Documents

INTRODUCTION TO NATIONAL SECURITY DIVISION STATISTICS ON UNSEALED INTERNATIONAL TERRORISM AND TERRORISM-RELATED CONVICTIONS The National Security Division’s International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Statistics Chart tracks convictions resulting from international terrorism investigations conducted since September 11, 2001, including investigations of terrorist acts planned or committed outside the territorial jurisdiction of the United States over which Federal criminal jurisdiction exists and those within the United States involving international terrorists and terrorist groups. Convictions listed on the chart involve the use of a variety of Federal criminal statutes available to prevent, disrupt, and punish international terrorism and related criminal activity. The convictions are the product of the Department’s aggressive, consistent, and coordinated national enforcement effort with respect to international terrorism that was undertaken after the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks. Criminal cases arising from international terrorism investigations are divided into two categories, according to the requisite level of coordination and monitoring required by the Counterterrorism Section of the National Security Division (or its predecessor section in the Criminal Division). This coordination and monitoring exists in response to the expanded Federal criminal jurisdiction over and importance of international terrorism matters and the need to ensure coherent, consistent, and effective Federal prosecutions related to such matters. Typically, multiple defendants in a case are classified in the same category. Category I cases involve violations of federal statutes that are directly related to international terrorism and that are utilized regularly in international terrorism matters. These statutes prohibit, for example, terrorist acts abroad against United States nationals, the use of weapons of mass destruction, conspiracy to murder persons overseas, providing material support to terrorists or foreign terrorist organizations, receiving military style training from foreign terrorist organizations, and bombings of public places or government facilities. A complete list of Category I offenses is found in Appendix A. Category II cases include defendants charged with violating a variety of other statutes where the investigation involved an identified link to international terrorism. These Category II cases include offenses such as those involving fraud, immigration, firearms, drugs, false statements, perjury, and obstruction of justice, as well as general conspiracy charges under 18 U.S.C. § 371. Prosecuting terror-related targets using Category II offenses and others is often an effective method – and sometimes the only available method – of deterring and disrupting potential terrorist planning and support activities. This approach underscores the wide variety of tools available in the U.S. criminal justice system for disrupting terror activity. Examples of Category II offenses are listed in Appendix B, and examples of Category II cases are described in Appendix C to illustrate the kinds of connections to international terrorism that are not apparent from the nature of the offenses of conviction themselves. The chart includes the defendant’s name, district, charging date, charges brought, classification category, conviction date and conviction charges. If a convicted defendant has been sentenced, the relevant date and sentence imposed is included. The chart is constantly being updated with new convictions, but currently includes only unsealed convictions from September 11, 2001 to March 18, 2010. The chart does not include defendants whose convictions remain under seal, nor does it include defendants who have been charged with a terrorism or terrorism-related offense but have not been convicted either at trial or by guilty plea. This chart does not include convictions related solely to domestic terrorism. Note that the chart maintained by the National Security Division is distinct from

statistics maintained by the Bureau of Prisons to track inmates with terrorist connections. The chart lists more than 150 defendants classified in Category I and more than 240 defendants classified in Category II. The chart is organized by conviction date, with the most recent convictions first. The earliest defendants included on the chart were identified and detained in the course of the nationwide investigation conducted after September 11, 2001, and were subsequently charged with a criminal offense. Since then, additional defendants have been added who, at the time of charging, appeared to have a connection to international terrorism, even if they were not charged with a terrorism offense. The decision to add defendants to the chart is made on a case-by-case basis by career prosecutors in the National Security Division’s Counterterrorism Section, whose primary responsibility is investigating and prosecuting international and domestic terrorism cases to prevent and disrupt acts of terrorism anywhere in the world that impact on significant United States interests and persons.

Appendix A Category I Offenses Aircraft Sabotage (18 U.S.C. § 32) Animal Enterprise Terrorism (18 U.S.C. § 43) Crimes Against Internationally Protected Persons (18 U.S.C. § § 112, 878, 1116, l201(a)(4)) Use of Biological, Nuclear, Chemical or Other Weapons of Mass Destruction (18 U.S.C. §§ 175, 175b, 229, 831, 2332a) Production, Transfer, or Possession of Variola Virus (Smallpox) (18 U.S.C. § 175c) Participation in Nuclear and WMD Threats to the United States (18 U.S.C. § 832) Conspiracy Within the United States to Murder, Kidnap, or Maim Persons or to Damage Certain Property Overseas (18 U.S.C. § 956) Hostage Taking (18 U.S.C. § 1203) Terrorist Attacks Against Mass Transportation Systems (18 U.S.C. § 1993) Terrorist Acts Abroad Against United States Nationals (18 U.S.C. § 2332) Terrorism Transcending National Boundaries (18 U.S.C. § 2332b) Bombings of places of public use, Government facilities, public transportation systems and infrastructure facilities (18 U.S.C. § 2332f) Missile Systems designed to Destroy Aircraft (18 U.S.C. § 2332g) Production, Transfer, or Possession of Radiological Dispersal Devices (18 U.S.C. § 2332h) Harboring Terrorists (18 U.S.C. § 2339) Providing Material Support to Terrorists (18 U.S.C. § 2339A) Providing Material Support to Designated Terrorist Organizations (18 U.S.C. § 2339B) Prohibition Against Financing of Terrorism (18 U.S.C. § 2339C) Receiving Military-Type Training from an FTO (18 U.S.C. § 2339D) Narco-Terrorism (21 U.S.C. § 1010A) Sabotage of Nuclear Facilities or Fuel (42 U.S.C. § 2284) Aircraft Piracy (49 U.S.C. § 46502) Violations of IEEPA (50 U.S.C. § 1705(b)) involving E.O. 12947 (Terrorists Who Threaten to Disrupt the Middle East Peace Process); E.O. 13224 (Blocking Property and Prohibiting Transactions With Persons Who Commit, Threaten to Commit, or Support Terrorism or Global Terrorism List); and E.O. 13129 (Blocking Property and Prohibiting Transactions With the Taliban)

Appendix B Examples of Category II Offenses Crimes Committed Within the Special Maritime and Territorial Jurisdiction of the United States (l8 U.S.C. §§ 7, 113, 114, 115, 1111, 1112, 1201, 2111) Violence at International Airports (18 U.S.C. § 37) Arsons and Bombings (18 U.S.C. §§ 842(m), 842(n), 844(f), 844(I)) Killings in the Course of Attack on a Federal Facility (18 U.S.C. § 930(c)) False Statements (18 U.S.C. § 1001) Protection of Computers (18 U.S.C. § 1030) False Information and Hoaxes (18 U.S.C. § 1038) Genocide (18 U.S.C. § 1091) Destruction of Communication Lines (18 U.S.C. § 1362) Sea Piracy (18 U.S.C. § 1651) Unlicensed Money Remitter Charges (18 U.S.C. § 1960) Wrecking Trains (18 U.S.C. § 1992) Destruction of National Defense Materials, Premises, or Utilities (18 U.S.C. § 2155) Violence against Maritime Navigation and Maritime Fixed Platforms (18 U.S.C. §§ 2280, 2281) Torture (18 U.S.C. § 2340A) War Crimes (18 U.S.C. § 2441) International Traffic in Arms Regulations (22 U.S.C. § 2778, and the rules and regulations promulgated thereunder, 22 C.F.R. § 121-130) Crimes in the Special Aircraft Jurisdiction other than Aircraft Piracy (49 U.S.C. §§ 46503-46507) Destruction of Interstate Gas or Hazardous Liquid Pipeline Facilities (49 U.S.C. § 60123(b))

Appendix C Examples of Category II Terrorism-Related Convictions Fort Dix Plot (conspiracy to murder members of the U.S. military). In 2008, following a jury trial in the United States District Court for the District of New Jersey, Ibrahim Shnewer, Dritan Duka, Shain Duka, Eljvir Duka and Serdar Tatar were convicted of violating 18 U.S.C. §1117, in connection with a plot to kill members of the U.S. military in an armed attack on the military base at Fort Dix, New Jersey. The defendants were also convicted of various weapons charges. The government’s evidence revealed that one member of the group conducted surveillance at Fort Dix and Fort Monmouth in New Jersey, Dover Air Force Base in Delaware, and the U.S. Coast Guard in Philadelphia. The group obtained a detailed map of Fort Dix, where they hoped to use assault rifles to kill as many soldiers as possible. During the trial, the jury viewed secretly recorded videotapes of the defendants performing small-arms training at a shooting range in the Poconos Mountains in Pennsylvania and of the defendants watching training videos that included depictions of American soldiers being killed and of known Islamic radicals urging jihad against the United States. Fawaz Damrah (citizenship fraud). In 2004, following a jury trial in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Ohio, Fawaz Damrah was convicted of violating 18 U.S.C. § 1425 for concealing material facts in his citizenship application. The government’s evidence showed that in his citizenship application, Damrah concealed from the U.S. government his membership in or affiliation with the Palestinian Islamic Jihad (PIJ), a.k.a. the Islamic Jihad Movement in Palestine; the Afghan Refugees Services, Inc., a.k.a. Al-Kifah Refugee Center; and the Islamic Committee for Palestine. Damrah further concealed the fact that he had, prior to his application for U.S. citizenship, “incited, assisted, or otherwise participated in the persecution” of Jews and others by advocating violent terrorist attacks against Jews and others. During the trial, the government’s evidence included footage of a 1991 speech in which Damrah called Jews “the sons of monkeys and pigs,” and a 1989 speech in which he declared that “terrorism and terrorism alone is the path to liberation.” Soliman Biheiri (false statements and passport fraud). In 2003 and 2004, following two jury trials in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, Soliman Biheiri was convicted of violating 18 U.S.C. §§ 1425 and 1546 for fraudulently procuring a passport, as well as 18 U.S.C. §§ 1001 and 1015 for making false statements to federal agents. Biheiri was the president of BMI, Inc., a New Jersey-based investment firm. The government’s evidence showed that Biheiri had deliberately deceived federal agents during a June 2003 interview in which he denied having business or personal ties to Mousa Abu Marzook, a Specially Designated Global Terrorist and a leader of Hamas. In fact, the government’s evidence showed that Biheiri had managed funds for Marzook both before and after Marzook was designated as a terrorist by the U.S. government in 1995. Specifically, the government presented files seized from Biheiri’s computer showing that Marzook had invested $1 million in U.S. business ventures managed by Biheiri and his investment firm. Mohammad Salman Farooq Qureshi (false statements). In 2005, following the entry of a guilty plea in the United States District Court for the Western District of Louisiana, Qureshi was convicted of violating 18 U.S.C. § 1001 for making false statements to the FBI regarding the nature and extent of his involvement with al-Qaeda member Wadih El Hage, and the non-

governmental organization Help Africa People. Qureshi was interviewed by the FBI in 1997, 1998, 2000, and 2004 in relation to terrorism crimes and during those interviews lied about his knowledge of El Hage, Help Africa People, and other al Qaeda members. The proffer filed in support of the plea agreement established Qureshi’s connections to and contacts with El Hage, his contact with a subject under investigation in Oregon, and his activities and financial support of Help Africa People, a non-governmental organization believed to have been used by El Hage and others to provide cover identities and funds in connection with the 1998 attacks on the United States Embassies in Kenya and Tanzania. By Qureshi’s admissions, at least $30,000 in Qureshi’s funds were given to El Hage in Nairobi, Kenya. El Hage is serving a life sentence for his role in the East Africa Embassy bombings. Sabri Benkahla (perjury, obstruction, false statements). In 2007, following a jury trial in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, Sabri Benkahla was convicted on two counts of violating 18 U.S.C. §1623, for perjury, one count of violating 18 U.S.C. § 1503 for obstructing justice, and one count of violating 18 U.S.C. § 1001 for making false statements to the FBI. These false statements included denial of his involvement with an overseas jihad training camp in 1999, as well as his asserted lack of knowledge about individuals with whom he was in contact. The government’s evidence revealed that the grand jury and FBI in 2004 sought to question Benkahla about his contacts with Ibrahim Buisir of Ireland, and Manaf Kasmuri of Malaysia, both of whom are Specially Designated Global Terrorists, as well as those with Ahmed Abu Ali, his friend and fellow student at the University of Medina, until both were arrested by Saudi authorities in June 2003. Further, the government’s evidence revealed that the grand jury and FBI sought to question Benkahla about his contacts with an individual suspected of being Malik al-Tunisi, a facilitator for the al-Zarqawi terrorist network in Iraq. Akram Musa Abdallah (false statements). In 2009, following the entry of a guilty plea in the United States District Court for the District of Arizona, Akram Musa Abdallah was convicted of violating 18 U.S.C. § 1001 for making false statements to the FBI. In January 2007, Abdallah knowingly made a false material statement to special agents of the FBI during an interview in connection with the federal investigation and prosecution of the Holy Land Foundation for Relief & Development (HLF) and its officers. At the time of the interviews, Abdallah knew the HLF was a Specially Designated Global Terrorist organization. Abdallah also knew that when he was interviewed, the HLF and its officers were pending trial in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas, for crimes including providing material support to a foreign terrorist organization. During the interviews, Abdallah told FBI agents he was not involved in fundraising activities for the HLF, when, in fact, between approximately 1994 and 1997, Abdallah was involved in numerous fundraising activities, including collecting donations, organizing, facilitating and coordinating fund raising events on behalf of the HLF in the Phoenix metropolitan area. In July 2004, the HLF and seven of its principals were indicted on a variety of charges stemming from its financial support of Hamas, and in November 2008, after a twomonth trial, those defendants were convicted on all charges.

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date Charges Category Conv Date Conviction Charges I 18-Mar-10 18/2332f(a)(2); 18/956; 18/2332(a)(1),(2) x 6; 18/2339A; 18/956(a)(1); 18/2339A; 18/2339B. 1 Headley, David Coleman NDIL 11-Oct-09 18/956; 18/2339A [Information filed 12/07/09 charging: 18/2332f(a)(2); 18/956; 18/2332(a)(1),(2) x 6; 18/2339A; 18/956(a)(1); 18/2339A; 18/2339B] 2 Conde Rubio, Nancy DDC 25-Sep-07 18/2339B x 2 I 17-Mar-10 18/2339B 3 Afzali, Ahmad Wais EDNY 19-Oct-09 18/1001 II 4-Mar-10 18/1001 4 Zazi, Najibullah EDNY 23-Sep-09 18/2332a(a)(2) & 3551 et seq [Superseding Information: 18/2332a; 18/956; 18/2339B] I 22-Feb-10 18/2332a; 18/956; 18/2339B 5 Siddiqui, Aafia SDNY 02-Sep-08 18/2332(b); 18/1114; 18/111; 18/924(c) I 03-Feb-10 18/2332(b); 18/1114; 18/111; 18/924(c) 6 Taleb-Jedi, Zanaib EDNY 29-Sep-06 18/2339B; [By information on 12/07/09: 50/1705(b)] I 07-Dec-09 50/1705(b) 7 Ali, Adarus Abdulle DMN 27-Oct-09 18/1623(a) [by Information] II 02-Nov-09 18/1623(a) [by Information] I 29-Sep-09 18/2339C, 18/371 Sent Date Sentence 8 Alishtari, Abdul Tawala Ibn Ali (a/k/a Michael Mixon) SDNY 14-Feb-07 18/2339C &2 , 18/2339A, 18/1956(a)(2)(A) & 2; 18/1349; 18/1343 & 2 [Superseding Information filed 9/29/09 charged him with 18/2339C and 18/371] 9 Sadequee, Ehsanul Islam NDGA 19-Jul-06 18/956, 18/2332b, 18/2339B [3SI 12/08/09 2x 18/2339A & 2x 18/2339B] I 12-Aug-09 2x 18/2339A(a); 2x 18/2339B(a)(1) 14-Dec-09 17 years, 30 years of supervised release EDNY 04-Jan-03 18/2339B I 07-Aug-09 18/2339B 07-Aug-09 Time Served; ordered deported to Yemen 11 Moshen Yahya EDNY 04-Jan-03 18/2339B I 07-Aug-09 18/2339B 07-Aug-09 Time Served; ordered deported to Yemen 12 Socrates, Nachimuthu EDNY 14-Sep-06 18/2339B; 2x 18/371 & 3551 I 15-Jun-09 2x 18/371 & 3551 13 Ahmed, Syed Haris NDGA 23-Mar-06 18/2339A, 18/2339B, 18/956, 18/2332b I 10-Jun-09 18/2339A [bench trial] 14 Kandasamy, Karunakaran EDNY 21-May-07 18/2339B [6/09/09 Superseding Information: 18/2339B & 18/371, 3551] I 09-Jun-09 18/2339B; 18/371, 3551 15 Patpanathan, Vijayshanthar EDNY 14-Sep-06 18/2339B I 09-Jun-09 18/2339B 16 Thavaraja, Pratheepan 14-Sep-06 18/2339B; 18/371 & 3551 I 09-Jun-09 18/2339B; 18/371 & 3551 Al-Moayad, Mohammed Ali 10 Hasan Zayed, Mohammed EDNY Page 1 of 26 14-Dec-09 13 years

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date Charges Category Conv Date Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence EDNY 14-Sep-06 18/2339B; 2x 18/371 & 3551; 50/1705 (b), 18/2 & 3551 I 09-Jun-09 18/2339B 18 Abdullah DMN 20-Jan-04 2x 18/2339B, 3x18/1001 I 20-May-09 18/2339B 09-Jul-09 19 Abraham, Patrick SDFL 22-Jun-06 18/2339A, 18/2339B, 18/844(n), 18/2384 I 12-May-09 18/2339A, 18/2339B, 18/844(n) 19-Nov-09 112.5 months; 15 years SR 20 Augustin, Burson SDFL 22-Jun-06 18/2339A, 18/2339B, 18/844(n), 18/2384 I 12-May-09 18/2339A, 18/2339B 18-Nov-09 72 months; 10 years SR 21 Augustine, Rotschild SDFL 22-Jun-06 18/2339A, 18/2339B, 18/844(n), 18/2384 I 12-May-09 18/2339A, 18/2339B 18-Nov-09 84 months; 10 years SR 22 Batiste, Narseal SDFL 22-Jun-06 18/2339A, 18/2339B, 18/844(n), 18/2384 I 12-May-09 18/2339A, 18/2339B, 18/844(n), 18/2384 20-Nov-09 162 months; 35 years SR 23 Phanor, Stanley Grant SDFL 22-Jun-06 18/2339A, 18/2339B, 18/844(n), 18/2384 I 12-May-09 18/2339A, 18/2339B 19-Nov-09 96 months; 15 years SR I 12-May-09 2x 18/2339A; 18/2339A(a); 4x 2339B(a)(1); 2x 18/956(a); 18/842(p)(2)(A); 18/371 15-Sep-09 Life Vinayagamoorthy, 17 Murugesu Warsame, Mohammed 24 Kassir, Oussama SDNY 06-Feb-06 2x 18/2339A; 18/2339A(a); 4x 2339B(a)(1); 2x 18/956(a); 18/842(p)(2)(A); 18/371; 18/229(a) [18/229(a) was dismissed] 25 Abdallah, Akram DAZ 19-Aug-08 18/1001 II 06-May-09 18/1001 26 al-Marri, Ali Saleh Kalah CDIL 26-Feb-09 2x 18/2339B I 30-Apr-09 18/2339B 27 Isse, Abdifatah Yusuf DMN 19-Feb-09 18/ 2339A; 18/956 I 24-Apr-09 18/2339A 01-Aug-07 2x18/2339A, 13x50/1705(b), 18/1001 I 31-Mar-09 18/2339A 29-May-07 18/2339B; 18/2332(b); 18/ 1114 and 1117; 18/2332g I 17-Mar-09 18/2339B; 18/ 1114, 1117 & 3238; 18/2332g (a)(1), (b)(4) & 3238 I 26-Feb-09 18/2332(b)(2) 28 Abdhir, Rahmat 29 Al Ghazi, Tareq Mousa NDCA SDNY 30 Al Delaema, Wesam DDC 09-Sep-05 18/2332(b); 18/2332a(a)(1) & (a)(3); 18/924(c)(1)(A) & (c)(1)(B)(ii); 18/924(o) 31 Hassan, Kamal DMN 11-Feb-09 18/USC 2339A; 18/2339B [both by Information]; 18/1001 [by supplemental Information on 8/12/09] I 18-Feb-09 18/USC 2339A; 18/2339B; and 18/1001 on 8/12/09 32 Ranjha, Imdad Ullah DMD 23-May-07 2x 18/1960(a); 18/1956(h) II 05-Feb-09 18/1960(a) Page 2 of 26 92 months, 3 years SR; ordered deported back to Canada at conclusion of sentence 29-Oct-09 100 months; 3 years SR 01-Jul-09 25 years, 5 years SR 25 years; plus an additional 18 month sentence - (sentences are intended to be served concurrently) 24-Mar-09 Time Served; Supervised Release 2 years; Special Assessment $100

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date 33 Vinas, Bryant Neal EDNY 28-Jan-09 34 Sabaratnam, Sahilal EDNY 35 Thiruthanikan Charges Category Conv Date Conviction Charges 18/956 [by indictment]; 18/2332(b)(2), 18/2339B, 18/2339D [by Superseding Information] I 28-Jan-09 18/2332(b)(2), 18/2339B, 18/ 2339D [Information] 14-Sep-06 2x 18/2339B (a)(1); 2x 2332g (a)(1), (b)(1), (c)(1) I 27-Jan-09 2x 18/2339B (a)(1); 2x 2332g (a)(1), (b)(1), (c)(1) EDNY 14-Sep-06 2x 18/2339B (a)(1); 2x 2332g (a)(1), (b)(1), (c)(1) I 27-Jan-09 2x 18/2339B (a)(1); 2x 2332g (a)(1), (b)(1), (c)(1) 36 Sarachandran, Sathajhan EDNY 14-Sep-06 3x 18/2339B (a)(1); 2x 2332g (a)(1), (b)(1), (c)(1) and 3551 et seq I 26-Jan-09 3x 18/2339B (a)(1); 2x 2332g (a)(1), (b)(1), (c)(1) and 3551 et seq 37 Yograrasa, Nadarasa EDNY 14-Sep-06 2x 18/2339B I 26-Jan-09 2x 18/2339B 38 Sandhu, Parvez Mehmood DMD 23-May-07 18/1960; 18/1956(h) II 21-Jan-09 18/1956(h) 39 Ahmed, Khaleel NDOH 13-Dec-07 18/956(a)(1) [18/2339A by Information on 1/15/09] I 15-Jan-09 18/2339A 40 Ahmed, Zubair A. NDOH 13-Dec-07 18/956(a)(1) [18/2339A by Information on 1/15/09] I 15-Jan-09 18/2339A 41 Elahwal, Saleh SDNY 15-Nov-06 2 x 18/2339B; 2x 18/2339B & 2; 4x 18/371; 3x 22/287c & 2; EO 13224; 31 CFR 594 I 30-Dec-08 42 Iqbal, Javed SDNY 15-Nov-06 2 x 18/2339B; 2x 18/2339B & 2; 4x 18/371; 3x 22/287c & 2; EO 13224; 31 CFR 594 I 43 Duka, Dritan DNJ 07-May-07 18/1117; 18/1114; 18/2; 18/924(c)(1)(a); (c)(1)(B)(ii); 18/922(g)(5); 18/922(o) 44 Duka, Eljvir DNJ 07-May-07 45 Duka, Shain DNJ 46 Ibrahim Sent Date Sentence Thanigasalam, 25-Mar-09 21 months, service of the sentence having begun September 20, 2007; 3 years SR 18/2339B & 2 23-Jun-09 17 months; 3 years SR; 200 hours of community service; $7,500 fine 23-Dec-08 18/2339B & 2 23-Apr-09 69 months; 3 years SR II 22-Dec-08 18/1117; 18/2; 18/924(c)(1)(a); (c)(1)(B)(ii); 18/922(g)(5); 18/922(o) 28-Apr-09 Life plus 30 years 18/1117; 18/1114; 18/2; 18/924(c)(1)(a); (c)(1)(B)(ii); 18/922(g)(5) II 22-Dec-08 18/1117; 18/922(g)(5) 28-Apr-09 Life 07-May-07 18/1117; 18/1114; 18/2; 18/924(c)(1)(a); (c)(1)(B)(ii); 18/922(g)(5); 18/922(o) II 22-Dec-08 18/1117; 18/2; 18/924(c)(1)(a); (c)(1)(B)(ii); 18/922(g)(5); 18/922(o) 28-Apr-09 Life plus 30 years DNJ 07-May-07 18/1117; 18/1114; 18/2; 18/924(c)(1)(a); (c)(1)(B)(ii); II 22-Dec-08 18/1117; 18/924(c)(1)(a); (c)(1)(B)(ii) 29-Apr-09 Life plus 30 years 47 Tatar, Serdar DNJ 07-May-07 18/1117; 18/1114 II 22-Dec-08 18/1117 29-Apr-09 33 years 48 Shareef, Derick NDIL 08-Dec-06 18/2332a; 18/844I by Complaint; Indictment returned 1Jan-07 on 18/2332a. I 28-Nov-08 18/2332a 30-Sep-08 35 years Shnewer, Mohamed Page 3 of 26

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant 49 Abdulqader, Mufid 50 Abu Baker, Shukri District Charge Date NDTX 26-Jul-04 1x 18/2339B; 1x 50/1701-1706; 1x 18/1956(h); 18/982(a)(1) 26-Jul-04 10x18/2339B; 11x 50/1701-1706; 1x 18/1956(h); 10x 18/1956(a)(2)(A); 1x 26/7206(1); 1x 18/371; 18/982(a)(1) NDTX Charges Category Conv Date I 24-Nov-08 1x 18/2339B; 1x 50/1701-1706; 1x 18/1956(h); 18/982(a)(1) 24-Nov-08 10x18/2339B; 11x 50/1701-1706; 1x 18/1956(h); 10x 18/1956(a)(2)(A); 1x 26/7206(1); 1x 18/371; 18/982(a)(1) 27-May-09 65 years I 24-Nov-08 10x 18/2339B; 11x 50/1701-1706; 1x 18/1956(h); 10x 18/1956(a)(2)(A); 1x 18/371; 2x 26/7206; 18/982(a)(1) 27-May-09 65 years I Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence 27-May-09 20 years; 3 years SR 51 Elashi, Ghassan NDTX 26-Jul-04 10x 18/2339B; 11x 50/1701-1706; 1x 18/1956(h); 10x 18/1956(a)(2)(A); 1x 18/371; 2x 26/7206; 18/982(a)(1) 52 El-Mezain, Mohammed NDTX 26-Jul-04 10x 18/2339B; 11x 50/1701-1706; 1x 18/1956(h); 10x 18/1956(a)(2)(A) I 24-Nov-08 18/2339B 27-May-09 15 years; 3 years SR 53 Odeh, Abulraham NDTX 26-Jul-04 1x 18/2339B; 1x 50/1701-1706; 1x 18/1956(h); 18/982(a)(1) I 24-Nov-08 1x 18/2339B; 1x 50/1701-1706; 1x 18/1956(h); 18/982(a)(1) 27-May-09 15 years; 3 years SR 54 Al Kassar, Monzer SDNY 29-May-07 18/2339B; 18/2332(b); 18/ 1114 and 1117; 18/2332g; 18/1956 I 20-Nov-08 18/2339B; 18/2332(b); 18/ 1114 and 1117; 18/2332g; 18/1956 24-Feb-09 30 years 55 Godoy, Luis Felipe Moreno SDNY 29-May-07 18/2339B; 18/2332(b); 18/ 1114 and 1117; 18/2332g; 18/1956 I 20-Nov-08 18/2339B; 18/2332(b); 18/ 1114 and 1117; 18/2332g; 18/1956 24-Feb-09 25 years 56 Chughtai, Mazhar Iqbal DMD 23-May-07 8x 18/1960(a), 18/1956(h) II 16-Sep-08 18/1956(h) 05-Dec-08 51 months; 2 years SR 57 Ranjha, Saifullah Anjum DMD 23-May-07 14x 18/1960(a); 18/1956(h); 18/2339C(c)(1)(A); 14x 31/5313(a) I 22-Aug-08 18/1956(h), 18/2339C(c)(1)(A) 04-Nov-08 110 months, 3 years SR, forfeit $2,208,000 I 18-Jun-08 18/2339A 18-Dec-08 180 months; 3 years SR; $100 SA Mohamed, Ahmed 58 Abdellatif Sherif MDFL 30-Aug-07 18/2339A; 18/842(p)(2)(A); 18/842(a)(3)(A); 26/5861(d) & 26/5871; 2x 18/922(g)(5)(B); 18/924(c) (1)(A) & B; and 6 counts forfeiture 59 Amawi, Mohammad Zaki NDOH 16-Feb-06 18/956(a)(1); 18/2339A; 18/842(p)(2)(A); 18/871 I 13-Jun-08 18/956(a)(1); 18/2339A; 2x 18/842(p)(2)(A) 21-Oct-09 20 years; Life on supervised release 60 El-Hindi, Marwan Othman NDOH 16-Feb-06 18/956(a)(1); 18/2339A; 18/842(p)(2)(A), 18/1001 I 13-Jun-08 18/956(a)(1); 18/2339A; 2x 18/842(p)(2)(A) 21-Oct-09 13 years (includes sentence for sep. fraud conviction) 61 Mazloum, Wassim I. NDOH 16-Feb-06 18/956(a)(1); 18/2339A I 13-Jun-08 18/956(a)(1); 18/2339A 21-Oct-09 100 months (8.3 years); Life on supervised release 62 Paul, Christopher SDOH 11-Apr-07 18/ 371 & 2339A; 18/2332a; 18/2339A I 03-Jun-08 18/2332a(a)(1), (2), (3) and (b) 26-Feb-09 20 years 63 Hupper, Richard David SDFL 13-May-08 2339B [by Information] I 21-May-08 2339B 21-Aug-08 46 months; 2 years SR; $15,000 fine 64 Chhun, Yasith CDCA 31-May-05 18/956(a); 18/956(b); 18/371; 18/2332a(b) I 16-Apr-08 18/956(a); 18/956(b); 18/371; 18/2332a(b) Page 4 of 26

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date 65 Abujihaad, Hassan DCT 21-Mar-07 66 Doudzai, Mohammad DMD 67 Naeem, Nadia Category Conv Date 18/2339A, 18/793(d) I 05-Mar-08 18/2339A, 18/793(d) (NOTE: on 3/4/09 the Court acquitted Abujihaad on the 2339A charge) 03-Apr-09 120 months; 3 years SR 31-Aug-06 18/371; 18/1505; 18/1001 II 04-Feb-08 18/371; 18/1505; 18/1001 18-Apr-08 8 months; 2 years SR DMD 31-Aug-06 18/371; 18/1505; 18/1001 II 04-Feb-08 18/371; 18/1505; 18/1001 18-Apr-08 364 days; 2 years SR 68 Mubayyid, Muhammad DMA 11-May-05 18/1001(a)(1), 18/371, 3x 26/7206(1), 26/7212(a) II 11-Jan-08 18/1001(a)(1), 3x 26/7206(1), 26/7212(a), 18/371 [Dismissed 6/3/08: 18/371] 18-Jul-08 11 months; 3 years SR; $500 SA; $1000 fine 69 Muntasser, Emadeddin DMA 11-May-05 18/1001(a)(1), 18/1001(a)(2), 18/371, [ 26/7212(a) dismissed 12/13/07] II 11-Jan-08 18/1001(a)(1), 18/1001(a)(2), 18/371 [Dismissed 6/3/08: 18/371 & 1 count of 18/1001] 17-Jul-08 12 months; 3 years SR; $10,000 fine WDKY 02-Dec-03 18/371, 18/2315, 26/7206, 18/981, 28/2461 II 17-Dec-07 18/2315 108 Months ; 3 years SR; $100 SPA; 20-Dec-07 $15,000 Fine; Restitution $1,243,162.04 03-Jan-06 8/1324(a)(2)(B)(ii); 8/1324(a)(1)(A)(iv); 8/1324(a)(1)(B)(I); 18/2339B(a)(1); 18/1956(h); 18/1956(a)(3)(A) & 2; 18/371 I 07-Dec-07 18/2339B 70 months, 3 years SR, $100 assessment & 25-Feb-08 removal I 07-Dec-07 18/2339B 70 months, 3 years. SR, $100 assessment & 29-Feb-08 removal upon completion of sentence 70 Suleiman, Eyad Ponton Caro, Carmen 71 Maria SDFL Charges Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence 72 Salamanca, Victor Daniel SDFL 03-Jan-06 8/1324(a)(2)(B)(ii); 8/1324(a)(1)(A)(iv); 8/1324(a)(1)(B)(I); 18/2339B(a)(1); 18/1956(h); 18/1956(a)(3)(A) & 2; 18/371 73 Gamboa, Edizon Ramirez SDFL 03-Jan-06 18/371, 6x 8/1324 II 05-Dec-07 2x 8/1324 36 months, 3 years. SR, $200 assessment & 29-Feb-08 removal upon completion of sentence 74 El-Shwehdi, Zuhair Hamed SDOH 31-Oct-07 26/7206(1); 26/7212(a) II 19-Nov-07 26/7206(1) & 7212(a) 29-Aug-08 3 years probation; $138,098.12 restitution DMD 31-Aug-06 18/371; 18/1505; 18/1001; 18/1546 II 19-Nov-07 18/371; 18/1505; 18/1001; 18/1546 18-Jan-08 22 months; 3 years SR 76 (or Qassem) Ahmed EDCA 28-Sep-06 6x 18/1956(a)(3) [by Information filed 11/15/2007] II 16-Nov-07 6x 18/1956(a)(3) 02-Jun-08 30 months, 3 years SR; $600SA 77 Moheisen, Jalal Sadat SDFL 03-Jan-06 4x 18/2339B, 18/371, 6x 8/1324 I 14-Nov-07 18/2339B 70 months, 3 years. SR, $100 assessment & 25-Feb-08 removal 78 Ricardo SDFL 03-Jan-06 18/371, 6x 18/1324 II 14-Nov-07 18/371, 2x 18/1324 36 months, 3 years. SR, $300 assessment & 25-Feb-08 removal 79 Abdullah, Agron DNJ 07-May-07 18/922(g)(5); 18/371 I 31-Oct-07 18/371 31-Mar-08 20 months 03-Jan-06 8/1324(a)(2)(B)(ii); 8/1324(a)(1)(A)(iv); 8/1324(a)(1)(B)(I); 18/2339B(a)(1); 18/1956(h); 18/1956(a)(3)(A) & 2; 18/371 I 29-Oct-07 8/1324(a)(2)(B)(ii); 18/371 04-Jan-08 75 Nabil, Nabi Muthana, Abdulla Kasem Tapasco Romero, Nicolas Bautista Martinez, Jorge 80 De Los Reyes SDFL Page 5 of 26 3 years

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date Charges Category Conv Date Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence I 29-Oct-07 18/2339B(a)(1) 04-Jan-08 30 months 81 Ulloa Melo, Jose Tito Libio SDFL 03-Jan-06 8/1324(a)(2)(B)(ii); 8/1324(a)(1)(A)(iv); 8/1324(a)(1)(B)(I); 18/2339B(a)(1); 18/1956(h); 18/1956(a)(3)(A) & 2; 18/371 82 Londono, Bernardo Valdes SDFL 03-Jan-06 8/1324(a)(2)(B)(ii); 8/1324(a)(1)(A)(iv); 8/1324(a)(1)(B)(I); 18/2339B(a)(1); 18/371 I 22-Oct-07 18/2339B(a)(1) 04-Jan-08 30 months 03-Jan-06 8/1324(a)(2)(B)(ii); 8/1324(a)(1)(A)(iv); 8/1324(a)(1)(B)(I); 18/2339B(a)(1); 18/1956(h); 18/1956(a)(3)(A) & 2; 18/371 I 15-Oct-07 18/2339B 04-Jan-08 Time Served I 15-Oct-07 18/2339B 04-Jan-08 30 months 83 Lopez, Julio Cesar SDFL Morales, Luis Alfredo Daza 84 (aka Fernando) SDFL 03-Jan-06 8/1324(a)(2)(B)(ii); 8/1324(a)(1)(A)(iv); 8/1324(a)(1)(B)(I); 18/2339B(a)(1); 18/1956(h); 18/1956(a)(3)(A) & 2; 18/371 85 Nguyen, Vinh Tan CDCA 20-Dec-06 18/1544 II 15-Oct-07 18/1544 14-Nov-07 14 months; 2 years SR 86 Padilla, Jose SDFL 17-Nov-05 18/956(a)(1); 18/371; 18/2339A I 16-Aug-07 18/956(a)(1); 18/371; 18/2339A 22-Jan-08 208 months 87 Jayyousi, Kifan SDFL 01-Dec-04 18/2339A, 18/956(a)(1), 18/371 I 16-Aug-07 18/956(a)(1); 18/371; 18/2339A 22-Jan-08 152 months 88 Hassoun, Adham SDFL 08-Jan-04 18/2339A, 18/371; 18/956(a)(1), 922, 1001, 1621, 1505, 924; 21/853 I 16-Aug-07 18/2339A, 8/956(a)(1), 18/371 22-Jan-08 188 months 89 Ujaama, Earnest James SDNY 13-Aug-07 2x 18/2339A, 18/1073; 18/371 (to violate 18/2339A) I 13-Aug-07 3x18/2339A, 18/1073 90 El-Zahabi, Mohammed DMN 25-Jun-04 2x18/1001; 3x 18/1546(a) [added 12/6/05 in superseding indictment] II 02-Aug-07 3x 18/1546(a) 14-Mar-08 Time Served 91 Abdi, Nuradin M. SDOH 14-Jun-04 18/371, 2339A, 956; 2339B, 2x1546 I 31-Jul-07 18/2339A 31-Jul-07 92 Reynolds, Michael Curtis MDPA 03-Oct-06 18/2339A; 18/2339B; 18/373; 18/842(p)(2); 2x 26/5841, 5861(d) & 5871 I 13-Jul-07 18/2339A; 18/2339B; 18/373; 18/842(p)(2); 1x 26/5841, 5861(d) & 5871 360 months; 3 years.SR; $500 special 06-Nov-07 assessment Pineda, Juvenal Ovidio Ricardo Palmera (aka 93 Simon Trinidad) DDC 13-May-04 18/2339A; 4x18/1203(a) I 09-Jul-07 1x18/1203 28-Jan-08 94 Sabir, Rafiq Abdus SDNY 27-Jun-05 2x18/2339B and 2 I 21-May-07 2x18/2339B and 2 30-Nov-07 300 months; 2 years SR DMD 03-Oct-06 18/2339B; 18/371 & 22/2778; 2x 18/1956(a)(2)(A), 18/924(c) I 10-May-07 18/2339B, 22/2778 03-Jan-08 Varatharasa, 95 Thirunavukarasu Page 6 of 26 10 years 60 years 57 months

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date 96 Maldonado, Daniel Joseph SDTX 02-Apr-07 97 Osman, Haniffa Bin DMD 98 Shah, Tarik 99 Brent, Mahmud Faruq Charges Category Conv Date Conviction Charges Sent Date 18/2339D I 19-Apr-07 18/2339D 20-Jul-07 10 years, $1000 fine, & 3 years SR 19-Sep-06 18/2339B; 18/371 & 22/2778; 2x 18/1956(a)(2)(A), 18/924(c) I 05-Apr-07 18/1956, 18/2339B 31-Oct-08 37 months; 3 years SR; $200 SA SDNY 27-Jun-05 18/2339B x3 I 04-Apr-07 18/2339B 07-Nov-07 15 years SDNY 07-Nov-05 18/2339B x2 I 02-Apr-07 18/2339B 25-Jul-07 15 years SDFL 20-May-05 18/2332B, 18/924(o), 21/963, 21/846, 21/853 I 27-Mar-07 2339B 15-Jun-07 50 months, 2 years SR w/ credit for Time Served in US and Columbia I 08-Mar-07 18/2339B; 18/1956(a)(2)(A) [ & 18/1956(a)(2)(A); 22/2778 in separate plea] 14-Dec-07 37 months; 3 years SR; $200 SA Rodriguez-Acevedo, 100 Hector Sentence 101 Subandi, Haji DMD 19-Sep-06 18/2339B; 18/371 & 22/2778; 2x 18/1956(a)(2)(A), 18/924(c) [& charged 10/03/06 w/ 18/371, 18/1956(a)(2)(A), 22/2778] 102 Wotulo, Erick DMD 19-Sep-06 18/2339B; 18/371 & 22/2778; 2x 18/1956(a)(2)(A), 18/924(c) I 23-Feb-07 18/2339B, 18/1956 10-Jul-08 30 months & 3 years SR 103 Benkahla, Sabri EDVA 09-Feb-06 18/1623; 18/1503; 18/1001 (a) II 05-Feb-07 18/1623; 18/1503; 18/1001 (a) 24-Jul-07 121 months , 3 years SR, $17,500 fine NDIL 19-Aug-04 18/1962, 18/401(3) & 1503 II 01-Feb-07 18/401(3) & 1503 21-Nov-07 135 months NDIL 19-Aug-04 18/2339B (dismissed before trial); 18/1962, 18/1503 II 01-Feb-07 18/1503 11-Jul-07 21 months 27-Apr-07 12 months & 1 day for each count (to run concurrently); 2 years SR for each count (concurrent) 12 months & 1 day for each count (to run concurrently); 2 years SR for each count (concurrent) Ashqar, Abdelhaleem 104 Hasan Abdelraziq Salah, Muhammad Hamid 105 Khalil 106 Rusli, Reinhard DMD 03-Oct-06 18/371, 18/1956(a)(2)(A), 18/2778 II 31-Jan-07 18/1956(a)(2)(A), 18/2778 107 Soedirdja, Helmi DMD 03-Oct-06 18/371, 18/1956(a)(2)(A), 18/2778 II 31-Jan-07 18/1956(a)(2)(A), 18/2778 27-Apr-07 108 Qazi, Shiraz Syed SDTX 28-Nov-06 18/922(g)(5)(B) & 924(a)(2) II 30-Jan-07 18/922(g)(5)(B) & 924(a)(2) 17-May-07 10 months; 3 years SR 109 Subeh, Mohammed WDNY 22-Apr-04 3x 18/1001 [& 1x 18/1001 by Superseding Information] II 04-Jan-07 18/1001 (a)(1) 07-May-07 1 yr probation; fine of $250 and a SA of $100 110 Awan, Khalid EDNY 08-Mar-06 18/2339A, 18/1956 (a)(2)(A) I 20-Dec-06 18/2339A, 18/1956 (a)(2)(A) 12-Sep-07 14 years 111 Kamran, Irfan DCO 26-Mar-03 3x18/371, 4x8/1324, 3x18/1001 II 29-Nov-06 18/3 (by Information) 29-Nov-06 Time Served Page 7 of 26

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date 112 Qayyum, Abdul DCO 26-Mar-03 113 Williams, Kobie Diallo SDTX 114 Abdul Rah) Category Conv Date 3x18/371, 4x 8/1324, 3x 18/1001 II 29-Nov-06 18/1001 29-Nov-06 1 year probation 22-Nov-06 18/371, 18/922(g)(5)(B), 50/1705(b) I 28-Nov-06 18/371 07-Aug-09 54 months, $5000 fine; 3 years SR SDNY 08-Feb-06 18/2339A, 18/1001 [11/09/06 Superseding Information: 18/371 & 18/1001(a)(2)] I 09-Nov-06 18/371, 18/1001 16-Apr-07 115 Shorbagi, Mohamed NDGA 28-Aug-06 18/2339B I 13-Oct-06 18/2339B 27-Feb-07 92 months 116 Aref, Yassin Muhiddin NDNY 06-Aug-04 18/2339A, 18/2339B, 18/1956, 18/1546, 18/1001 I 11-Oct-06 18/1956(h); 18/2339A; 18/2339B, 18/1956(a)(3)(B); 18/1001 08-Mar-07 15 years 117 Mosharref NDNY 06-Aug-04 18/2339A, 18/2339B, 18/1956 I 11-Oct-06 18/2339A, 18/2339B, 18/1956, (all counts) 08-Mar-07 15 years 118 Grecula, Ronald SDTX 16-Jun-05 18/2332B I 21-Sep-06 18/2339B 13-Feb-07 5 years, 3 years SR 119 Berro, Lina (aka Lina Reda) EDMI 20-Apr-05 18/1001, 18/982 II 14-Aug-06 18/1001 20-Dec-06 1 year probation 120 Berro, Noura EDMI 26-Apr-04 18/371, 18/157, 18/1344, 18/1956, 18/982 II 14-Aug-06 18/371 (conspiracy to commit bank and mail fraud) 30-Jan-07 8 months; 2 years SR; $124,549 restitution w/husband Sami Berro (also charged) 121 Berro, Sami Ahmad EDMI 26-Apr-04 18/371, 18/1344, 18/1001, 18/982 II 14-Aug-06 18/371 (conspiracy to commit bank and mail fraud) 30-Jan-07 27 months; 2 years SR; $124,549 restitution w/wife Noura Berro (also charged) 122 Berro, Sadek EDMI 26-Apr-04 18/371,18/157, 18/1344, 18/1956, 18/1962, 18/982 II 11-Aug-06 18/1962 (d) 31-Jan-07 78 months; 3 years SR; restitution $1,224,003 123 Berro, Zeinab EDMI 26-Apr-04 18/371, 18/157, 18/1344, 18/1956, 18/982 II 11-Aug-06 18/371 31-Jan-07 15 months, 3 years SR, restitution $554,878 124 Berro, Almire Ali-Sadek EDMI 20-Apr-05 18/1344 II 09-Aug-06 18/1344 24-Jan-07 1 day with Time Served; 3 years SR 125 Berro, Houda Mohamad EDMI 20-Apr-05 18/1344, 18/1956, 18/982, 18/371 II 09-Aug-06 18/1344 12-Dec-06 12 months' and 1 day 126 Berro, Abdul Halim EDMI 26-Apr-04 18/371, 18/157, 18/1344, 18/1956, 18/982 II 09-Aug-06 18/371 12-Dec-06 35 months, $421,120 restitution 127 Berro, Abdulamir EDMI 26-Apr-04 18/371, 18/1344, 18/1956-1957, 18/1001, 18/1349, 18/1962, 18/982 II 03-Aug-06 18/1962 05-Dec-06 70 months. $669,125 restitution Farhane, Abdulrahman (or Charges Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence 13 years (156 months); 2 years SR Hossain, Mohammed Page 8 of 26

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date 128 El-Sablani, Bilal EDMI 26-Apr-04 129 Berro, Abdul Karim Akram EDMI 130 Farhat, Amira Ali Category Conv Date 18/371, 18/157, 18/1344, 18/1956, 18/982 II 03-Aug-06 18/371 02-Jul-08 20-Apr-05 18/1001, 18/982 II 31-Jul-06 18/1001 30-Nov-06 10 months, 2 years SR EDMI 20-Apr-05 18/1344, 18/1001, 18/1349, 18/982, 18/371 II 31-Jul-06 18/1344 18-Jan-07 131 Farhat, Ali Abdul Karim EDMI 26-Apr-04 18/371, 18/1344, 18/1956-1957, 18/1001, 18/1341, 18/1349, 18/1962, 18/982 II 31-Jul-06 18/1962 74 months., $669,125 restitution, forfeiture of 21-Feb-07 business & residential property 132 Murshed, Ahmed WDNY 06-Dec-01 8/1324 II 27-Jul-06 8/1324 Time Served, 2 years SR; and deportation 13-Nov-06 proceedings pursuant to Title 18/ 3583(d). 133 Berro, Akram Abdul Karim EDMI 26-Apr-04 18/371, 18/157, 18/1344, 18/1956, 18/1349, 18/982 II 25-Jul-06 18/1344, 18/157, 18/371, 18/1956, 18/1349 18-Jan-07 44 months each of the 9 counts (concurrent) & restitution 134 Berro, Jamal Saadallah EDMI 26-Apr-04 18/371, 18/157, 18/1344, 18/1956, 18/1349, 18/982 II 25-Jul-06 18/371, 18/157, 18/1344, 18/1956, 18/1349 18-Jan-07 46 months each of the 9 counts (concurrent) & restitution 135 Peters, Troy M. EDNY 22-May-02 18/1962; 15/78j(b) & 78ff; 18/1951; 18/1503; 18/371 II 25-Jul-06 18/1951 [on CR-00521] & 15/78j(b) & 78ff [on CR00620] Time Served; special assessment $200; 10-Dec-07 $706,300 restitution 136 Albanna, Mohamed WDNY 17-Dec-02 18/1960, 18/982, 31/5313, 26/7206 II 23-Jun-06 18/1960 30-Nov-06 5 years 137 Fariz, Hatim Naji (Hatem) MDFL 19-Feb-03 18/2339B, 18/1962, 18/956, 18/1952, 18/371, 50/17011705 I 21-Jun-06 50/1701-1705 25-Jul-06 138 Jaber, Arwah WDAR 11-Aug-05 18/2339B(a)(1), 42/408(a)(7)(B), 18/1015(a), 18/1542 and 18/1425 I 19-Jun-06 42/408(a)(7)(B), 18/1015(a), 18/1542 and 18/1425 16-Nov-06 15 months, 3 years SR, $2,000 fine. 139 Chandia, Ali Asad EDVA 15-Sep-05 18/2339A x2, 18/2339B x2 I 06-Jun-06 18/2339A, 18/2339B x2 25-Apr-08 140 Hayat, Umer EDCA 31-May-06 18/1001 (information) II 31-May-06 18/1001 25-Aug-06 Time Served and a $3600 fine 141 Siraj, Shahawar Matin EDNY 09-Feb-05 18/844(i), 18/1993(a)(1), 18/1993(a)(3); 18/2332f(a)(1)(B) I 24-May-06 18/844(i), 18/1993(a)(1), 18/1993(a)(3); 18/2332f(a)(1)(B) 08-Jan-07 142 Nasser, Saleh Alli EDMI 18-Jul-05 18/371, 21/841A, 18/1960, 31/5324, 18/1546 II 11-May-06 18/1546 16-Nov-06 3 years probation; deportation 18/371, 31/5324 30 months in custody, 2 years SR, a $200 SA, & forfeiture approx. $200K cash & 11-Aug-06 $9,693,669 in substitute assets 143 Omian, Monasser EDMI 12-Apr-05 Charges 18/371, 18/1960, 18/1001, 31/5324, 18/1546, 18/1425 II 11-May-06 Page 9 of 26 Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence 1 day; 3 years SR; $ 489,174.25 restitution 12 months, 1 day, $4000 fine, forfeiture $72,611 37 months; 2-3 years SR 180 months. 30 years

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date Charges Category Conv Date Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence 144 Omian, Sadik EDMI 06-Apr-05 18/371, 18/1960, 18/1001, 31/5324, 18/1546 II 11-May-06 18/371, 31/5324, 18/1001 145 Wasil, Jarallah EDMI 06-Apr-05 18/371, 18/1960, 18/1425, 21/841(a)(1), 31/5324, 31/5332 II 11-May-06 18/371, 18/1425, 31/5324, 21/841(a)(1) 12 months & 1 day in custody, 2 years SR, $300 SA, forfeit $200,000cash & $5,391,000 11-Dec-06 sub assets 57 months in custody, 3 years SR, $400 SA, and forfeiture of approx $200K cash & $9,693,669 in substitute assets; possibility of 11-Aug-06 deportation 146 Hayat, Hamid EDCA 07-Jun-05 18/2339A, 3x 18/1001 I 25-Apr-06 18/2339A, 3x 18/1001 10-Sep-07 288 months, 120 months SR 147 Wu, Chao Tung CDCA 17-Aug-05 18/2332g; 2x 21/846; 7x 21/841; 2x 18/2342; 18/2320 [& 18/371 on 05-cr-00805] I 19-Apr-06 18/2332g; 2x 21/846; 18/2342; 18/2320 [& 18/371] 148 Al-Arian, Sami Amin MDFL 19-Feb-03 18/2339B, 1962, 956, 371, 1952, 1425, 1505, 1956 I 17-Apr-06 18/371 01-May-06 57 months; 3 years. SR 149 Shah, Syed Mustajab SDCA 30-Oct-02 21/846, 841; 21/952, 960, 963; 18/2339B II 30-Mar-06 21/841, 18/2339B 25-Sep-06 225 months, 5 years SR, $200 SA 150 Awada, Monir CDCA 14-Jan-03 2x 31/5332, 5322(a) II 03-Feb-06 1x 31/5332, 5322(a) 03-Feb-06 1 year probation 151 Rahal, Nemr Ali EDMI 19-May-05 18/371; 18/1344; 18/1029 II 17-Jan-06 18/1344 27-Apr-06 33 months., 3 years SR, $416,783 restitution; $5K forfeiture; $100 SA 152 Maatouk, Fadl Mohammed MDFL 10-Nov-04 18/1956; 18/1014; 18/371; 18/1001; 21/863 II 13-Jan-06 18/371 60 months, 5 years SR, $100SA, & $58K forfeiture; if deported can't return w/o 25-May-06 permission 153 Rania M. Fawaz Rahal EDMI 19-May-05 18/371; 18/1344 II 03-Jan-06 18/371 27-Apr-06 FNU LNU ("Abdulhakeem Nour," "Noureddine Malki," 154 "Almaliki Nour") EDNY 09-Nov-05 2x 18/1001 (a)(2); 18/1425 (a) & 3551 et seq. II 20-Dec-05 2x 18/1001 (a)(2); 18/1425 (a) & 3551 et seq. 121 months; 3 years SR; subject to 19-May-08 deportation [total for 2 dockets] 155 Paracha, Uzair SDNY 08-Aug-03 2x18/2339B, 2x 50/1705(b), 18/1028 A I 23-Nov-05 2x18/2339B, 2x 50/1705(b), 18/1028 A 20-Jul-06 360 months; 5 years SR; $500 SA 156 Abu Ali, Ahmed Omar EDVA 03-Feb-05 18/2339B, 2339A, 50/1705(b), 18/1751(d), 18/32, 49/46502 I 22-Nov-05 18/2339B, 2339A, 50/1705(b), 18/1751(d), 18/32, 49/46502 27-Jul-09 Life 157 Mohamed, Omar Abdi SDCA 19-Dec-03 18/1546(a), 18/1015(a) II 28-Oct-05 18/1546, 18/1015 20-Dec-05 18 months, 3 years. SR 158 Gujar, Tariq NDNY 05-Oct-05 26/7202 (Information) II 07-Oct-05 26/7202 27-Jan-06 159 Makki, Ali EDMI 26-Jun-03 18/2320, 18/371, 18/1956 II 05-Oct-05 18/371, 18/1956 [& 18/1623 from Information filed in NDTX] 2 years probation on each count 02-Feb-06 (concurrent); $10,190 restitution Page 10 of 26 1 yr probation, $100 SA 3 years probation, $5000

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date 160 Makki, Tarek EDMI 25-Jun-03 161 Elfgeeh, Abad EDNY 162 Elfgeeh, Aref 163 Maatouk, Ali Charges Category Conv Date Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence 18/2320, 18/1001, 18/371, 18/1956 II 05-Oct-05 18/2320, 18/1001, 18/371, 18/1956 14-Mar-06 24 months, $879, 056 restitution 04-Feb-03 18/1960, 18/371, 31/5324 II 21-Sep-05 18/1960, 18/371, 31/5324 03-Feb-06 188 months & 5 years SR EDNY 03-Feb-03 18/1960, 18/371 II 21-Sep-05 18/1960, 18/371 07-Feb-06 51 months MDFL 10-Feb-05 18/371; 8/1325 II 14-Sep-05 8/1325 07-Oct-05 24 months probation 164 Khalil, Naji Antoine Abi SDNY 16-Jun-04 18/2339B, 50/1705, 18/371 I 09-Aug-05 18/2339B, 50/1705, 18/371 57 months on Arkansas charges; 57, 60 & 60 months on SDNY charges (all will run 02-Feb-06 concurrently); 3 years SR; $100,000 rest. 165 Grinberg, Tomer SDNY 16-Jun-04 18/371 II 28-Jul-05 18/371 12-Apr-06 6 months; 2 years SR 166 Wingate, Lynn EDNY 22-May-02 18/1962; 18/1503; 18/371 II 23-Jun-05 18/1503 21-Jul-06 3 years probation, $2500 fine 167 Al-Uqaily, Ahmed Hassan MDTN 07-Oct-04 18/922(o); 18/924(a), 26/584126/5861(d), 26/5871 & 18/2 II 31-May-05 18/922(o), 26/5861(d) 24-Oct-05 57 months, 3 years SR 168 Villalobos, Herbert EDVA 23-May-05 18/1028 and 2 II 23-May-05 18/1028 and 2 29-Jul-05 4 months, 2 years SR 169 Wagner, Michael SDIA 27-Jul-04 18/922, 18/931, 18/1001 II 29-Apr-05 18/1001 02-May-05 Time Served WDTX 09-Dec-04 2x 50/1705 I 28-Apr-05 50/1705 28-Apr-05 171 Lakhani, Hemant DNJ 18-Dec-03 18/2339A, 22/2778, 18/1956, 18/542 I 27-Apr-05 18/2339A, 22/2778, 18/1956, 18/542 12-Sep-05 47 years 172 Berro, Hussein A. EDMI 26-Apr-04 18/371, 18/157, 18/1344 II 27-Apr-05 18/157 24-Oct-06 14.5 months 173 Al-Timimi, Ali EDVA 23-Sep-04 50/1705, 18/371, 18/924(c)&A, 18/844(h), 18/2384, 18/373 I 26-Apr-05 50/1705, 18/371, 18/924(c)&A, 18/844(h), 18/2384, 18/373 13-Jul-05 Life DAZ 13-Mar-03 18/371, 18/2314, 18/2315, 18/1956 & 1957, 18/1001, 31/5322(a), 8/1324 II 26-Apr-05 8/1324, 18/2314, 18/2315, 18/1956, 18/1001, 31/5322, 18/371 07-Oct-05 120 months, 3years SR 170 Walker, Mark Robert 174 Jamal, Samih Fadl Page 11 of 26 24 months; 3 years SR; $100 SA

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date Charges Category Conv Date EDVA 11-Dec-01 18/2332A, 18/2332B, 18/844, 18/1114, 49/46502, 18/32 I 22-Apr-05 18/2332A, 18/2332B, 18/844, 18/1114, 49/46502, 18/32 04-May-06 Life 176 Cecilia SDTX 21-May-03 18/2339B I 14-Apr-05 18/2339B 01-Dec-05 61 months 177 Berjaoui, Issam EDMI 29-Jan-03 18/371, 18/1956 II 11-Apr-05 18/1956 12-Sep-06 17 months 178 Abodayah, Akrem DNJ 03-Dec-03 21/844 II 01-Apr-05 21/844 15-Jun-05 Time Served (6 months) 179 Youssef EDMI 19-Nov-03 18/2339B, 18/371 I 01-Mar-05 18/371 14-Jun-05 54 months, 3years SR, SA 180 Carpenter, Cedric SDMS 31-Aug-04 18/2339B; 18/371, 21/846, 21/853, 18/922 I 28-Feb-05 18/2339B, 18/922 68 months for 18/2339A ; 3 yr SR; each w/ 20-May-05 $2000 fine & $100 SA 181 Ranson, Lamont SDMS 31-Aug-04 18/2339B, 18/371, 21/846, 21/853 I 28-Feb-05 18/2339B 20-May-05 29 months; 3 years SR; $2000 fine; $100 SA 182 Gamarra-Murillo, Carlos MDFL 18-Aug-04 21/841, 18/924, 22/2778, 2339B I 11-Feb-05 22/2778, 18/2339B 08-Aug-05 120 months, 3 years SR 183 Salman Farooq WDLA 13-Oct-04 4x18/1001 II 11-Feb-05 18/1001 48 months. w/ credit Time Served, 3 years 25-Aug-05 SR (to be suspended if return to Pakistan) 184 Dhafir, Rafil NDNY 19-Feb-03 50 / 1701 et seq; 18/1956, 18/371, 26/7201C, 26/7201, 18/1001, 18/1546, 18/1347, 18/1343, 18/1341 I 10-Feb-05 2x 18/371; 13x 18/1956; 26/7206; 6x 26/7201; 18/1546; 26x 18/1347; 18/1001; 4x 18/1343 27-Oct-05 264 months; 3 years SR 185 Sattar, Ahmed Abdel SDNY 09-Apr-02 2x18/2339B, 373, 371, 1001, 956 I 10-Feb-05 2x18/2339B, 373, 371, 1001, 956 186 Stewart, Lynne SDNY 09-Apr-02 2x18/2339B, 2x18/2339A, 373, 371, 1001 I 10-Feb-05 2x 18/2339B, 2x18/2339A, 373, 371, 1001 187 Yousry, Mohammed SDNY 09-Apr-02 2x18/2339B, 2x18/2339A, 373, 371, 1001 I 10-Feb-05 2x 18/2339B, 2x18/2339A, 373, 371, 1001 188 Elgindy, Amr I. EDNY 22-May-02 3x 18/1951(a); 18/1962(d); 14x 15/78(j)(b) & 78ff; 11x 18/1343; 2x 18/371; 18/1503 [& 2x 18/1001; 18/3147] II 24-Jan-05 18/1962(d); 2x 18/1951(a); 5x 15/78(j)(b) & 78ff; 2x 18/1343; 18/371 [& 2x 18/1001; 18/3147 on 8/01/05] 19-Jun-06 135 months; 3 years SR; SA $1400; forfeiture of $1,568,000 189 Royer, Jeffrey EDNY 22-May-02 18/1962; 7x 15/78j(b) & 78ff; 3x 18/1951; 18/1503; 18/1512(2)(B); 2x 18/371 II 24-Jan-05 18/1962; 2x 18/371, 18/1503, 18/1512, 4x 15/78(j)(b) & 78ff; 02-Oct-06 72 months ; 3 years SR; Special assessment of $900 190 Al Mosaleh, Ali Mohammed DMN 28-Jul-04 3x18/1001 II 29-Dec-04 18/1001 29-Dec-04 Time Served, 3 years SR 175 Moussaoui, Zacarias Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence Barrera-De Amaris, Fanny Kourani, Mahmoud Qureshi, Mohammad Page 12 of 26

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date 191 Mohamed, Zameer CDCA 21-May-04 192 Steitiye, Ali Khaled DOR 193 El Hage, Saleh Eldin Ali Charges Category Conv Date Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence 18/844(e) II 21-Dec-04 18/844(e) 31-Mar-05 60 months., 3 years SR 16-Mar-04 18/922 II 19-Nov-04 18/922 01-Jun-05 SDTX 17-Sep-04 8/1326 II 17-Nov-04 8/1326 18-Feb-05 6 months, 1 yr. SR, $100 194 Ayesh, Hasan Ali EDAR 05-Mar-04 31/5324, 18/1343, 18/1425 II 16-Nov-04 31/5324, 18/1343, 18/1425 13-May-05 5 years probation, $400 SA 195 Benmoumen, Elmeliani WDPA 10-Nov-04 18/371 II 10-Nov-04 18/371 29-Dec-04 Time Served, SR 12 months Puerta, Edgar Fernando Blanco (Commandante 196 Emilio) SDTX 04-Dec-02 18/2339B, 21/841, 21/846 I 25-Oct-04 18/2339B, 21/841, 21/846 31-May-06 Life 197 Kamran Akhtar) WDNC 05-Aug-04 4x 18/1001, 8/1253, 18/1028 II 12-Oct-04 3x 18/1001, 8/1253, 18/1028 24-Jan-05 Time Served; 3 years SR 198 Biheiri, Soliman EDVA 06-May-04 18/1001 x2; 18/1546 II 12-Oct-04 18/1546 (pleaded), 18/1001 (convicted) 14-Jan-05 13 months., 1 day w/ credit for Time Served 199 Ahmed, Farida SDTX 16-Aug-04 8/1325; 18/1001, 18/1543 II 27-Sep-04 8/1325; 18/1001, 18/1543 13-Dec-04 Time Served; 3 years SR 200 Raja, Manthena DNJ 10-Sep-04 18/1956 II 10-Sep-04 18/1956 20-Oct-05 201 Khan, Imran DCO 26-Mar-03 2x18/371, 18/1028 II 31-Aug-04 18/1028 31-Aug-04 Time Served 202 Elshafay, James EDNY 27-Aug-04 18/844 II 27-Aug-04 203 Tumer, Yildirim Beyozit EDPA 23-Jul-04 18/844(e) Complaint; Charged with 18/1001 by Information 8/9/04 II 25-Aug-04 18/1001 Time Served; Immediate Deportation to 25-Aug-04 Turkey 204 Nasrallah, Hussein EDMI 29-Jan-03 18/1344, 18/513(a) II 17-Aug-04 18/1344 05-Apr-05 1 day ; 3 years SR; $35K restitution; $100 SA 205 Muhammad EDVA 28-Sep-03 50 /1701 et seq.; 18/1001, 18/2332d, 18/1956, 31/5324. 18/1544, 18/1425, 31/5322, 26/7206(1), 26/7212(a) I 30-Jul-04 50/1705, 18/1425, 26/7212 14-Oct-04 23 years 206 Elashi, Basman NDTX 20-Feb-02 50 / 1701 et seq., 18/1001, 18/371, 18/1956, 18/1957 I 07-Jul-04 50/1701, 18/1001, 18/371, 18/1957 13-Oct-06 80 months incarceration (for INFOCOM I and INFOCOM II trials) 60 months Shaikh, Kamran (aka al-Amoudi, Abdurahman Page 13 of 26 24 months., 3 years SR 02-Mar-07 5 years, 3 years SR

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date 207 Elashi, Bayan NDTX 20-Feb-02 208 Elashi, Ghassan NDTX 209 Elashi, Hazim Charges Category Conv Date Conviction Charges 50/ 1701 et seq., 18/1001, 18/371, 18/1956, 18/1957 I 07-Jul-04 50/1701, 18/1001, 18/371, 18/1957 11-Oct-06 7 years (84 months) incarceration, 3 years SR (for INFOCOM I and INFOCOM II trials) 20-Feb-02 50 / 1701 et seq., 18/1001, 18/371, 18/1956, 18/1957 I 07-Jul-04 50/1701 (Syria only), 18/1001, 18/371, 18/1957 12-Oct-06 80 months incarceration, 3 years SR (for INFOCOM I and INFOCOM II trials) NDTX 20-Feb-02 50/ 1701 et seq., 18/1001, 18/371, 18/1956, 18/1957 I 07-Jul-04 50/1701, 18/1001, 18/371, 18/1957 24-Jan-06 66 months; reduced to 60 months on 2/1/06 NDOH 16-Dec-03 18/1425 II 17-Jun-04 18/1425 2 months + 4 months house arrest, 20-Sep-04 denaturalization DAZ 15-Sep-03 18/1425(a) II 16-Jun-04 18/1425(a) Time Served, 36 months SR + 22-Sep-04 denaturalization & deport 212 Adolfo SDTX 21-May-03 18/2339B I 09-Jun-04 18/2339B 01-Dec-05 36 months 213 Babar, Mohammed Junaid SDNY 03-Jun-04 2x18/2339A, 2x2339B, 50/1705 I 03-Jun-04 2x18/2339A, 2x2339B, 50/1705 214 Hassan, Abdulghefur Abdul EDNY 13-Feb-03 31/5324, 18/371 II 01-Jun-04 31/5324 06-Jan-05 36 months., 3 years SR Time Served; 2 years SR Damrah, Fawaz 210 Mohammed 211 Alferahin, Osama Musa Sent Date Sentence Romero-Panchano, Carlos Hameed, Moinuddeen 215 Ahmed DNJ 13-Aug-03 18/371 (to violate 18/1960) [by Information 04/20/2004] II 19-Apr-04 18/371 (to violate 18/1960) 06-Jun-05 216 Abraham, Yehuda DNJ 19-Aug-03 18/1960 II 30-Mar-04 18/1960 14-Nov-05 2 years probation; $10,000 fine 217 Daher, Mohamad EDMI 23-Jan-03 18/1962(d), 18/1029 & 18/2 II 09-Mar-04 18/1962(d) 18-Aug-04 3 years probation; $60K restitution; $100 SA 218 Fawaz, Issam Hassan EDMI 23-Jan-03 18/1962(d), 18/1029 II 09-Mar-04 18/1962(d) 14-Jul-04 15 months; 2 years SR; $100 SA; $5000 Fine 219 Abdur-Raheem, Hammad EDVA 25-Jun-03 18/2339A, 18/ 371, 18/960, 18/924(b)&(c)&(g)&(h) I 04-Mar-04 18/371, 18/2339A, 18/924(o) 29-Jul-05 52 months. on each count (reversed 9/1/06 and re-sentenced on 8/16/07 to 52 months. total) 220 Chapman, Seifullah EDVA 25-Jun-03 18/2339A, 18/371, 18/960, 18/924(c)&(h)&(o), 18/1001 I 04-Mar-04 18/371, 18/2339A, 18/924(o) 29-Jul-05 780 months. 221 Khan, Masoud Ahmad EDVA 25-Jun-03 50/1705, 18/2339A, 18/2339B, 18/371, 18/2384, 18/960, 18/924(c)&(o) I 04-Mar-04 18/371, 18/2384, 50/1705, 18/2339A, 18/924(c)&(o) 29-Jul-05 Life 222 Afridi, Muhammed Abid SDCA 30-Oct-02 21/846, 841; 21/952, 960, 963; 18/2339B I 03-Mar-04 21/846, 841; 18/2339B 03-Apr-06 57 months custody and 5 years SR Page 14 of 26

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date 223 Ali, Ilyas SDCA 30-Oct-02 224 Ahmed, Aref WDNY 225 Daher, Ali Charges Category Conv Date 21/846, 841; 21/952, 960, 963; 18/2339B I 03-Mar-04 21/846, 841; 18/2339B 10-Apr-06 57 months custody and 5 years SR 22-Sep-99 18/1956, 21/853, 5x18/2342 II 03-Mar-04 18/1956 26-Jul-05 37months, 3years. SR, restitution EDMI 23-Jan-03 18/1962(d), 18/2342 II 01-Mar-04 18/1962; 18/2342 07-Jun-04 5 months for each count; 2 years SR ; $200 SA; $175,500 restitution 226 Maflahi, Numan EDNY 09-Apr-03 18/1001 II 18-Feb-04 18/1001 09-Jul-04 60 months; 3years SR 227 Talyi, Yaudat Mustafa EDLA 09-Jan-04 2x 50/1702 & 1705(b) I 29-Jan-04 2x 50/1702 28-Apr-04 5 months; 1 yr SR, $25K fine 228 Mora, Adriana Gladys SDTX 04-Sep-03 18/2339B; 21/841 I 26-Jan-04 18/2339B; 21/841 30-Apr-07 120 months; 5 years SR; $200 SA 229 Malike, Sayed Abdul EDNY 03-Jun-03 18/1001, 21/844(a) II 23-Jan-04 18/1001 26-May-04 37 months., 3 years SR 230 Al-Hamdi, Ibrahim Ahmed EDVA 25-Jun-03 18/2339A, 18/371, 18/960, 18/924(c)&(g)&(o), 18/844 I 16-Jan-04 18/924(c), 18/844 09-Apr-04 120 months, 3 years SR 231 Royer, Randall Todd EDVA 25-Jun-03 50/1705, 18/2339A, 2339B, 18/371, 18/2384, 18/960, 18/924(c)&(g), 18/844 I 16-Jan-04 18/924(c), 18/844 09-Apr-04 20 years 232 Sallam, Tarek Abdelhamid CDCA 07-Apr-03 15x 18/1343, 2x 42/408, 31/5324 II 08-Jan-04 18/1343 17-May-04 18 months, 3years SR, restitution 233 Foley, Lori CDCA 30-Jul-03 15x 18/1343 II 22-Dec-03 18/1343 15-Mar-04 15 months., 3 years SR, restitution 234 Sarsour, Jamil Salem EDWI 22-Jan-03 31/5324 II 10-Nov-03 31/5324 09-Jan-04 Ruiz, Elkin Alberto Arroyave (Commandante 235 Napo) SDTX 04-Dec-02 18/2339B, 21/841, 21/846 I 05-Nov-03 18/2339B 236 Haydous, Fadi EDMI 24-Apr-03 18/2314, 18/922(g)(1) II 28-Oct-03 18/2314 31-May-06 180 months 27 months to run concurrently w/ 99-CR00131-14 in Western District NY, Plus 1 day consecutive; credited with time in WDNY; 2 31-Mar-05 years SR (concurrent w/ WDNY) 237 Battle, Jeffrey Leon DOR 03-Oct-02 18/2339B, 2384, 924, 50/1705 I 16-Oct-03 18/2384 24-Nov-03 18 years 238 Ford, Patrice Lamumba DOR 03-Oct-02 18/2339B, 2384, 1956, 924, 50/1705 I 16-Oct-03 18/2384 24-Nov-03 18 years Page 15 of 26 Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence 2 years probation w/conditions; $2500 fine; 25K restitution

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date 239 Biheiri, Soliman S. EDVA 07-Aug-03 240 Mahmoud, Amna EDNY 241 Lewis, October Martinique Charges Category Conv Date 18/1425, 18/1001, 18/1015 II 09-Oct-03 18/1425, 18/1015 [18/1001 on 10/12/04], pleaded: 1546 12-Jan-04 01-Oct-03 18 / 1029 x2 II 01-Oct-03 18 /1029 x2 16-Dec-03 3 years probation $67,306.00 DOR 03-Oct-02 18/2339B, 2384, 1956, 50/1705 I 26-Sep-03 18/1956 01-Dec-03 36 months 242 Aatique, Mohammed EDVA 25-Jun-03 18/960, 1001, 924, 371, 1543, 112 I 22-Sep-03 924(c), 960 17-Dec-03 126 months 243 Abdallah, Hassan EDTX 20-Mar-03 18/659, 18/2342, 18/371 II 19-Sep-03 18/2342 08-Apr-04 244 Makki, Hassan Moussa EDMI 23-Jan-03 18/1962(d), 18/2342 & 18/2, 18/2315 & 18/2, 2339B(a)(1) I 18-Sep-03 18/2339B; 18/1962 16-Dec-03 57 months; 3 years SR; $657K restitution 245 Bilal, Ahmed Ibrahim DOR 03-Oct-02 18/2339B, 2384, 924, 50/1705 I 18-Sep-03 50/1705; 924(c) 09-Feb-04 10 years 246 Bilal, Muhammad Ibrahim DOR 03-Oct-02 18/2339B, 2384, 50/1705 I 18-Sep-03 50/1705; 924(c) 09-Feb-04 8 years 247 Akhdar, Ali Mohamad EDMI 03-Feb-03 18/1962(d) II 16-Sep-03 18/1962 11-Dec-03 12 months, 1 day 248 Tchibassa, Artur DDC 25-Sep-91 18/1203, 18/371 I 12-Sep-03 18/1203, 18/371 27-Feb-04 293 months; 5 years SR; SA & restitution 249 Khafagi, Bassam Kamel EDMI 24-Jan-03 18/1344; 18/1546 II 09-Sep-03 18/1344; 18/1546 13-Nov-03 Time Served (10 Months), 1 yr SR 250 Kwon, Yong Ki EDVA 25-Jun-03 18/960, 18/924(c)&(g)&(h), 18/371 I 25-Aug-03 18/371, 924(c) & (h) 07-Nov-03 138 months 251 Surratt, Donald Thomas EDVA 25-Jun-03 18/960, 18/924(b)&(c)&(o), 18/371 II 22-Aug-03 18/371, 924(b) 07-Nov-03 46 months 252 Hasan, Khwaja Mahmood EDVA 25-Jun-03 18/1001, 18/924, 18/371 II 21-Aug-03 18/371, 924 07-Nov-03 135 months 253 Jubara, Hosam Yousef MDFL 19-Mar-03 18/1546 II 14-Aug-03 18/1546 06-Nov-03 5 months, 2years SR, $500 fine, $400 SA 254 Hawash, Maher Mofeid DOR 02-May-03 18/2339B, 2384, 924, 50/1705 I 06-Aug-03 50/1705 09-Feb-04 7 years Page 16 of 26 Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence 12 months [& 13months on 1/13/05] 5 years probation

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date 255 Akhdar, Elias EDMI 03-Feb-03 256 Hansen, Robert EDNY 257 Hatfield, G. William Category Conv Date 18/1952, 18/1962, 18/1952, 18/1512 II 29-Jul-03 18/1962 08-Jan-04 15-Jul-03 18/371 [by Information] II 15-Jul-03 18/371 3 years probation; Fine in the amount of 02-Nov-06 $2,500 NDNY 03-Jul-03 26/7206 II 03-Jul-03 26/7206 01-Jun-05 2 years probation, $15K fine 258 Dhafir, Priscilla NDNY 01-Jul-03 18/1001 II 01-Jul-03 18/1001 06-Jun-05 2 years probation, $10K fine & restitution 259 Jensen, Uwe SDTX 04-Dec-02 18/2339B, 21/841(a)(1), (b)(1)(A), 21/846 I 24-Jun-03 18/2339B; 21/841; 21/846 31-May-06 168 months 260 Rodriguez, Marlon EDTX 20-Mar-03 18/659, 18/2342, 18/371 II 19-Jun-03 18/371 29-Apr-04 12 months DNJ 25-Oct-01 18/371, 18/659 II 17-Jun-03 18/371 29-Jan-04 Time Served (5 months), 3 years. SR 262 Addelhafiz (Sammy) CDCA 25-Mar-03 42/408(a)(7)(B) II 23-May-03 42/408 02-Jul-03 112 days, 3yr SR 263 Al-Bakri, Mukhtar WDNY 21-Oct-02 2x18/2339A I 19-May-03 18/2339A 03-Dec-03 10 years, 3 years SR, $2000fine, $100 SA 264 Ali, Ahmed NDNY 16-May-03 26/7206 II 16-May-03 26/7206 20-May-05 2 years probation, $15K fine 265 Taher, Yasein WDNY 21-Oct-02 2x18/2339B I 12-May-03 18/2339B 04-Dec-03 96 months, 3SR, $100SA 266 Faris, Iyman EDVA 30-Apr-03 2x18/2339B, I 01-May-03 18/371, 2x 2339B 28-Oct-03 20 years (60 months w/credit for Time Served, 3 years SR, $100 SA 267 Jarwan, Ayman NDNY 19-Feb-03 4x 18/371 II 25-Apr-03 2x 18/371 (to violate IEEPA) 19-Oct-05 18 months. 268 Varela, Carlos Ali Romero SDTX 04-Dec-02 18/2339B, 21/841, 21/846 I 23-Apr-03 18/2339B, 21/846 15-Jun-09 120 months , 5 years SR, $200 special assessment 269 Al-Wahaidy, Osameh NDNY 19-Feb-03 50 / 1701 et seq. I 22-Apr-03 50/1701 et. seq. 24-Aug-05 2 years probation, $5K fine 261 Abuali, Hussein Charges Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence 70 months, 3 years SR, $100 SA, $2,062,500 restitution Samhan, Husam Page 17 of 26

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date 270 Shishani, Omar EDMI 21-Jul-02 271 Awde, Salim Nemir EDMI 05-Feb-03 Charges Category Conv Date Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence 18/513, 18/545, 18/371 II 21-Apr-03 18/545, 18/371 18-Nov-03 57 months, 2 years SR, $200SA 18/1962(d) II 18-Apr-03 18/1962 08-Apr-04 Time Served (14 months), 3 years SR, $100 272 Ismail, Nabil Mohamad EDMI 23-Jan-03 18/1962(d) on 01/23/03 II 18-Apr-03 18/1962 08-Apr-04 Time Served (12 months concurrent w/ sent. for 18/1029); 3 years SR; $100 SA; $37500 restitution 273 Bowman, Brandy EDMI 03-Feb-03 18/1962(d) II 16-Apr-03 18/1962 08-Apr-04 4 months, 3 years SR in WDNY, $45,750 restitution, $100 SA 274 Gordon, Carol EDMI 23-Jan-03 18/1962(d) II 16-Apr-03 18/1962 (conspiracy RICO) 08-Apr-04 7 months; 3 years SR; $202,500 restitution; $100 SA 275 Ujaama, Earnest James WDWA 28-Aug-02 18/2339B,18/2339A, 18/956(a)(1) and (b); 18/924 I 14-Apr-03 50/1705 13-Feb-04 24 months 276 Alwan, Sahim WDNY 21-Oct-02 2x18/2339A I 08-Apr-03 18/2339A 17-Dec-03 114 months, 3years SR, $100 SA 277 Hmimssa, Youssef EDMI 27-Sep-01 18/1546, 18/1028(a)(6), 18/1029, 18/371, 18/1543, 18/2339A I 07-Apr-03 18/1546, 18/1028, 1029, 1543 01-Sep-05 78 months, 3 years SR 278 Florez-Gomez, Libardo SDFL 12-Nov-02 18/1960, 18/982 II 04-Apr-03 18/982 25-Jul-03 18 months, 2 years SR, forfeiture 279 Hariri, Mohamad Ahmad EDMI 23-Jan-03 18/1962(d) II 01-Apr-03 18/1962 17-Jun-04 Time Served (6 months); 3 years SR; $100 SA; $2062,500 restitution 280 Goba, Yahya WDNY 21-Oct-02 2x18/2339B I 25-Mar-03 18/2339B 10-Dec-03 10 years, 3 years SR, $1500fine, $100SA 281 Mosed, Shafal WDNY 21-Oct-02 2x18/2339B I 24-Mar-03 18/2339B 09-Dec-03 96 months, 3years. SR, $100SA 282 Salim SDCA 15-Nov-02 8/1324 II 19-Mar-03 8/1324 19-Jun-03 283 Awan, Khalid EDNY 04-Dec-01 18/1029A&B, 18/1956 II 17-Mar-03 18/1029B 08-Nov-04 60 months 3 years. SR 284 Hussain, Choudhry EDNY 04-Dec-01 18/1029A&B, 18/1956 II 17-Mar-03 18/1029B 13-May-03 21 Months, 3 years SR Boughader-Mucharrafille, Page 18 of 26 12 months + 1 day, 3years SR

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date 285 Sarwer, Suhail EDNY 04-Dec-01 286 Serrano-Valdez, Patricia SDCA 287 Guillermo 288 Arnaout, Enaam M. Charges Category Conv Date Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence 18 / 1029x2 and 3551 II 17-Mar-03 18/ 1029 x2 and 3551 28-Oct-04 55 months 3 years SR 15-Nov-02 8/1324 II 13-Mar-03 8/1324 17-Jun-03 10 months, 2years SR SDCA 15-Nov-02 8/1324 II 18-Feb-03 8/1324 03-Mar-03 Time Served, 1 years SR NDIL 09-Oct-02 18/2339A, 18/1962, 18/371, 18/1956, 18/1341, 18/1343 I 10-Feb-03 18/1962 17-Feb-06 120 months 289 Suleiman SDNY 22-Mar-01 18/2332(b), 18/1114-1117, 18/2155A, 18/2155B I 31-Jan-03 18/2155B 20-Feb-03 121 months, 3 years SR 290 Johnson, John Earl NDNY 22-Jan-03 18/922(g)(1) II 31-Jan-03 18/922(g)(1) 01-Aug-03 46 months, 3 years SR 291 Galab, Faysal WDNY 21-Oct-02 2x 18/2339B, 50/1705 I 10-Jan-03 50/1705 16-Dec-03 84 months, 3years SR, $100SA 292 Issa, Mohamed Ahmed EDMI 04-Dec-02 18/1546; 18/1546(a); 18/1028(a)(4); 18/1001 II 09-Jan-03 18/1546(a), 18/1001, 18/1028 08-Apr-04 6 months.; 3 years SR 293 Khatib, Yaser DSC 03-Jan-03 18/1344 , 18/1028 II 03-Jan-03 18 /1344 and 1028 03-Jan-03 Time Served (14 months) 294 Jabar Mohamed NDIL 16-Oct-02 18/1546 II 24-Dec-02 18/1546 15-Jan-03 Time Served (15 Months) 3 years. SR 295 Ahmed, Rabi DNJ 25-Oct-01 18/371, 18/659 II 11-Dec-02 18/371 04-Dec-03 Time Served (4 months), 2 years. SR 296 Dweikat, Majeda SDCA 04-Sep-02 18/1546(a) I 21-Oct-02 18/1546 21-Oct-02 Time Served/Deported 297 Basnan, Osama Yousef SDCA 11-Sep-02 2x 18/1546(a), 18/2 II 21-Oct-02 18/1546 21-Oct-02 Time Served/Deported 298 Reid, Richard DMA 16-Jan-02 18/2332a(a)(1), 2332(b)(1), 924(c), 49/46505(b)(3) & (C), 49/46506(1), 49/46504 18/32(a)(1)&(7), 18/1993 I 04-Oct-02 18/2332a(a)(1), 2332(b)(1), 924(c), 49/46505(b)(3) & (C), 49/46506(1), 49/46504 18/32(a)(1)&(7), 30-Jan-03 299 Ahmad EDVA 30-Sep-02 18/1546 II 30-Sep-02 18 /1546 30-Sep-02 Time Served, 1 yr. SR 300 Sarama, Nabil NDCA 12-Dec-01 8/1325, 18/1546, 18/1001, 18/1028 II 25-Sep-02 8/1325 25-Sep-02 Time Served (10 Months), 1 yr SR Alvarez-Duenas, Jose Al-Nalfi, Mohamed Al-Hadi, Nageeb Abdul Life Ahmad, Ahmad Abeed Page 19 of 26

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date 301 Khahil WDPA 16-Sep-02 302 Tebbakh, Karim EDNY 303 Oulai, Jean Tony Charges Category Conv Date Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence 18/1462 II 16-Sep-02 18/1462 16-Sep-02 Time Served, 3 years.SR 27-Jun-02 18 / 2315 x2 and 3551 II 05-Sep-02 18 / 2315 x2 and 3551 10-Dec-02 Time Served 3 years SR MDFL 20-Feb-02 18/1001 II 15-Aug-02 18/1001 05-Sep-02 Time Served, 2 years SR 304 Mansour SDNY 30-Jul-02 18/2332(b); 18/1111, 1114, 1116, 1117; 18/ 2332a; 18/844; 18/1001 I 30-Jul-02 18/2332a; 18/2332(b); 18/1111, 1114, 1116, 1117; 18/844; 18/1001 04-Feb-08 Life 305 Almari, Saleh Ali EDVA 30-Jul-02 18/1341, 18/1343, 18/371 II 30-Jul-02 18/ 1341, 1343, 371 18-Oct-02 4 Months, 2 years SR 306 Al Attas, Hussein SDNY 25-Jul-02 18/1001 II 25-Jul-02 18/1001 22-Oct-02 Time Served; 2 years SR, $700 307 Cleveland, Derrick EDNY 22-May-02 18/1962; 18/371; 18/1951 II 17-Jul-02 18/1962 23-Oct-06 4 years probation; $5000 fine 308 Lindh, John Walker EDVA 05-Feb-02 4x 50/1705, 18/2332(b), 18/924, 3x 18/2339B, 18/844 I 15-Jul-02 50/1705; 18/844 04-Oct-02 20 Years EDNY 01-Nov-01 18/1343, 18/1001, 18/1029 II 09-Jul-02 18/1343, 18/1001, 18/1029 24-Jan-03 35 months., 3 years probation, restitution & $600 310 Mohamed SDCA 02-Nov-01 18/1001, 18/1546 II 02-Jul-02 18/1001 02-Oct-02 Time Served (335 days), 3years SR 311 Hammoud, Mohammed WDNC 28-Mar-01 9x18/1956; 6x18/2342; 6x18/1029; 3x18/1325; 3x18/1546; 2x18/1962; 2x18/1341, 2x2339B I 23-Jun-02 2x18/2339B, 18/1325, 18/1546, 3x18/2342, 3x18/1956, 3x18/1029, 18/1962 28-Feb-03 155 Years, 3 years SR, $1400SA 312 Hammoud, Chawki WDNC 28-Mar-01 4x18/2342; 7x18/1956; 4x18/371; 3x18/1029; 2x18/1962; 2x18/1341 II 21-Jun-02 18/371 (plea), 2x18/1029, 18/1956, 18/1962, 2x18/2342 28-Feb-03 51 Months, 3years SR, $700SA 313 Khan, Ayub Ali SDNY 14-Jan-02 18/1029 II 20-Jun-02 18 / 1029 314 Elashyi, Ihsan NDTX 07-Feb-02 13x 50/1702 and 1705(b); 10x 18/1029 (a)(2)(5), 12x 18/1956 (a)(1)(A)(i), 4x 18/1343 I 17-Jun-02 50/1702 & 1705, 18/1029, 18/1956, 18/1343 15-Aug-02 1 Year, 1 day, 3 years SR, $15,000 48 months (for each count to run concurrently); SR for 3 years (each count to run concurrently); Restitution $281,892.52; 23-Oct-02 SA $400.00 315 Mohammed CDCA 05-Jun-02 42/408(a)(7)(A); 18/1546(b)(1); 42/408(s)(7)(c) on 11/20/01 II 10-Jun-02 18/1546 24-Jun-02 316 Al-Marabh, Nabil WDNY 06-Dec-01 18/371, 18/1001, 18/1324 II 08-Jun-02 8 / 1324 03-Sep-02 8 months, 3 years. SR Koshak, Abdurahman Jabarah, Mohammed Elashmouny, Ahmed 309 Abdulla Abdoulah, Mohadar Trabelsi, Kamel Page 20 of 26 Time Served, 3years SR, comply w/ INS

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date 317 Butt, Ashar Iqbal EDPA 20-May-02 318 Azmath, Mohammed SDNY 319 Al-Saraf, Kumeit Charges Category Conv Date Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence 18/1543 II 06-Jun-02 18 /1543 12-Sep-02 6 Months 14-Jan-02 18/1029 II 06-Jun-02 18/ 1029 18-Sep-02 Time Served (9 Months), SR 36 months WDPA 04-Oct-01 18/1028 II 29-May-02 18/371 23-Aug-02 3 Years Probation, $250 320 Hussein, Mohamed DMA 14-Nov-01 2x 18/1960 II 30-Apr-02 18/1960 x2 22-Jul-02 321 Iqbal, Javaid EDNY 30-Nov-01 18/371 and 3551; 18/1028(a)(2), 18/1028(a)(6), 18/513 II 22-Apr-02 18/ 371 and 3551; 18/1028(a)(2) 17-Sep-02 16 Months, 3 years SR 322 Al Rababah, Eyad EDVA 06-Mar-02 18/1028 x2 II 17-Apr-02 18/ 1028x2 17-May-02 6 Months, 3 years. SR 323 Almutari, Mubarek NDIN 12-Oct-01 18/1344, 18/1014 II 17-Apr-02 18/1344 29-Jul-02 21 Months, 3 years SR 324 Albred, Kamel WDPA 04-Oct-01 18/1028 II 16-Apr-02 18/1028 29-Jul-02 3 Months Probation, $250 325 Alshomary, Haider WDPA 04-Oct-01 18/1028 II 15-Apr-02 18/1028 15-Aug-02 1 Year Probation, $250 326 Butt, Moeen Islam EDPA 06-Mar-02 8 /1325 II 10-Apr-02 8/1325 13-Jun-02 Time Served, 3 years SR 327 Refai, Mohammed Ibrahim NDOH 20-Feb-02 18/1001, 18/1546 II 10-Apr-02 18 / 1546 and 8 / 1325 10-Apr-02 Time Served, 3 years. SR 328 Al-Atabi, Wathek WDPA 04-Oct-01 18/1028 II 10-Apr-02 18/1028 15-Aug-02 3 Months Probation, $350 329 Salmain Saleh SDCA 04-Jan-02 18/1546, 42/408 II 29-Mar-02 18/1546, 42/408 29-Mar-02 Time Served, 3 years SR 330 Al-Maleky, Raad WDPA 04-Oct-01 18/1028 II 28-Mar-02 18/1028 16-Aug-02 3 Years Probation 331 Almazaal, Samir WDPA 04-Oct-01 18/1028 II 28-Mar-02 18 /1028 02-Aug-02 3 Years Probation DNJ 25-Oct-01 18/371, 18/659 II 27-Mar-02 18/371 04-Dec-03 Time Served (5 months), 3 years. SR 18 Months, 2 years. SR Bakarbashat, Omer 332 Abuali, Nasser Page 21 of 26

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date Category Conv Date DNJ 11-Dec-01 18/1343 II 26-Mar-02 18/1343 24-May-02 3 years. SR, restitution 334 Al Aboudy, Akeel WDPA 04-Oct-01 18/1028 II 26-Mar-02 18 /1028 02-Aug-02 36 Months Probation, $250 335 Alazawi, Ali F. WDPA 03-Oct-01 18/1028 II 26-Mar-02 18/1028 12-Jul-02 3 Years Probation 336 Maddy, Mohammed EDNY 16-Nov-01 8 / 1324 x2, 18/3551 II 25-Mar-02 8/1324 x2, 18/3551 04-Apr-02 Time Served, 5 years SR 337 Al-Atabi, Hatef WDPA 04-Oct-01 18/1028 II 25-Mar-02 18/1028 12-Jun-02 3 Years Probation, $250 338 Al-Aboody, Mustafa WDPA 03-Oct-01 18/1028 II 20-Mar-02 18 /1028 12-Jul-02 3 Years Probation 339 Al-Shiblawy, Hisham WDPA 04-Oct-01 18/1028 II 19-Mar-02 18/1028 08-Jul-02 3 Years Probation, 100 hrs. comm. service 340 Ahmed, Ifikhar EDNC 16-Jan-02 18/1546, 18/1028 II 18-Mar-02 18/1546 19-Jun-02 Time Served 341 Al-Hachami, Sabah WDPA 04-Oct-01 18/1028 II 18-Mar-02 18/1028 03-Jul-02 1 Year Probation, $250 342 Al-Khaledy, Fadhil WDPA 04-Oct-01 18/1028 II 15-Mar-02 18/1028 18-Jun-02 3 Years Probation 343 Al-Obaidi, Hussain WDPA 04-Oct-01 18/1028 II 13-Mar-02 18/1028 01-Jul-02 3 Years Probation $250 344 Sudani, Hussain WDPA 03-Oct-01 18/1028 II 11-Mar-02 18/1028 07-Jun-02 3 Years Probation 345 Budiman, Agus EDVA 21-Feb-02 18/1028 II 04-Mar-02 18 /1028 10-May-02 7 Months, 1 yr. SR NDOH 23-Oct-01 18/1325 II 28-Feb-02 18/ 1325 15-Apr-02 WDNC 28-Mar-01 18/2339B, 18/2339A, 18/201A, 18/1956, 18/2342, 18/371, 1344A, 18/1029, 18/215, 18/1324, 18/2314, 18/1962 I 25-Feb-02 18/2339A, 18/371, 18/1956, 18/1962 41 Months; 3 years SR, $500 Special 19-Mar-03 Assessment (SA) DAZ 25-Oct-01 18/1001, 42/408(a)(7)(A) II 25-Feb-02 18/1001, 42/408 15-Apr-02 333 Kilfat, Ahmad Charges Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence Rouissi, Zuhaier Ben 346 Mohammed 347 Harb, Said 6 Months Seif, Malek Mohamad 348 (Malek mohamed Abdulah) Page 22 of 26 Time Served, 3 years SR

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date Category Conv Date SDNY 04-Feb-02 18/1029 II 22-Feb-02 18 / 1001 13-Mar-02 Time Served DAZ 06-Nov-01 2x 18/1001, 3x 42/408(a)(7)(B) II 22-Feb-02 2x18/1001, 42/408 06-May-02 3 Years probation 351 Hamdan MDFL 31-Oct-01 18/1325 II 21-Feb-02 18/1325 04-Mar-02 Time Served 352 Khan, Raza Nasir DDE 09-Oct-01 18/922(g)(5) & 924(a)(2) II 20-Feb-02 18/922 & 924 20-Mar-02 177 days, 2 years SR 353 Alibrahimi, Mohammed WDPA 04-Oct-01 18/1028 II 15-Feb-02 18/1028 17-May-02 5 Years Probation, 100 hrs. comm. service 354 Abdall, Assam EDNY 11-Jan-02 18/1001(a)(2) and 3551 II 14-Feb-02 18/1001(a)(2) and 3551 22-Apr-02 DAZ 09-Oct-01 2x 18/1001 II 14-Feb-02 18/1001 14-Mar-02 6 Months, 3 years SR SDNY 13-Feb-02 18/1001 II 13-Feb-02 18 / 1001 07-Oct-02 DNJ 11-Dec-01 18/1543 II 13-Feb-02 18/1543 21-Mar-02 Time Served (6 Months) 2 years. SR 358 Elmaghraby, Ehab EDNY 26-Oct-01 18/1029 II 13-Feb-02 18/1029(a)(2) 29-Jul-02 359 Rizvi, Armoghan DCO 19-Dec-01 18/ 911 II 11-Feb-02 18/911 22-Feb-02 Time Served, 1yr SR 360 Alandon, Arkan WDPA 04-Oct-01 18/1028 II 11-Feb-02 18/1028 24-May-02 3 Years Probation, 100 hrs. comm. service 361 Ferrari, Robert WDPA 04-Oct-01 18/1028 x5 II 08-Feb-02 18 /1028x5 26-Sep-03 18 months, 3 years. SR 362 Al Tamimi, Haider WDPA 04-Oct-01 18/1028 II 01-Feb-02 18/1028 10-May-02 3 Years Probation 363 Rizvi, Arsalan Absar DCO 28-Nov-01 18/922(g)(5), 18/911 II 29-Jan-02 18/922 06-Feb-02 Time Served, 3years SR 364 Al Hamdan, Nasri MDFL 31-Oct-01 18/1325 II 24-Jan-02 18/1325 01-Mar-02 Time Served (5 months); 3 years SR 349 Dawe, Nadim 350 Laimeche, Sofiane Charges Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence Al Hamdan, Montaser 355 Al Salmi, Faisal M. 356 Pervez, Mohammed 357 Kilfat, Mustafa Page 23 of 26 6 Months 3 years SR Probation 1 year 24 Months, 3 years SR

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date 365 Bin Hasher SDFL 25-Oct-01 366 Kishk, Wael EDNY 367 Alubeidy, Ali 368 Hyder, Salman Charges Category Conv Date Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence 18/1546, 21/841, 18/1028A II 18-Jan-02 21/841, 18/1546 25-Apr-02 04-Oct-01 18/1001, 18/1028, 18/1543 and 3551, 49/46306(b)(2) II 17-Jan-02 18/1001 27-Feb-02 Time Served (6 Months), 3 years. SR WDPA 04-Oct-01 18/1028 II 14-Jan-02 18/1028 11-Apr-02 CDCA 21-Dec-01 18/1028, 18/1546 II 10-Jan-02 18/1546 25-Mar-02 4 months., 3years SR MDFL 31-Oct-01 18/1546, 8/1325 II 10-Jan-02 18/1546, 8/1325 08-Mar-02 Time Served, 3years SR 370 Badri, Adel WDMO 14-Nov-01 4x 18/1344, 18/1956, 18/2314 II 08-Jan-02 18/1344 06-Mar-02 Time Served, 3 years SR, $1,000 371 Atta, Ahmed Nawaz CDCA 21-Dec-01 18/1028, 18/1546 II 03-Jan-02 18/1028, 18/1546 11-Feb-02 Time Served, 3years SR 372 Abassi, Sabre EDVA 15-Nov-01 18/1001x2 II 03-Jan-02 18/1001 x2 03-Jan-03 373 Abu-Zbaida, Maher Yousef DMT 22-Oct-01 18/922(g) II 02-Jan-02 18/922(g) 28-Mar-02 10 Months, 10 months SR 374 Kopke, Roxanne EDVA 15-Nov-01 8/1306c.p II 20-Dec-01 8/1306c.p 20-Dec-01 50 Days 375 Menepta, Mujahid Abdul WDOK 29-Nov-01 18/ 922(g)(1) II 19-Dec-01 18/922(g)(1) 03-Apr-02 376 Awad, Hadir EDVA 17-Dec-01 18/1546 II 17-Dec-01 18 /1546 01-Mar-02 2 Years SR 377 Abdi, Mohamed EDVA 23-Oct-01 18/513 II 13-Dec-01 18/513 11-Jan-02 378 Al-Baraa, Alawi Hussain WDPA 04-Oct-01 18/1028 II 13-Dec-01 18/1028 13-Mar-02 6 months SR 379 El Zaatari, Salam Ibrahim WDPA 01-Nov-01 49 /46505(b)(1) I 12-Dec-01 49 / 46505(b)(1) 12-Dec-01 Time Served 380 Ahmad, Hafiz Khalil MDFL 13-Nov-01 18/1546, 18/1001, 18/1621 II 12-Dec-01 18/1546 19-Dec-01 Time Served, 2 years SR Alghamdi, Muhamed Nasir 6 months; 3 years SR; $10,000 3 Years Probation, $250 Al Qaryuti, Mohammed 369 Basheer Page 24 of 26 63 Days, 2 years probation, $500 15 Months, 3 years SR 4 Months, 3 years SR

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date 381 Hani Ayoub MDFL 31-Oct-01 382 Farid, Abdul MDNC 383 Khamis, Sherif Charges Category Conv Date Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence 18/1325 II 12-Dec-01 18/1325 10-Jan-02 29-Oct-01 18/1014 II 11-Dec-01 18/1014 26-Mar-02 Time Served (6 months) 3 years. SR MDFL 03-Oct-01 18/1001 II 07-Dec-01 18/1001 19-Dec-01 Time Served + 7 days, 3years SR 384 Siddiqui, Imitiaz MDNC 30-Oct-01 18/911 II 06-Dec-01 18/911 26-Feb-02 Time Served (5 months), 1 yr. SR 385 Martinez-Flores, Luis EDVA 25-Oct-01 18/1028 x4 II 06-Dec-01 18/1028 x4 15-Feb-02 21 Months, 2 years SR 386 Hafaiedh, Ben Sami Fathi CDCA 13-Nov-01 18/1546, 42/ 408, 18/1001 II 30-Nov-01 18/1546 11-Feb-02 6 Months 387 Pierre, Vincente Rafael WDVA 18-Sep-01 18/922, 18/924 and 18/371 II 30-Nov-01 18/922, 924 and 371 05-Apr-02 24 Months, 3 years SR 388 Upshur, Traci WDVA 18-Sep-01 18/922, 18/924 and 18/371 II 30-Nov-01 18/922, 924 and 371 05-Apr-02 15 Months, 2 years SR 389 Jimmy) NDNY 19-Sep-01 8 / 1325 II 20-Nov-01 8/ 1325 08-Jan-02 5 Years Probation 390 Iqbal, Jawaid NDNY 19-Sep-01 8 / 1325 II 20-Nov-01 8 / 1325 1. 5 Years Probation, $100 SA & $3000 15-Mar-02 Fine 391 Lopez-Flores, Victor EDVA 19-Nov-01 18/1028 and 8 usc 1326 II 19-Nov-01 18/1028 and 8/1326 01-Feb-01 27 Months, 3 years SR 392 Al Draibi, Khalid EDVA 10-Oct-01 18/1546 II 19-Nov-01 18/1546 04-Jan-02 393 Raza, Atif SDAL 27-Sep-01 18/1029(a)(2) II 19-Nov-01 18/1029 07-Feb-02 Time Served (140 days), restitution 394 El Ouariachi, Hossain WDPA 19-Nov-01 18/ 1001 II 15-Nov-01 18/1001 15-Nov-01 Time Served 395 Galicia, Kenys EDVA 25-Oct-01 18/1028 II 09-Nov-01 18 /1028 25-Jan-02 396 Fall, Manel WDPA 30-Oct-01 18/1544 II 02-Nov-01 18 /1544 27-Dec-01 3 Months, $100 Al Khammash, Nermine Time Served (3 Months); 3 years SR Iqbal, Jamshed (aka Page 25 of 26 4 Months, 3 years SR 1 Year, 3 years SR

National Security Division Statistics on Unsealed International Terrorism and Terrorism-Related Convictions 9/11/01 - 3/18/10 Defendant District Charge Date 397 Tauseef, Hafiz NDNY 17-Oct-01 398 Younes, Aisha NDNY 399 Hussain, Arshad Charges Category Conv Date 18 /1546 II 01-Nov-01 18 / 1546 05-Dec-01 5 Years Probation 17-Oct-01 18/ 1546 II 01-Nov-01 18 / 1546 05-Dec-01 5 Years Probation WDNY 31-Oct-01 18/1544 II 31-Oct-01 18/ 1544 04-Jan-02 400 Haddoumi, Faycal NDIN 18-Oct-01 8/1305 II 22-Oct-01 8/1305 09-Nov-01 30 Days 401 Rahmani, Kamal NDIN 18-Oct-01 8/1305 II 22-Oct-01 8/1305 09-Nov-01 30 Days 402 Mahmood, Ansar NDNY 16-Oct-01 8 /1324 II 16-Oct-01 8 / 1324 25-Jan-02 5 Years Probation, $3000 403 Guagni, Francois DME 25-Sep-01 8/1326 II 28-Sep-01 8/1326 23-Jan-02 20 Months, 3 years Supervised Release (SR) Page 26 of 26 Conviction Charges Sent Date Sentence Time Served, 2 years SR