an attempt by the United States to contain China’s growing economic and political clout in that region. But the resulting increase in U.S. pressure on China’s eastern periphery has had an interesting side-effect — it has led China to look elsewhere on the continent for opportunities to trade, invest, and build diplomatic influence.

A major target of this redirected effort has been China’s neighbor to its west, Pakistan. A series of joint Chinese-Pakistani infrastructure projects are now underway, branded collectively as the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC). These investments are intended to build Pakistan’s economic capacity and increase its links to western China, while giving China access to port facilities on the Indian Ocean.

Although the project could have significant long-term economic benefits to the region, it has engendered tensions with India, which has had contentious relations with both China and Pakistan in the past. How China navigates this effort to expand its influence with Pakistan, and how other powerful countries respond, could determine whether South and Central Asia embark on a new era of shared prosperity or remain trapped in a cycle of conflict.

Pakistan President Mamnoon Hussain (L) meets with Chinese Premier Li Keqiang (R) at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing, China, 20 February 2014. Hussain is on a four day visit to China to bolster bilateral ties including a range of agreements on economy and trade.   AFP PHOTO / POOL / ADRIAN BRADSHAW        (Photo credit should read ADRIAN BRADSHAW/AFP/Getty Images)

Pakistani President Mamnoon Hussain, left, meets with Chinese Premier Li Keqiang, right, in Beijing, China, on Feb. 20, 2014, while visiting to bolster bilateral ties including agreements on economy and trade.

Photo: Adrian Bradshaw/AFP/Getty Images

During a state visit to Pakistan in 2015, Chinese President Xi Jinping signed a series of high-profile agreements for Chinese companies to construct roughly $46 billion worth of highways, ports, and energy infrastructure in Pakistan. The projects are related to a larger Chinese effort to expand its economic and political influence in Asia, known as the Silk Road Economic Initiative. The massive investment in Pakistan is also seen as providing an economic anchor to the longstanding military and political relationship between the two countries.

Speaking to the Pakistani parliament during that visit, Xi highlighted a history of traumatic events that brought the two countries together over the latter half of the 20th century. “Both China and Pakistan suffered from imperialist and colonialist aggression and oppression and we extended mutual sympathy and support to each other,” he said. “We will never forget that Pakistan was one of the first countries to recognize New China and the first Islamic country to enter into diplomatic relations with China.” He noted that in its early years, Pakistan helped the nascent People’s Republic of China circumvent a blockade by foreign powers and claim a seat at the United Nations.

Pakistani politicians have promised that the billions of dollars in Chinese infrastructure projects will be a “game changer” for Pakistan’s economy after years of instability. But the huge political capital invested in the projects has also bred fears that the projects will be undermined by Pakistan’s strategic rivals. The Pakistani military — whose leaders are often unhealthily fixated on India even during calm times — have repeatedly claimed that Indian intelligence agents and their proxies are fomenting attacks aimed at sabotaging CPEC projects.

While views among Indian politicians vary, hawkish figures in the ruling party do tend to view CPEC with trepidation. On India’s Independence Day this August, Prime Minister Narendra Modi gave a speech that seemingly offered support to separatist insurgents in regions of Pakistan where major CPEC projects are located. “Today from the ramparts of Red Fort, I want to greet and express my thanks to some people,” Modi said. “In the last few days, people of Balochistan, Gilgit, Pakistan Occupied Kashmir have thanked me, have expressed gratitude, and expressed good wishes for me.”

Modi’s speech was widely viewed in Pakistan as a threat to undermine CPEC. It was also viewed with alarm in China, where the CPEC investments are seen as both an economic opportunity and a means of stabilizing Pakistan, a neighbor that has teetered uncomfortably close to the brink of chaos over the past decade.

Terrorist attacks in Pakistan have dropped over the past two years following the launch of a major military campaign in the tribal regions, but the country remains beset by a number of serious challenges to its long-term stability and prosperity. China’s investment is viewed as a means of shoring up Pakistan’s economy, creating a new market for its own excess production, and reducing Chinese dependence on other trade routes in Southeast Asia, particularly the Strait of Malacca.

“There is a mindset on China’s part that there is a need to stabilize their western periphery, and that the best means to do so are economic,” says Andrew Small, senior Asia fellow at the German Marshall Fund, a trans-Atlantic think tank. “Chinese state industries have a lot of excess capacity that they are seeking to export. Meanwhile, in Pakistan, the current government was elected on promises to kickstart the economy with grand infrastructure plans and energy projects, so there is a neat convergence of interests.”

Small is the author of The China-Pakistan Axis, a 2015 book analyzing the strategic relationship between the two countries that has developed over the past several decades. Historically, this relationship has been anchored in military and political cooperation at the elite level. Pakistani diplomats famously helped engineer China’s rapprochement with the United States during the Nixon era, while China has long been a source of military hardware and intelligence cooperation for the Pakistani armed forces.

But now China is beginning to view Pakistan as a place to showcase its ability to project soft power as well. Despite its mammoth population as well as its economic and military size, from a political standpoint China remains relatively isolated in its region. Relations with Japan, India, and the ASEAN countries are often contentious, while Chinese patronage of North Korea is generally seen as more of a burden than an alliance. As Small writes, China’s warm relationship with Pakistan is thus seen by Chinese leaders as an outlier, offering a foreign policy relationship that has been “tested out over decades, commands deep support from across the political spectrum and institutions of state, and has a base of public support.”

That relationship didn’t mean much to the rest of the world when China was preoccupied with its own instability. But now that the country has emerged as a major economic and political power, its foreign policy preferences matter a lot more. “China is looking to develop power-projection capabilities in the Middle East, East Africa, and Indian Ocean, to allow it to conduct operations like the 2011 evacuation of its workers in Libya,” Small says. “China needs facilities that Pakistan provides, but there is also a desire to demonstrate that Chinese diplomatic relationships have strong benefits to prospective allies, both politically and economically.”

Pakistani labourers arrange a welcoming billboard featuring pictures of visiting Chinese President Xi Jinping (C) and his Pakistani counterpart Mamnoon Hussain (L) and Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif (R) in Islamabad on April 18, 2015. Pakistan needs a "huge amount of financing" for infrastructure and energy projects and China is ready to announce help when President Xi Jinping visits next week, a foreign ministry official said April 17, 2015. AFP PHOTO / Farooq NAEEM        (Photo credit should read FAROOQ NAEEM/AFP/Getty Images)

Pakistani workers arrange a welcoming billboard featuring pictures of visiting Chinese President Xi Jinping, center, his Pakistani counterpart, Mamnoon Hussain, left, and Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif, right, in Islamabad, Pakistan, on April 18, 2015.

Photo: Farooq Naeem/AFP/Getty Images
The CPEC project is thus envisioned as a kind of Marshall Plan for Pakistan’s economy. It is estimated that power shortages drain as much as 2 percent of Pakistan’s GDP annually, while a lack of infrastructure prevents local industries from developing to their full capacity. CPEC would address these shortcomings with energy projects, highways, and the development of a major port facility in the Indian Ocean town of Gwadar.

For China, CPEC is also an answer to American efforts to box out its economic influence in East Asia. Earlier this year, Obama signed the Trans-Pacific Partnership, a trade agreement intended to solidify the United States as the key economic player in East Asia. Naval tensions have also increased in the South China Sea, where U.S. allies are engaged in a series of long-running territorial disputes with China.

But despite seeking to contain Chinese influence in East Asia, the United States has taken a generally benign view of the CPEC project. Some in the U.S. see the project as a means of helping stabilize Pakistan, a nuclear-armed country that spent the past decade wracked by a domestic insurgency. With an overwhelmingly young population of nearly 200 million people, Pakistan is the sixth biggest country in the world by population. Generating stability in Pakistan through economic growth could be a win-win for an American administration whose own relationship with Pakistan has soured — and that is otherwise wary of seeing its allies courted by a regional rival like China.

Views differ in India, however. Modi’s hostility toward the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor represents a school of thinking in Indian foreign policy circles that sees an economically revitalized Pakistan connected to China as a potential threat. Sensitive about foreign interference in India’s own restive province of Kashmir, India’s suspicious view of the project seems to reflect historic fears of strategic coordination by hostile neighbors.

But analysts say there is little to indicate that CPEC is rooted in such a strategy.

“The China-Pakistan Economic Corridor is basically an economic project, despite some in Delhi and Washington viewing it through a strategic lens,” says Arif Rafiq, a non-resident fellow at the Middle East Institute and specialist on Pakistan. “The primary goal is addressing Pakistan’s energy crisis, with a view towards lifting the economy and reducing both Chinese and Pakistani dependence on existing ports and maritime trade routes.”

Instead of starting a new era of conflict, the economic integration of the region could actually help close the chapter on its troubled post-colonial history. If it succeeds in modernizing Pakistan’s infrastructure and boosting its economic output, CPEC could transform Pakistan from a threat to India into a robust trading partner.

“These countries are home to some of the world’s youngest populations and have the potential to be among the biggest zones of economic growth in the coming decades,” Rafiq says. “If they want to move forward and develop stable relations, they need to increase economic connectivity, similar to what France and Germany managed to accomplish after years of conflict.”

Top photo: Pakistani residents walk past welcome banners ahead of a visit by Chinese President Xi Jinping in Islamabad on April 18, 2015.

Join The Conversation