Norfolk Southern Argued Against “Emotional Evocations of ‘Deadly Chemicals’” After 2005 Derailment

After East Palestine, as in 2005, harmful chemical releases are unlikely to affect the rail company’s stock price or bottom line.

MICHIGAN, UNITED STATES - FEBRUARY 18: A train derails in Michigan with several cars veering off track in Van Buren Township, in Michigan, United States on February 18, 2023. There are no reported injuries or release of hazardous materials at this time. Congresswoman Debbie Dingell, Representative of the district that includes the site of the derailment, stated âThe car carrying hazardous material has been put upright and is being removed from the area of the other derailed cars, and EPA is dispatching a team to ensure public safety.❠The train was operated by Norfolk Southern, the same company operating the train that derailed in East Palestine, Ohio less than two weeks ago. The company has faced scrutiny for the ongoing situation in East Palestine after the release of hazardous chemicals. It is unclear what caused Thursdayâs derailment in Michigan, first reported before 9 in the morning. An investigation is ongoing. (Photo by Nick Hagen/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)
Derailed Norfolk Southern cars showing the company logo in Van Buren Township, Mich., on Feb. 18, 2023. Photo: Nick Hagen/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images

More than a decade before the train derailment that triggered a series of events sending a mushroom cloud of carcinogenic vinyl chloride burnoff over East Palestine, Ohio, the same rail company, Norfolk Southern, fought responsibility for another large-scale accident in Graniteville, South Carolina.

The Graniteville crash released chlorine gas stored in derailed train cars, resulting in the deaths of nine people and hospital admissions for over 500. The crash, caused by two trains colliding from an improperly aligned railroad switch, released 90 tons of chlorine gas. The accident, the largest rail disaster of its type since 1978, resembled a chemical weapons attack. Many of the casualties were local textile workers who were killed by asphyxia from inhaling the gas, which hovered over a nearby plant owned by Avondale Mills.

In a court filing attached to a class-action lawsuit brought against Norfolk Southern in the wake of the 2005 crash, attorneys for the defense wrote “Plaintiffs emotional evocations of ‘deadly chemicals,’ ‘mangled metal,’ or ‘deadly liquid chlorine’ forming a gas that ‘crept through Graniteville’ and ‘killed those who could not outrun it’ can have no use other than to divert this court from the issue at hand – whether certain of plaintiffs claims are preempted by federal law.”

Norfolk Southern estimated the cost of the 2005 derailment at $41 million, noting the marginal stock impact of the crash was just 5 cents a share. Ultimately, it paid out $4 million in fines to the federal government and more than $10 million in settlements.

After the case, a law firm representing Norfolk Southern in the litigation issued a press release touting its role in diminishing the settlement paid to the railroad’s victims. Avondale Mills, shortly after the disaster, closed all of its plants, getting rid of approximately 4,000 jobs and citing the spill as one of the primary reasons for the company’s demise.

Wall Street is now pointing to the relatively small financial cost of that incident to suggest that Norfolk Southern stocks won’t be severely impacted following the East Palestine derailment. Financial forecasting suggests that the rail giant could emerge from the East Palestine disaster with a repeat performance: paying out fines, compensation claims, and construction costs that fail to seriously impact its bottom line.

Nine lawsuits have so far been filed against the company. In its first round of financial outreach, Norfolk Southern offered residents with an East Palestine ZIP code $1,000 “inconvenience fees” and a $25,000 donation to the Red Cross. Norfolk Southern, which recorded $4.8 billion in income revenue in 2022, has since said that the company has committed $6.5 million in remuneration to the town. But as local and statewide officials race to East Palestine to drink local tap water and calm residents beset by mass animal die-offs and widespread respiratory and skin ailments, the extent of the impact is yet to be seen.

Ralph Nader, former presidential candidate and a long-standing champion of consumer rights, said federal regulators captured by the rail industry are largely to blame, and that it is unlikely those impacted will receive the remuneration they deserved.

“They are afraid of the railroad lobby and that means working-class people are never going to be actually protected.”

“There has to be a completely new legal structure going through Congress. You see the members don’t ride trains, especially not freight trains,” Nader told The Intercept. “So you have to find out who the champions are. Usually something like this happens and a couple of senators jump up and get press and credit. On the other hand, they are afraid of the railroad lobby and that means working-class people are never going to be actually protected or remunerated at all when something like this happens.”

In its annual 10-K report, filed the same day as the East Palestine crash, Norfolk Southern acknowledged the potential for “catastrophic losses” resulting from a rail accident involving hazardous materials. “A common carrier by rail, we must offer to transport hazardous materials, regardless of risk,” the filing warns investors. “Transportation of certain hazardous materials could create catastrophic losses in terms of personal injury and property (including environmental) damage and compromise critical parts of our rail network. The costs of a catastrophic rail accident involving hazardous materials could exceed our insurance coverage.”

The filing also states that “insurance is available from a limited number of insurers and may not continue to be available or, if available, may not be obtainable on terms acceptable to us.” Norfolk Southern noted that it had liability insurance for certain situations that would cover up to $800 million (or $1.1 billion for “specific perils”).

Despite the risks disclosed in its 10-K, Norfolk Southern did not believe there was an immediate likelihood of a catastrophic incident impacting its finances. “Based on our assessment of the facts and circumstances now known, we believe we have recorded the probable and reasonably estimable costs for dealing with those environmental matters of which we are aware. Further, we believe that it is unlikely that any known matters, either individually or in the aggregate, will have a material adverse effect on our financial position, results of operations, or liquidity.”

Smoke rises from a derailed cargo train in East Palestine, Ohio, on February 4, 2023. - The train accident sparked a massive fire and evacuation orders, officials and reports said Saturday. No injuries or fatalities were reported after the 50-car train came off the tracks late February 3 near the Ohio-Pennsylvania state border. The train was shipping cargo from Madison, Illinois, to Conway, Pennsylvania, when it derailed in East Palestine, Ohio. (Photo by DUSTIN FRANZ / AFP) (Photo by DUSTIN FRANZ/AFP via Getty Images)

Smoke rises from a derailed cargo train in East Palestine, Ohio, on Feb. 4, 2023.

Photo: Dustin Franz/AFP via Getty Images

Rail companies and Norfolk Southern in particular have never paid out sums approaching their insurance limits. In 2022, the combined cost of 18 train derailments involving hazardous materials was a mere $41.6 million.

“They are so weak, if they were any weaker the insurance industry wouldn’t cover railroads.”

“The federal railroad administration is the most captured regulatory agency in the U.S. government,” Nader said. “It is owned and staffed by the railroad industry. They have anesthetized it, and created the weakest regulations and standards imaginable. They are so weak, if they were any weaker the insurance industry wouldn’t cover railroads.”

Nader also laid blame for the crash and what he described as an inadequate response at the feet of Secretary of Transportation Pete Buttigieg, who he says failed to respond promptly, calling him a “ribbon-cutting coward.” “He should have been there immediately,” said Nader. “Usually regulators love to go because they get all kinds of national publicity. Well, how long did it take them? They waited for the smoke to clear.”

On Tuesday, Norfolk Southern CEO Alan Shaw told CNBC, “This isn’t the time nor is it the place to talk about the financial impact. My focus on this community is helping with environmental remediation, reimbursing the citizens of this community.” The EPA has already demanded Norfolk Southern pay the full costs of any public health and environmental fallout from the disaster.

“I would be skeptical that they will make these people who have suffered from this disaster whole again because so many of the harms won’t be apparent the right way and will most likely lead to serious health impacts like cancers down the road,” Emily Jeffers, a senior attorney at the Center for Biological Diversity told The Intercept.

“Soil, groundwater, and air are all going to be affected. I don’t think it’s any surprise that there will be cancers as a result of this. When you burn vinyl chloride, it transforms into a dioxin, which is a persistent organic pollutant and enters the food chain and environment and is likely to be present for decades to come. So while we’ve already seen fish die-offs, which have been analogized to a canary in the coal mine, I think the true impact and cost is years away from our understanding.”

A report published by HuffPost this week describes how the initial testing used to justify the claim that East Palestine water supply was secure was conducted by a third-party contractor hired by Norfolk Southern, in a way that did not comport with the EPA’s own testing standards.

“Their results that claim there were no contaminants is not a reliable finding,” Sam Bickley, an aquatic ecologist told HuffPost. “I find this extremely concerning because these results would NOT be used in most scientific applications because the samples were not preserved properly, and this is the same data they are now relying on to say that the drinking water is not contaminated.” Another expert described the testing as “sloppy” and “amateur.”

Other impacted municipalities say they have failed to receive any remuneration at all and have struggled to contact representatives from Norfolk Southern to get answers.

Kayla Miller, who lives in the town of Negley three miles south of East Palestine, told The Intercept she hasn’t heard anything about testing, financial compensation, or air safety from the rail company. Dead aquatic life in the creek behind her house and on her farm has also stoked her fears that the full extent of damage to surrounding towns is yet unaccounted for.

“They keep saying the air is fine and everything, but I’ve had animals die, and it was all within 24 hours,” Miller said. “They were all healthy before. My stepdaughter has these reactions every time she goes outside. I have a farm. So, you know, seeing dying animals is not good for us.”

Miller also was concerned that while the train derailment has gripped national news media, in the coming months and years that attention may fade, making it all the more important that as much aid is pushed into towns surrounding East Palestine as soon as possible. “Maybe if they were to spend the money now and do it the right way, then, you know, in five or 10 years, we’re not as worried about our towns going bankrupt and our homes becoming ghost towns. If they do as much as they can right now, there’s not going to be as many repercussions down the road.”

Norfolk Southern did not respond to The Intercept’s request for comment.

Join The Conversation