In Senate Bid Launch, Conor Lamb Appears to Misremember His Own Record

The Pennsylvania representative cast himself as an advocate for Democrats and an anathema to Trump. His voting record says otherwise.

U.S. Rep. Conor Lamb, D-Pa., speaks during the dedication ceremony of the Gladden Acid Mine Drainage Treatment Plant on Tuesday, April 27, 2021, in McDonald, Pa. Construction began in June, 2020. The facility is said to improve water quality and restore sections of Chartiers Creek and Millers Run for fishing and recreation. (Andrew Rush/Pittsburgh Post-Gazette via AP)
Rep. Conor Lamb, D-Pa., speaks during the dedication ceremony of the Gladden Acid Mine Drainage Treatment Plant on April 27, 2021, in McDonald, Pa. Photo: Andrew Rush/Pittsburgh Post-Gazette via AP

Standing outside the union hall for the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers in Pittsburgh, Rep. Conor Lamb, D-Pa., announced his much-awaited Senate bid. “I am Conor Lamb,” he told the several dozen people in attendance. “You all know me, but I’m getting ready to introduce myself all over the state.”

Lamb’s entry into the race has been the topic of much discussion of late. A moderate front-line Democrat, Lamb narrowly won reelection to the House last year and has been eyeing the seat since Sen. Pat Toomey, R-Penn., announced his retirement last year.

In his speech to Pittsburgh union workers on Friday, and in a video his campaign posted Friday morning announcing his entry into the race, Lamb portrayed himself as an antagonist to former President Donald Trump. “I talk with Pennsylvanians every day who have come to believe that our democracy is in crisis. And they’re right,” he said in the video. “The other side denies reality and worships Trump. They’re making it harder to vote, and lying about our elections.”

Such rhetoric marks a 180-degree turn for Lamb, whose voting record has actually been very generous to the former president.

During Lamb’s first session in Congress, he voted almost 70 percent of the time in line with Trump’s positions on issues like opposing a carbon tax, expressing support for the Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency and denouncing calls to abolish ICE, and making signature pieces of the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act permanent. During Lamb’s next session, that number was closer to 10 percent. During his last, the number was zero percent.

Lamb also voted in favor of a measure by former Rep. Steve King, R-Iowa, to fund a border wall under Trump and to extend the ongoing war in Iraq (he was one of just two Democrats to vote for extension). In addition, he voted against the HEROES Act, one of his party’s signature Covid-19 reliefs packages. Other votes Lamb took in recent years include a vote last year against a measure that would have prevented Trump from using military force against protests; a vote against a bill to decriminalize marijuana; and a vote in favor of a failed measure that would have prevented tax-paying families with an undocumented parent from receiving stimulus checks.

But Lamb’s Senate strategy appears to include carefully distancing himself from that record. “Here is the real danger, if they will take such a big lie and place it at the center of their party, you cannot expect them to tell the truth about anything else,” Lamb said of the Republican Party’s attempts to undermine the 2020 election results — a party with which he voted over much of his time in Congress. And that makes sense: Lamb will enter a field of frontrunners in the Democratic primary, namely Pennsylvania Lt. Gov. John Fetterman and state Rep. Malcolm Kenyatta, who are significantly to his left. Lamb, a lifelong moderate, was always expected to take a more centrist lane in the race. But he and Fetterman will be battling over some of the same voters in Pennsylvania’s western and Allegheny County regions.

Lamb won reelection to the House last year by a slim margin of 2 percentage points, which he blamed during a now-infamous post-Election Day House Democratic caucus call on the push from organizers to defund police forces. What Lamb left out was that several of his recent votes — including his vote against the HEROES Act — hadn’t sat well with many of his constituents. Or that while his 2020 House race was close, he still won by a more comfortable margin than in his 2018 special election to the House.

It was always an open question of whether Lamb’s congressional seat would survive upcoming redistricting, or whether it would survive in a way that would make him viable next cycle, said one Democratic strategist close to the race. “He’s got a really nice profile,” they added. “He also has problems. He’s voted with Trump more than any other Democrat.”

Lamb’s campaign did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Join The Conversation